Syrian rebels kill prisoner as war fuels hatred

HAREM, Syria Thu Nov 8, 2012 10:24am EST

1 of 6. A member of the Free Syrian Army is reflected in a mirror in a house they use as a base during street fighting in Harem town, Idlib Governorate, in this October 26, 2012 file photo. Picture taken October 26, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Asmaa Waguih/Files

HAREM, Syria (Reuters) - Unarmed and cornered by Syrian rebel fighters, the man seemed to accept his death with more silent sorrow than surprise; his killers did not hesitate as they shot their prisoner.

The incident, filmed by a Reuters video crew, happened last week in Harem, near Aleppo, where rebels have surrounded hundreds of troops and militiamen loyal to President Bashar al-Assad. Taking one neighborhood after days of bitter street fighting, opposition fighters went from house to house.

From one building they hauled a man in middle age, dressed in casual clothes, black bearded and without a weapon. He seemed anxious and shied away as he stumbled into the street. Three rebels fighters casually raised their Kalashnikov rifles. A shot rang out, then another. A third. The man began to fall. Still silent. More shots. He lay still. A final round hit his head.

For rebel commanders who present their siege of the former Crusader fortress town of Harem as a showcase for efforts to forge a disciplined fighting force out of motley volunteers, the killing was an embarrassment, offering evidence that Assad's "shabbiha" gunmen have no monopoly on atrocities.

Brigade commander Basel Eissa did shout at his men but was unable to stop them. Leaders of the unit said the fighters were angry at taking casualties. They also justified their action by saying they later found documents showing the dead man was a loyalist army officer - though that would be no defense in a war crimes court.

"I try to remind them that there are moral reasons we do not just kill soldiers," Eissa said. "And beyond that, I tell them that strategically it is bad - we get help or information when we spare these men's lives. We are not their judge, God is."

Commanders are also aware that bad publicity could hamper rebel efforts to secure arms and funding from abroad that might allow them to better match the tanks, aircraft and artillery which Assad's forces are using against them to deadly effect - Eissa himself was killed in an air strike earlier this week.


U.N. investigators accuse pro-government forces of war crimes, including the murder and torture of civilians, in what they said in August may be a state-directed policy. They said rebel fighters were also guilty of war crimes, including executing prisoners, but on a smaller scale.

Assad's state media give extensive coverage to allegations of atrocities committed by opponents whom the president brands as "terrorists" bent on destroying Syrian society.

Major Mohammed al-Ali, an army defector at Harem trying to coordinate rebel brigades in the hope of greater international support, said: "In every battle, there are violations. We deal with them harshly to make an example of them."

There was no sign of immediate punishment, however, for those fighters who killed the prisoner last week, although their commanders in field reprimanded them. After the shooting, the unit involved continued its operation.

Elsewhere in Harem, Reuters saw the bodies of four uniformed soldiers lined up in a garden, all shot in the head. And, although dozens of prisoners were held by rebels at Harem, at least one fighter there described commanders' calls for fair treatment as a smokescreen to keep the killing hidden.

More and more instances of executions are coming to light, including a video uploaded to the Internet last week that showed rebels in another part of Idlib province in the northwest lining several soldiers up against a wall and gunning them down, an act the United Nations has said could constitute a war crime.

(Editing by Alastair Macdonald)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (10)
Bob9999 wrote:
“Syrian rebels kill prisoner as war fuels hatred”

This is not something that we approve of; however, Syrian rebels captured by the government may be tortured first and then killed. And if they give up enough information to identify where they come from, their families may be targeted, as well.

Nov 08, 2012 11:01am EST  --  Report as abuse
ofilha wrote:
The west should be very careful with this situation. We do not know really who are the rebels, and i am sure they now have been infiltrated by Jihadists and alqaida types who will use these tactics to sow discord and hatred. If it becomes a tit for tat we are going to see the deterioration of Syria into a Somalia type of situation or Lebanon’s civil wars and the West will not win any friends there.

Nov 08, 2012 11:52am EST  --  Report as abuse
Slammy wrote:
Very sad but foreseeable. Just about every armed conflict has similar incidents. Americans killed many Japanese prisoners during WWII because they could not guard and/or transport them to holding areas during combat. Heard similar stories in Vietnam and even in Afghanistan. Not sleeping for days in a war zone while watching ones friends being killed can drive men to actions they would not otherwise commit. Not legal, not acceptable but predictable.

Nov 08, 2012 12:03pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.