In the aisles of Wal-Mart, Bain is a four-letter word

Fri Jun 8, 2012 3:27pm EDT

* Ads attacking Romney record making mark with key swing voters

* Romney must tell own story to "Wal-Mart Moms," establish credentials

* "Moms" want specifics on how Obama, Romney will lift economy

By Alister Bull

WASHINGTON, June 8 (Reuters) - President Barack Obama has been battered by bad news dimming the outlook for his re-election, but he might find hope in an unlikely place: the aisles of Wal-Mart.

Female shoppers at the big-box superstore are viewed as crucial swing voters in the closely fought 2012 election, and a pair of recent focus groups suggest that Obama's attempts to portray Republican rival Mitt Romney as a ruthless corporate raider might bear fruit.

Obama's attacks on Romney's private equity career at Bain Capital have been widely panned by pundits and even some prominent Democratic allies, like President Bill Clinton. But the blame-it-on-Bain approach might be hitting its mark with Americans outside Washington.

"The main thing I've heard that kind of scares me is ... the whole Romney thing, where all these people, the factories that have been shut down where they've worked over 30 years and then they are left with nothing," said Rebecca W., a participant in the Virginia focus group whose last name was not given. "That concerns me."

In 1996, political strategists deemed suburban "soccer moms" - middle-class suburban women - as that year's crucial voting bloc. Eight years later, "NASCAR dads" - blue-collar, usually white men - were seen as a key demographic to win over. In recent years it's been "Wal-Mart moms," who are similar to soccer moms but less affluent. Obama carried this group in 2008, but they voted Republican in the 2010 congressional elections.

Perhaps sensing a branding opportunity, Wal-Mart Stores Inc has financed the political study of its shoppers, although the retail chain had no part in the selection of participants. The moms all shop at least monthly at the retail giant and were screened to exclude strong partisans of either party.

Rebecca, who voted for Republican John McCain in 2008 but is undecided now, was among 10 women taking part in a focus group in Richmond, Virginia, on a recent night. She heard the claim about Romney and jobs in a television ad.

Focus groups are a vital tool for election campaigns looking to find messages that resonate with voters. They are usually staged privately, but a small group of Washington reporters was invited to remotely observe sessions in Richmond and another in Las Vegas, which was centered on Hispanic mothers.

Virginia and Nevada are vital 2012 battlegrounds that will help sway the outcome of what is expected to be a very tight election.


While some participants admired Romney's business success, there was a general sense that they did not know enough about the specific policies of either man vying for the White House on Nov. 6, particularly on how they would boost U.S. jobs.

"There is still a lot of opportunities for both candidates here. There is good news and also some lessons," said Margie Omero, president of Momentum Analysis, a Democratic pollster who helped run the bipartisan study.

"I would advise Democrats to continue talking to these women because they are hearing some of the beginnings of the general election campaign but still want to hear some more specifics."

The women in both the Virginia and Nevada groups sensed they had little in common with Romney, one of the richest men to ever seek the White House, as the race hits full stride.

"He seems stand-offish. He really needs to be more connected to the people," said Karla A. in Las Vegas, who described herself as a Republican who had voted for McCain in 2008 and was currently leaning Romney's way for November.

Republican pollster Alex Bratty of Public Opinion Strategies, who helped run the study, said Romney had an opportunity to fill in voters on his personal life story and fight back against the negative ads.

"Mitt Romney is not well defined with these moms," she said. "There is clearly room for him to develop his credentials, his reputation, who he is as a person with these moms, because they really don't know much more beyond the fact that he is a business man."

The examination was part of a bipartisan study of Wal-Mart moms that began in 2010. The pollsters estimate the group makes up 14 percent to 17 percent of the U.S. electorate.

Members of the Wal-Mart's founding family, the Waltons, have so far given $813,000 to Republicans in this election cycle, according to the Center for Responsive Politics in Washington.

Wal-Mart employees and political action committees affiliated with the company have so far given $811,000, in roughly equal amounts to both parties, according to the nonpartisan research group.

Women and Hispanics favored Obama in 2008 and continue to do so after the Republican primary contests that gave Romney enough delegates to claim the party's presidential nomination was marked by a series of attacks on immigration and women's reproductive health.

Obama needs to maintain his standing with both groups of voters to succeed in November but he has been chided by Latino leaders for failing to live up to 2008 promises on immigration reform and for conducting aggressive deportations since taking power.

The Hispanic moms in Las Vegas did not echo that disappointment. They said they felt a strong affinity with Obama, America's first black president, as a fellow member of a minority.

"I feel more connected to Obama than the white man," said Leanne B., who said she was undecided about November but voted for Obama in 2008.

"He (Romney) had it easier than the black man, or a Hispanic."

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
madmilker wrote:
Romney must tell own story to “Wal-Mart Moms,” ….duh!

Why don’t the 5 and Dime from the Ozarks tell the American Mom’s that they put less than 5% foreign in all their stores in China.

Cause they do.

Why don’t they tell the American Mom’s that they moved their Global Procurement Office to Hong Kong and than to China years ago.

Why don’t they tell them about the port deal in Mexico.

Why don’t they tell them about those fifteen supper cargo ships that pollute as much as 760 million automobiles.

Why don’t they tell them that the Walton family, which owns Walmart, has already donated $624,100 to Republican candidates and Super PACs.

If you think for a minute all 5 and Dime shoppers are jack@’s you are one sandwich short of a picnic and three sheets in the wind.

They may not all have gone to Harvard but look at America today and you will see just what an Harvard Education has done for We the People.

The first Federal Reserve chairman came from Harvard and when he set down in that chair in 1914 the American Government was $2.9 billion in debt.

2006 another chairman set in that chair and he was looking at $8.6 trillion of debt….he gradated Harvard too.

And today that same chairman is still sitting in that chair and the US Government debt has mushroomed to all most $16 trillion.

Oh! look at the one serving We the People while living in the People’s house and the one you are writing about….

oh! and lets not forget Jill Stein from the Green Party.

There be more ignorance taught at that school than Carter has little liver pills.

Good day!

Jun 08, 2012 3:56pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.