Arizona Republican's "Middle Easterners" comments spark debate

PHOENIX Wed Aug 29, 2012 7:27pm EDT

Related Topics

PHOENIX (Reuters) - Remarks by a conservative Arizona Republican Congressional candidate that Middle Easterners' "only goal in life is to cause harm to the United States" have landed her in the midst of a dispute over whether the comments amount to hate speech.

Tea Party-backed Gabriela Saucedo Mercer, who was born in Mexico and is a naturalized U.S. citizen, won the Republican primary on Tuesday to run in an Arizona Congressional district that flanks the border in southern Arizona. She faces Democrat Raul Grijalva, a five-term incumbent, in the November general election.

Grijalva sparked the debate Tuesday when he circulated a video in which the Republican tells an interviewer that authorities in the previous year nabbed 25,000 illegal immigrants who were other than Mexican nationals.

"That includes Chinese, Middle Easterners. If you know Middle Easterners, a lot of them they look Mexican or like a lot of people in South America - dark skin, dark hair, brown eyes, and they mix in," she said in the interview, recorded last year by

"And those people, their only goal in life is to cause harm to the United States, so why do we want them here, either legally or illegally?" she said.

Arizona has been in the national spotlight after a Supreme Court ruling in June allowing a controversial "show-your-papers" measure permitting police to ask anyone they stop for other reasons about their immigration status. The measure is part of a crackdown on illegal immigration signed by Republican Governor Jan Brewer in 2010.

Backers said it was needed because of the federal government's failure to secure the state's porous border with Mexico, although opponents have slammed the law as a mandate for racial profiling.

Mercer is running on a platform of tighter border security, protection for unborn children and defense of gun rights, and has been endorsed by Brewer, Republican Secretary of State Ken Bennett and the Border Patrol union's Tucson chapter, among others.

Grijalva, a long-term opponent of the immigration crackdown, issued a news release on Tuesday denouncing what he called Mercer's "reckless hate speech" and urged everyone who endorsed Mercer to "withdraw their support immediately."

"This is not a he-said, she-said question of interpretation. Her comments are reprehensible and deserve condemnation from every quarter. Anyone who continues to support her campaign should be asked whether they want someone with her views in Congress," he said in a statement.

Rep. Keith Ellison, the first Muslim American elected to Congress, said he was "disappointed" in Mercer's "decision to inject division and fear" into the Congressional race.

The American-Arab Anti Discrimination Committee, a non-sectarian civil rights and civil liberties group, also weighed into the debate, slamming Mercer's choice of words, which it said "once again exemplifies the bigotry and racism rampant within the Republican party, and politics as a whole."

The nonprofit group called on Republican party leaders, including presidential candidate Mitt Romney, to condemn her remarks and "move away from the politics of hate and fear."

A call to Mercer seeking comment was not immediately returned on Wednesday. In comments reported by the Arizona Daily Star newspaper, she said the video was edited to be misleading and took her comments out of context.

"He (Grijalva) must be scared or something," the newspaper reported Mercer saying at a primary-election night party on Tuesday. "The tactics he's using to smear me as a racist are unconscionable."

(Editing by Greg McCune and Eric Walsh)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
CountryPride wrote:
“Hate Speech” is just another propaganda tool of the Left to try destroy our first amendment rights and dumb down the nation to be afraid to say anything or speak the right to their opinion and that includes the right to agree or disagree the right to speak well of someone and the right to bash someone. You don’t have to listen or agree with it but they have the right to their opinion. The only debate that should be going on is why does the PC left remain ignorant of the threat of Islam and it’s agenda to this country. Please tell me one good thing Islam has brought to any country it entered? Just one, now I can show a whole lot of facts of what Islam has brought to countries it entered and it’s not pretty. That’s a fact.

Aug 31, 2012 9:16pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.