AU Optronics fined $500 million in U.S. for price fixing
TAIPEI/SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Taiwan-based AU Optronics Corp was fined $500 million by a U.S. judge for price fixing in the market for liquid crystal display panels, but the company's shares jumped as much as 5 percent early on Friday amid relief the fine wasn't larger.
U.S. District Judge Susan Illston in San Francisco also handed down three-year prison sentences to two individual defendants on Thursday.
A jury convicted the company and two AU executives, Hsuan-Bin Chen, 60, and Hui Hsiung, 58, in March. Former AU Chief Executive L.J. Chen, who remains a top executive at the company, was acquitted at the trial.
AU was charged as part of an investigation into an alleged price-fixing cartel between 1999 and 2006. Several other companies, including LG Electronics Inc, have pleaded guilty in the LCD probe.
U.S. prosecutors had accused company executives of meeting more than 60 times at luxury hotels to fix prices of LCD panels, saying the conspiracy cost the U.S. economy billions of dollars.
Criminal trials against publicly traded companies are rare, and AU has said it would appeal its conviction. At the trial, AU's lawyers asserted that the company "competed fiercely" and that the mere exchange of information between companies was not illegal.
AU, which has a market capitalization of about $3.3 billion, had argued it should be fined no more than $285 million. U.S. antitrust prosecutors had sought $1 billion.
On Friday, AU shares jumped as much as 5 percent, versus a broader market's 0.49 percent gain, because the fine was less than some investors had expected.
The Taiwanese company said in a statement that it will make an extra provision of $223 million this quarter.
"This was a documented, far-reaching, clearly illegal conspiracy to fix pricing," Judge Illston said at Thursday's hearing. She said she took into consideration fines imposed on other companies in the investigation, and the fact that AU had already incurred heavy costs in money and time for this trial.
"That's why I find that $500 million is adequate but not excessive," she said.
Rival LG Electronics agreed to pay a $400 million fine in 2008, while Samsung Electronics Co Ltd cut an early deal to avoid prosecution.
AU was the sole Asian LCD maker to plead not guilty.
"$500 million is not enough to deter cartels like this from forming," Department of Justice antitrust division trial attorney Heather Tewksbury said.
In urging a larger penalty, Tewksbury said LG Electronics had been fined $400 million even after providing substantial assistance to authorities.
"AU Optronics is getting a 50 percent discount and that's an inequitable result," she said.
The judge also ordered three years of probation for the company, including implementation of a compliance and ethics program. The company was ordered to pay the fine over three years.
Both Chen and Hsiung declined to make personal remarks when asked by Judge Illston. They sat motionless as she sentenced them to three years in prison for making "poor choices and bad judgment."
"The Antitrust Division will continue to pursue vigorously international cartels that target American consumers and rob them of their hard-earned money," Scott D. Hammond, Deputy Assistant Attorney General for the Antitrust Division's criminal enforcement program, said in a statement.
The case in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, is United States v. Hsuan Bin Chen et al, 09-cr-00110.