Federal agency to switch to iPhone, drop BlackBerry

Mon Oct 22, 2012 5:32pm EDT

1 of 2. A Research in Motion (RIM) BlackBerry smartphone handset is reflected in the logo of an Apple iPhone in this illustration picture taken in Lavigny, in this July 21, 2012 file photo.

Credit: Reuters/Valentin Flauraud/Files

Related Topics

(Reuters) - The U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency (ICE) said it will end its contract with BlackBerry maker Research In Motion Ltd in favor of Apple Inc's iPhone, dealing a new blow to RIM just months before it launches a vital new device.

The agency said in a solicitation document posted last week that it intends to buy iPhones for more than 17,600 employees - a purchase worth $2.1 million.

The agency said it has relied on RIM for eight years, but the company "can no longer meet the mobile technology needs of the agency."

It also said it analyzed Apple's iOS-based devices and Google Inc's Android operating system and concluded that, for the near term, Apple's iPhone services offer the best technology for the agency because of Apple's tight controls of the hardware platform and operating system.

The agency said the iPhone will be used by a "variety of agency personnel, including, but not limited to, Homeland Security Investigations, Enforcement and Removal Operations and Office of the Principal Legal Advisor employees.

"The iPhone services will allow these individuals to leverage reliable, mobile technology on a secure and manageable platform in furtherance of the agency's mission."

Last week, consulting firm Booz Allen Hamilton said it was dropping BlackBerry and switching to iPhone and Android smartphones for its staff of around 25,000.

Analysts said that other businesses and agencies are likely to follow suit especially in light of demand for other smartphones.

"You're going to see this happen more and more," said Ed Snyder, an analyst at Charter Equity Research.

"They still have excellent security ... but if your handsets are a brick that no one wants to use it's going to drag down your business."

RIM has high hopes that its new BB10 smartphone, expected to in early 2013, will compete with iPhones and Android phones. The BB10 will come equipped with a revamped operating system and is aimed at putting an end to a precipitous decline in RIM's market share over the past year and longer.

"Of course, we are disappointed by this decision," RIM vice president of government solutions Paul Lucier said in an emailed statement. "We are working hard to make our new mobile computing platform, BlackBerry 10, meets the future needs of government customers."

RIM said that, after accounting for the ICE move, it had one million government customers in North America.

RIM's advantage has been what industry experts widely describe as superior security and device-management features that have made the BlackBerry appealing to corporate IT managers and a crucial tool for police, government and military use.

But that advantage is waning with the growing number of providers that help companies beef up security on iPhones and Androids and with Apple working on better security on its devices.

"Apple is really addressing security," Sterne Agee analyst Shaw Wu said, adding that it had improved security with the acquisition of AuthenTec and that it now supports Cisco's VPN.

Wu said RIM's problems were compounded by questions over the company's economic viability.

"Is the company going to be around in the next couple of years?" Wu said.

In addition, he added that "a lot of these enterprises have moved beyond email and voice, on to apps and, with RIM, it's pretty clear that their app ecosystem is very weak."

(Reporting By Nicola Leske in New York. Additional reporting by Sinead Carew; Editing by Peter Galloway and Andre Grenon)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (3)
timacheson wrote:
“analyzed Apple’s iOS-based devices and Google’s Android operating system and concluded that for the near term Apple’s iPhone services offer the best technology for the agency because of Apple’s tight controls of the hardware platform and operating system”

I am profoundly skeptical about this decision, which will result in a substantial expenditure of public money. The public deserves a detailed comparison of iPhone vs Android alternatives to justify this.

Oct 22, 2012 12:36pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
“Manageable platform?” That describes RIM’s stuff pretty well but has no resemblance to what Apple sells. They don’t even HAVE administrative tools for iOS, at least none that I’ve heard about. I suppose if you’re using Exchange an iPhone could be almost as secure as a Blackberry. However, I suspect this change has more to do with agents who want remote surveillance apps (and Angry Birds) than it does with RIM’s shortcomings – and there are *definite* shortcomings with BB, but security and manageability aren’t among them. RIM’s biggest mistake has been virtually ignoring its existing devices. The most recent ones (Bold 9000, etc) have pretty capable hardware, but the OS is so antiquated, inflexible and buggy that it cripples them.

Oct 22, 2012 12:51pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
sleeplessinva wrote:
Sure, the “apps” market is far more dominant in the iOS market, but it is ironic to think that when an application gets deployed on a government platform, piles of paperwork must be pushed through, numerous amounts of security testing and validation work must be documented and vetted. Yet, with the ease of “application” deployment on the iOS platform, and the closed environment that is iOS (any serious Apple user/hacker knows that unless you jail break it, iOS configuration management is a nightmare, if not, impossible because Apple will not let you downgrade the device even if you have all the software and hardware).

Let us not forget that the IPhone does not have a tactile keyboard. With this decision, I would not be surprised if all the malware writers now will got after iOS in an attempt to write some nifty “app” just so they can piggy back their way into the phone.

Also, just because you put a pin lock on the phone it does not mean you need to re-enter the pin lock when someone takes the phone and physically connect it to a Mac/PC.

Unfortunately, RIM hasn’t done themselves any favors in trying to “keeping up with the Jones” and in effect lost their identity the past few years. Then again, my old 8830 world edition is still working after nearly 5 years of usage and the only thing I’ve had to replace are batteries and the trackball.

Oct 22, 2012 7:31pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.