Portugal passes bailout review, risks remain high

LISBON Mon Nov 19, 2012 3:49pm EST

Portugal's Finance Minister Vitor Gaspar reacts during a news conference in Lisbon November 19, 2012. REUTERS/Hugo Correia

Portugal's Finance Minister Vitor Gaspar reacts during a news conference in Lisbon November 19, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Hugo Correia

Related Topics

LISBON (Reuters) - Debt-laden Portugal has passed the sixth quarterly review of its performance under an EU/IMF bailout, opening the way for payment of the next 2.5 billion euro tranche of the loan despite growing economic risks, the lenders said on Monday.

The review, which lasted just a week, found the country was progressing in reforming its economy and the program remained broadly on track to allow it to again finance itself in debt markets as planned next year. Previous reviews lasted two weeks.

The lenders and the government expect the economy, in its worst slump since the 1970s, to contract 1 percent next year after this year's 3 percent fall, unchanged from the forecasts in their last review in September. The economy should only return to growth, of 0.8 percent, in 2014.

"Confidence in Portugal's prospects continues to grow, both among its institutional partners and market participants," Olli Rehn, the European Commission's top economic official, said in a statement. "This bodes well for Portugal's full return to market financing."

Portugal's Finance Minister Vitor Gaspar said that after the next payment the country will have received 87 percent of the 78-billion-euro bailout.

But he said risks remained, not least from a recession in neighboring Spain, Portugal's biggest export market.

"An emergency situation is characterized by innumerous risks and uncertainty, denying these circumstances is unrealistic. The challenges we face are very demanding, they will continue to demand sacrifices," Gaspar said.

He said Portugal was considering a cut in corporate tax, a move which could make it more attractive for foreign investment. Planned spending cuts of 4 billion euros in 2013-14 will be discussed with lenders in the next review, he added.

Under the bailout, Portugal must post a budget deficit of 5 percent of gross domestic product this year and 4.5 percent next year. The 'troika' of lenders - the European Commission, European Central Bank and IMF - said the outlook for the bailout plan remained unchanged.

"While downside risks to growth are significant, the program's macroeconomic framework remains appropriate," the troika said in a statement.

The deepening recession, which has undercut tax revenues, prompted the lenders to give Portugal some leeway on its tough budget goals at the last review in September.

The EU and IMF have previously warned of increasing challenges for Portugal's bailout, considering growing opposition to austerity measures that have sent unemployment to record highs at 15.8 percent. Next year, the Portuguese will face their largest hike in taxes in modern history to meet the budget goals.

Economists have warned the tax hikes could prompt a much bigger contraction than expected as consumer confidence suffers.

Portuguese workers staged a general strike on November 14 which turned violent.

Rehn said he was "acutely aware" of how difficult the situation is for the Portuguese, especially those who have lost their jobs. Unemployment is expected to rise to 16.4 percent next year.

"The reforms under way are laying the ground for sustainable growth and job creation and the Commission will continue to stand by Portugal as it sees these reforms through," Rehn said.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel signaled her strong support for Lisbon's efforts during a visit to Lisbon last week.

The lenders and the government have said they remain confident Portugal will be able to return to bond markets as planned next year and bond yields remain far below highs reached early this year.

Yields on Portugal's 10-year bonds fell sharply to 8.5 percent on Monday from 8.75 percent on Friday, a far cry from highs around 17 percent in January.

(Additional reporting by Andrei Khalip; Writing by Axel Bugge; Editing by Ron Askew and Robin Pomeroy)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (1)
dareconomics wrote:
Portugal passes its latest troika review in line with the 1st Iron Law of the Eurocrisis— when it gets serious, you have to lie.

According to the troika, Portugal is on a path of deficit reduction and will be able to reenter international debt markets next year. This is a dishonest optimistic analysis of the data.

In order to proclaim that Portugal’s program is on track, the troika made several rosy assumptions. They believe that Portugal’s economy will only shrink by 1% next year and return to growth by 2014 and will able to reduce its budget deficit in the midst of an economic depression.

The country will never attain these goals. Spain, its largest trading partner is imploding. Additionally, the country plans €2bn per year in additional spending cuts; this figure alone will lop off 1% per year off its €186bn GDP, not even accounting for the multiplier effect.

Since the economy will shrink more than forecast, the government budget will not attain its revenue goals and miss the 4.5% budget deficit for 2013. Of course, this does not stop Ollie Rehn from opening his mouth:

Confidence in Portugal’s prospects continues to grow, both among its institutional partners and market participants…This bodes well for Portugal’s full return to market financing.

Allow me to remind you of the 2nd Iron Law of the Eurocrisis— ignore whatever the politicians have to say, and focus on the numbers.

These are the important numbers, Portugal’s Government Debt to GDP:

Portugal Government Debt To GDP

The ratio has been steadily rising for years. While the rate of increase is projected to slow during the next two years, adding two more annual 5% budget deficits means that Portugal will approach a 120% debt to GDP ratio.

Mind you, that is the best case scenario. A more realistic two 7% budget deficits blows through the 120% barrier. Just like Greece, there is no way this small, relatively poor country will ever be able to pay back this debt.

Sometime within the next two years, Portugal will need to renegotiate this bailout, just like Greece is doing now; just like Greece, Portugal will eventually default on its debt.

See complete post with chart here:


Nov 19, 2012 5:21pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.