New York probes private equity tax strategy: source

Sat Sep 1, 2012 10:31pm EDT

(Reuters) - At least a dozen U.S. private equity firms have been subpoenaed by the New York state attorney general as part of a probe into whether a widely used tax strategy that saved these firms hundreds of millions of dollars is proper, a source familiar with the situation said on Saturday.

Among the firms that were subpoenaed are Bain Capital LLC, KKR & Co LP, TPG Capital LP, Apollo Global Management LLC and Silver Lake Partners LP, the source said.

Bain was once headed by Mitt Romney, the Republican candidate who hopes to unseat President Barack Obama in the November 6 election.

The subpoenas, which were sent out in July, seek documents related to the conversion of fees these private equity firms charge for managing investors' assets into fund investments, the source said. This means the investigation predates the release last month of confidential Bain fund documents by Gawker that revealed such a practice.

The practice is known as a "management fee waiver." As fund investments, the income would be taxed as capital gains, which attract rates around 15 percent. Without the conversion, the fees would be ordinary income, taxed at rates around 35 percent.

Other firms that received subpoenas include Sun Capital Partners; Clayton, Dubilier & Rice; Crestview Partners; H.I.G. Capital; Vestar Capital Partners; and Providence Equity Partners.

Jennifer Givner, a spokeswoman for New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman's office, declined to comment. The firms were not immediately available for comment.

The investigation comes in the midst of a heated U.S. presidential election campaign. Romney has been scrutinized for his tenure as head of Bain, through which he amassed much of his estimated $250 million fortune.

The timing of the probe and Schneiderman's credentials as a Democrat could raise eyebrows in political circles.

Romney's record at Bain is already a target of attack by President Barack Obama's campaign and has put an uncomfortable spotlight on the industry. A probe into a potential tax dodge by the industry could further play into the Democrats' hands.

Romney earned about $13 million in income over the past two years from carried interest, or the portion of a private equity fund's profits that goes to its managers, according to his campaign, which has issued a statement denying that he ever profited from using a management fee waiver.

With the latest probe, Schneiderman, who has been in office for less than two years, follows in the footsteps of predecessors Andrew Cuomo and Eliot Spitzer, who played the role of sheriff of Wall Street.

Schneiderman, who is co-chair of a mortgage crisis unit under Obama, has looked into mortgage practices at banks. Other high-profile cases involving financial institutions include an investigation of possible manipulation of the Libor benchmark international lending rates by banks.

The tax probe is being conducted out of the New York Attorney General's Taxpayer Protection Bureau, which was set up in early 2011. The agency was established "to root out fraud and return money illegally stolen from New York taxpayers at no additional cost to the state," according to the AG's website.

In April, the AG's office also sued Sprint Nextel Corp for more than $300 million, accusing the company of tax fraud by deliberately not collecting or paying millions of dollars of taxes for its cell phone service.


Private equity firms sometimes grant investors a waiver of their management fee - typically charged at 1-2 percent of investments - in exchange for being able to use that capital as their own investment income in the fund.

The benefit for the investor is recouping its fee, while the fund manager gets extra incentive to make the fund perform well but is also taxed less on this money.

The Internal Revenue Service has so far not banned such a practice, which some private equity fund managers argue is done to align their interests more with those of their investors rather than to reduce taxes.

They point out that money that is secure for the fund manager as a management fee is being converted into carried interest, which is far from guaranteed.

The New York Times first reported news about the Attorney General's probe.

(Additional reporting by Nivedita Bhattacharjee in Chicago; Editing by Paritosh Bansal and Eric Walsh)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
Pmo4Me wrote:
Pay your taxes like the rest of us. Stop gaming the system then wrapping yourself in the american flag.

Sep 01, 2012 11:56pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
SteveC wrote:
So let me get this straight. I get to put my paycheck(fees) into the same fund(s) I or my firm manage, then withdraw the money when I wish, at the same rate as a dividend distribution or cash-out?
I suppose I can use the value of these funds as assets in the debt-to-equity assessment when I want to borrow funds to tide me over past the minimum hold time on these funds? Then of course if the money I borrow is part of a cash out mortgage or equity line, I can deduct the interest?
No wonder this is raising some eyebrows, especially in cash-strapped states. Seems like an elaborate variation on a Ponzi scheme.

Sep 02, 2012 1:28pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
SteveC wrote:
So the republicans(and most likely the mega wealthy democrats as well) have to pull out all the stops to prevent Obama from being elected to another term, especially given the prospect of Obama changing the ideological makeup of the Supreme Court. They have everything to gain and much to lose should any meaningful changes to the tax code or Citizens United become reality. They’re in the fight of their corporate and financial lives. Expect the worst.

Sep 02, 2012 2:02pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.