New York state asks Washington to cover all storm costs

NEW YORK/WASHINGTON Wed Oct 31, 2012 7:37pm EDT

Related Topics

NEW YORK/WASHINGTON (Reuters) - New York state on Wednesday asked the U.S. federal government to pay all the costs of cleaning up and repairing damage from massive storm Sandy that tore through the Northeast this week and crippled New York City.

Governor Andrew Cuomo said he is asking fellow Democrat, President Barack Obama, to pay 100 percent of the estimated $6 billion bill, at a time that state and local government budgets remain constrained by a weak economic recovery.

That would be a significant change from last year when the federal government covered about 75 percent of the $1.2 billion cost paid by New York to clean up after storm Irene hit the region.

The two U.S. senators from neighboring New Jersey, the other state hit hardest by the storm, also asked that the federal government cover more than the usual share of the cost, given the size of the disaster and the financially strapped local coffers.

"Recent storms in New Jersey have already placed a significant burden on our state and local governments, which have been forced to pay for disaster response and will need federal assistance for recovery from Hurricane Sandy," Senator Frank Lautenberg and Senator Robert Menendez, both Democrats, wrote in a letter to Obama.

"While we understand the federal share is typically 75 percent of these total costs, the unprecedented and extraordinary extent of damage Hurricane Sandy has caused to our state merits an adjustment to this cost-share to 90 to 100 percent federal coverage," the two senators said.

New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, a Republican, did not reply to request of comments.

Obama and Christie toured storm-stricken parts of New Jersey on Wednesday, taking in scenes of flooded roads from the air and telling residents they were moving quickly to get them help.


New York top finance official, Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, said Washington should foot the bill, because of lingering financial pressures on state and local governments from the 2007-09 recession.

"I think the focus will have to be on Washington, for obvious reasons," DiNapoli told Reuters in an interview.

"They have greater resources. They can print money; we can't do that here. And given the fact this is not just a New York disaster, it's really a national disaster, it's probably for the federal government to step up and play a significant role."

"The problem is the state is limited in its resource capacity. We just put out the mid-year report a week or two ago and it really showed tax revenues are down," DiNapoli said.

Most U.S. states must balance their budgets, unlike the federal government, and it is up to Obama to decide if federal funds can cover all the costs.

"The president has the discretion to go higher. Seventy-five percent is a floor not a ceiling," said Matt Mayer, a former senior official at the Department of Homeland Security.

If Obama accepts covering all the costs, this would be announced by Federal Emergency management Agency, Mayer said.

Former President George W. Bush allowed 100 percent reimbursement of costs in some states after Hurricane Katrina struck in 2005, Mayer, who worked at DHS during Bush's presidency, told Reuters.

Cuomo said in a letter to Obama that "initial estimates project up to $6 billion in lost economic revenue in the greater metropolitan area and the state" due to disruption to business in the world's financial hub.

Cuomo added that "the significant impact from Hurricane Sandy plainly warrants providing this assistance."

The state, he said, was still battling multi-building fires, tunnel closures, and power outages at hospitals and other vital facilities. Plus there are destroyed homes and people needing shelter.

"Moreover, the cost to restore the complex electrically driven subway and rail transportation systems after total inundation from saltwater flooding will place a tremendous financial burden on New York state," Cuomo said in the letter.

In New York alone nearly 2 million homes and businesses are still without power.

Cuomo said federal support is key to making sure state and local governments can respond effectively to the disaster.

New York state is rated AA by Standard and Poor's and Aa2 by Moody's and its outstanding debt is the second highest among states, after California.

(Additional reporting by Michael Connor in Miami; writing by Tiziana Barghini in New York; Editing by Mary Milliken and Bob Burgdorfer)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (11)
mklass wrote:
Mighty nice of him to ask the rest of us to pay for all of it.

Shouldn’t the locals bear some of the cost?

Oct 31, 2012 5:01pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Progression wrote:
“They have greater resources. They can print money; we can’t do that here. And given the fact this is not just a New York disaster, it’s really a national disaster, it’s probably for the federal government to step up and play a significant role.”

Why do people seem to think that we can just print money? Do they not know what happens when you increase the supply of cash into a society? It is called inflation and it hurts everyone. The Federal government should not be able to just print money when they need too.

Oct 31, 2012 9:05pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
morbas wrote:
The tax flaw is fundamental between Federal, State and Municipality revenue basis. At the lower levels, taxes tend to a broader based flat taxation that inherently weighs heavier on sustenance income levels. Secondly, monetary supply should be regulated by supply and value, not mandated by debt. As the population increases, monetary supply must expand to accomodate economic means. This is called monetary supply theory. The present monetary threat is in not circulating (hoarding) cash. Foreign governments (China #1) and corporation hoarding is slowing present economic growth. (Money should have an idle lifetime.)
The first corner is to Nationalize the Revenue with a single income tax, all revenue divided in thirds between Federal State and Municipalty proportioned within each level by voter turn out. No other taxation allowed. Tax margined well above (1.5X) poverty (approx $30K). These are the published 2011 national budget summations.
Total USA Income $12,981,740,848,000 [1]
Federal Budget: $ 2,314,000,000,000 17.83% of Income[1].
State Budget : $3,007,320,000,000 23.17% of Income[1].
City-County Municipality :$37,945,809,589 16.4% of Income [2].
Total USA Budget: 57.4% of USA Income.
My estimate is that just over $150K year is where taxation is comparatively equal to present day effective taxation rates.
[1] taken from published web datum.
[2] extrapolated from North Carolina Iredell County, scaled by population to USA total.

We are a United States, so yes, we must execute a collective responsibity.

Oct 31, 2012 9:20pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.