U.S. Presbyterian Church at crossroads over gay marriage

NEW YORK Sat Jul 14, 2012 4:18pm EDT

Related Topics

NEW YORK (Reuters) - Midwestern minister Greg Smith is considering an act of ecclesiastical disobedience.

Deeply sympathetic to gay rights since his son, Matty, came out as gay a decade ago, the lifelong Presbyterian told his son he will officiate at his wedding, defying church policy.

"I believe that we're doing more harm than good prolonging the inevitable," said Smith, who at 64 is retired but still ministers in Des Moines, Iowa.

"On this issue, there is no mechanism for pastors to express conscientious objection without either defying church authority or demitting from one's pastoral call. And that's extremely stressful and distressing."

Like many other denominations, the Presbyterian Church(U.S.A.), the 10th largest U.S. religion according to the National Council of Churches, is in the grips of a crisis over gay marriage.

The 2.7-million-strong church has lost about 500,000 members over the last decade, and church leaders fear that an endorsement of same-sex marriage could spur an exodus of Christians who view it as incompatible with biblical teachings.

But failing to act could mean the church is viewed as irrelevant and homophobic by young and progressive members.

Earlier this month at its General Assembly, a gathering held every two years, church leaders rejected a constitutional change, by a vote of 338-308, that would have defined marriage as between two people, rather than a man and a woman.

Some have said the church was moving too fast. Just two years ago, the church agreed to open the ranks of its clergy to homosexuals, prompting dozens of congregations to split off to join more conservative denominations or to form their own.

"The Assembly was trying to hold together a broken church with both hands, trying to honor people on both ends of the spectrum who feel pain around the issues of marriage," said Reverend Aimee Moiso, who led the assembly's committee on marriage.

"But we did manage something miraculous: In a polarized church and nation, we spent several days trying to figure out a way to stay together across our divisions," she said.

The Presbyterian Church allows ministers to bless same-sex unions but prohibits them from solemnizing legal homosexual marriages. In February, the church's highest ecclesiastical court upheld the censure of Reverend Jane Spahr for performing 16 same-sex marriages in California.

"Shall we follow the culture, or shall we follow the Bible? That is the dividing line," Carmen Fowler LaBerge, president of the conservative Presbyterian Lay Committee, said this month.


The legalization of marriage in six states and the District of Columbia, along with the growing visibility of gay parishioners, has put pressure on U.S. churches to reconsider their strict definition of marriage.

Just days after the Presbyterian assembly, the Episcopal Church held its own convention, where the church approved a liturgy for blessing same-sex unions.

"I think it's the same conversation that's going on in society, as people have more relationships with people who are LGBT and they have to wrestle with all these issues," said Reverend Gradye Parsons, a Presbyterian leader, using the acronym for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender.

When gay parishioners request a wedding, ministers find themselves in a "pastoral quandary," he said.

There is no official count of same-sex Presbyterian weddings, but anecdotal evidence suggests they are on the rise.

During several hours of assembly debate, two ministers publicly declared they would perform gay weddings.

But the consequence of such defiance was also on view: Reverend Tara Spuhler McCabe resigned shortly after being elected vice moderator, a leadership post, amid an outcry that she had signed a marriage license for a same-sex couple in Washington, D.C.

"The church as a whole is divided over what to do," said Reverend Neal Presa, who was elected moderator this year. "The questions is, the division that's already there, would it become more visible, as manifested by actual churches leaving?"


Still, defiance can come at a heavy price.

Jean Southard, a Presbyterian minister in the Boston area, says she has performed four same-sex wedding ceremonies since 2004, when Massachusetts legalized gay marriage.

In one case, she wed a lesbian couple, including a woman who taught adult Bible study and her partner who taught Sunday school. A group of pastors filed a complaint and Southard was charged with violating her ordination vows.

The cost of the initial church trial, $25,744, plus $25,000 for two appeals, was paid by a wealthy parishioner who has remained anonymous, she said. In the end, the church's high court found her not guilty.

"It's an alienating experience to have your colleagues accuse you of breaking your ordination vows by violating the Constitution when you believe you have done what Jesus would have you do," Southard said.

(Editing by Mohammad Zargham)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (5)
frapper wrote:
This is not all Presbyterians or their denominations, only the mainline PC(USA). Unfortunately the media just uses the term “Presbyterians.” The PC(USA) is virtually apostate and has brought shame on the entire reformation. There are several biblically-faithful Presbyterian bodies in the US and Canada.

This is a symptom and not at the heart of the problem. Once biblical authority has been rejected by a denomination, things like this just follow (although it may take a while). The PC(USA) is nothing but a man-made pagan religion.

Jul 14, 2012 7:46pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Domjohn wrote:
ALL religions are man made.

Jul 14, 2012 9:27pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
SteveMD2 wrote:
teh PCUSA is going to have a liturgy for same sex couples marrying, just give them time.

Its about time we stopped honoring a book written in an age of ignorance by men, who thought they knew what God wants.

Which reminds me of Islam in Saudi land. Where if a woman is raped, she is usually whipped. The judge decides her punishment based on what god wants.

The Jews btw no longer murder people for not being virgins aon their wedding day, working on the sabbath etc. Sure they have some extremist elements, eg a couple of the Shas said gays were like bird flu about Jan 2990.

Imagine that – people calling for the murder of gays. These shas orthodox conveneintly forgetting how the gays shared hitler’s ovesn with their own close relatives.

Its time to go modern. Find some one country where the extremists can all live. I predict they wont last very long as they, xtians, jews, Islamics etc do the old thing religion is so much about – dividing them and then playing jeckel and hyde for more centuries

Jul 14, 2012 11:30pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.