San Bernardino, California, sets course for bankruptcy

SAN BERNARDINO, California Thu Jul 19, 2012 1:06am EDT

A concrete sign marking the city limits for San Bernardino, California is seen July 11, 2012. REUTERS/Alex Gallardo

A concrete sign marking the city limits for San Bernardino, California is seen July 11, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Alex Gallardo

Related Topics

SAN BERNARDINO, California (Reuters) - San Bernardino's city council on Wednesday declared a fiscal emergency, allowing the California community to file for bankruptcy protection without having to first hold talks with its creditors.

The city will take about 30 days to make its filing for Chapter 9 protection, most likely in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Riverside, California, said City Attorney James Penman.

The city of about 210,000 people located 65 miles east of Los Angeles could become the third city in California to seek protection from its creditors since late June. Stockton and the ski resort city of Mammoth Lakes have already filed in bankruptcy court.

A fourth city, Compton on the outskirts of Los Angeles, could be the next city to turn to bankruptcy protection.

Compton will run out of cash to make its payroll on September 1, a city official said.

San Bernardino has burned through its reserves and is out of other ways to pay for its longstanding deficit spending. It faces a deficit of nearly $46 million.

"This problem has been coming for a long, long time," said Council Member Fred Shorett. "It's here, now."

The extent of San Bernardino's financial problems became public suddenly last week, prompting its city council to vote on July 10 to begin the process of moving toward Chapter 9 bankruptcy protection as part of a plan to overhaul the city's finances.

That move caught San Bernardino's residents by surprise and many have spoken out against a bankruptcy filing, fearing its stigma for the city.

San Bernardino's employees are particularly concerned about what bankruptcy means for their pay and benefits.

"This sets a bad example for the people of San Bernardino," said Steve Tracy, the representative for San Bernardino's firefighters union. "It shows the city can make contracts, agreements, and can renege on them by filing for bankruptcy."

San Bernardino's financial staff expects to present a short-term budget to the council on July 24 and city administrators have been authorized to begin negotiations with the city's employee unions.


The municipal debt market, which has been keeping a close eye on California, also was caught off guard by the July 10 vote and its analysts are still trying to piece together how San Bernardino's finances fell apart without city leaders stepping in to prevent it.

"They either didn't know, which is shameful, or they did know, which is worse," said Dick Larkin, director of credit analysis at municipal bond broker-dealer HJ Sims.

Penman said last week that financial documents had been falsified in 13 of the past 16 years but has not made evidence of the claim public.

A former city manager who warned the city council in mid-2010 that San Bernardino faced financial ruin, the city's mayor and its auditing firm say they are unaware of any wrongdoing.

Larkin said he expected the city council would press ahead with a Chapter 9 filing given the severity of the city's financial trouble.

"They seemed hell bent to do it," he said. "I understand they're just about out of cash. I got the feeling that when they voted last Tuesday, they were out of options."

A state law approved after Vallejo, California, declared bankruptcy in 2008 requires financially troubled cities to enter into talks with creditors to try to avert bankruptcy.

But the law also allows cities to skip talks and move directly toward a bankruptcy filing by declaring a fiscal emergency and stating that they are unable to pay their obligations within 60 days.

(Reporting by Tori Richards; Writing by Jim Christie; Editing by Peter Cooney and Christopher Wilson)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (8)
glenjo1 wrote:
Time for the State to consider real pension reform before the State goes bankrupt as well. Undoubtedly it will be unpopular, but the State’s politicians sold the State to get votes by giving away more than it could afford to pay. With new employees not getting the same benefits and other costs going up more taxes are not going to fly.

Jul 18, 2012 11:30pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Airycat wrote:
Cities have the power to tax. How can they be bankrupt? They should tax, cut spending and pay their bills

Jul 18, 2012 11:38pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
CountryPride wrote:
It is time for our country to crack down on illegal immigration and stop these criminals from robbing our taxpayer funded public services which raise our taxes and bankrupt our city coffers. As a matter of fact we need to cut back on immigration period and focus on making our own citizens more competitive and helping them find jobs instead of leaving them helpless and allowing foreigners to come and steal our jobs and money we pay in taxes for our families! It was the same case in Stockton California that went bankrupt. Over the last decade immigration increased at a 20% rate and as of the 2010 census Stockton was 40% Hispanic and 22% Asian. The problem is that once they bankrupt these towns they will just move to another nice town in the USA and bankrupt those ones too until the USA is a 3rd world garbage can just like home. The American people need to get real serious and real tough on immigration period because it is killing our country!

Jul 19, 2012 1:34am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

Full focus