Time for Santa to wave "vaarwel" to Black Pete?

BRUSSELS/AMSTERDAM Mon Dec 3, 2012 10:26am EST

1 of 6. Saint Nicholas (L) is followed by his two assistants called 'Zwarte Piet' (Black Pete) during a traditional parade in central Brussels December 1, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Francois Lenoir

Related Topics

BRUSSELS/AMSTERDAM (Reuters) - The Netherlands and Belgium are two countries that pride themselves on progressive laws and open societies, but critics say they are stuck in the dark ages when it comes to depictions of Santa Claus and his helpers.

Saint Nicholas, or "Sinterklaas" in Dutch, brings presents to children on December 5 in the Netherlands and on December 6 in Belgium, and is always accompanied by at least one assistant dressed in 17th century costume who has a blackened face.

The tradition has been difficult for Dutch and Belgian people to explain abroad, where "Zwarte Piet" (Black Pete) is viewed with either outrage or ridicule.

Dutch pub "De Hems" in London opts for blue face paint instead. Sinterklaas celebrations in western Canada organized by the Dutch community were called off last year and former Dutch colony Suriname has said Zwarte Piet is not welcome this year because of concerns over racism.

For most Dutch and Belgians Zwarte Piet is an innocuous fairytale character who assists the popular Sinterklaas and hands out candy to children, but some there too argue he is a harmful stereotype best done away with.

"It was about six years ago when my mum came home from work and phoned me," performance artist Quinsy Gario, who was born on the Dutch Caribbean island of Curacao, told Reuters.

"On the phone I could hear her trembling. She was upset, livid, and said someone at work had called her Zwarte Piet."

In 2011, Gario decided to protest against the tradition by standing with a "Zwarte Piet is racism" T-shirt in a crowd watching a Sinterklaas parade in the Dutch town of Dordrecht. His subsequent arrest made headlines in Dutch media.

Film by a bystander showed three police officers pinning him to the ground and kneeing him in the back. Gario also said he had pepper spray sprayed in his eyes.

"I spent six and a half hours in a jail cell for freedom of expression," he said.


Nevertheless, Zwarte Piet remains popular in 2012, and his traditional arrival by boat with Sinterklaas a few weeks ahead of the actual celebration was witnessed by thousands of starry-eyed children in Brussels and Amsterdam.

Sinterklaas, the presents he brings, as well as the traditional food and candy sold around this time are also good business for companies such as toy stores and supermarkets.

"Families with children are a very important customer group of ours. How would you explain to your children that Zwarte Piet is no longer allowed?," said Chief Operating Officer Sander van der Laan of Albert Heijn, the Netherlands' largest supermarket.

Dutch anti-discrimination organisation RADAR said that it would talk to retail organizations in the coming months about how to make Zwarte Piet less racist.

"We believe that you have to go to Piet, not Zwarte Piet, to leave the celebration intact but get rid of the stereotypes," said Margriet Maris, a lawyer at RADAR.

Formal complaints are still quite rare. Belgium's centre of equal opportunities said that of more than 4,000 complaints it received a year only one or two were related to Zwarte Piet.

RADAR said it had received about 25 related complaints this year, still only a fraction of the 1,000 it dealt with overall.

The tradition of St Nicholas exists in other European countries, including Austria and Germany. But he is only accompanied by black helpers in the Netherlands and Belgium.

Celebrations were depicted on paintings of 17th century Dutch artists Jan Steen and Richard Brakenburg, but Zwarte Piet only made his first appearance in a mid-19th century illustrated book by Dutch teacher Jan Schenkman.

Entitled "St Nicholas and his servant," it showed a short, dark-faced man dressed in a Moorish costume a few steps behind an imposing white man with a white beard and bishop's outfit.

"There's a theory that says that important people had a black servant, it was a status symbol. Sinterklaas was an important man, so he needed one too," said John Helsloot a researcher at the Meertens Institute in Amsterdam.

"Somebody who dresses up as Zwarte Piet is not a racist but it is a fact that he's part of a tradition which gives a stereotypical, racist image of black people," he said.

Pressure on Zwarte Piet seems to be increasing in 2012 and even well-known conservative blog "Geen Stijl" (No Style) has written that it's time for Sinterklaas to find a new helper.

"It's 2012, people," wrote GeenStijl in a post that attracted much attention. "We're better than Zwarte Piet."

(Additional reporting by Philip Blenkinsop, editing by Paul Casciato)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (2)
EmKing2 wrote:
Thanks for this article! I am a black American married to a Belgian living in Belgium and it gets increasingly hard to explain “Zwarte Piet” to my kids and then get barraged by the “harmless” questions of their school chums at this time of year e.g. “do you know Zwarte Piet” , “are you his cousin”, “do you work for Saint Nicolas”? I actually dread Saint Nicolas Day because of it, and I do not take my kids to a mall to take a picture. The one time that my kids did see “Zwarte Piet” was at my office Christmas party for kids a couple of years back and you could hear a pin drop in quite a crowded room when my kid asked why there was a guy with make up (my boss) on to look like me. Haha. It’s 2012 and it’s not a defensible tradition, so definitely time to say bye bye.

Dec 04, 2012 10:31am EST  --  Report as abuse
pieman73 wrote:
Thank you for this article. I’m a Belgian living in the United States, married to an American, and we have three children. When we approached our first holiday season with our first born we talked about family traditions and how we wanted to proceed. It didn’t take long for me to realize how uncomfortable it would be to explain “Zwarte Piet” to my child, or how awkward it would be to have them at some point talk about “Zwarte Piet” at school. Not only is the tradition not commonly observed/celebrated in the U.S. but let’s be honest here and acknowledge the stereotypes and racism involved. The time to modify and update Sinterklaas is now, and not a minute sooner. Surely the culture can continue to celebrate the generous and gift-giving tradition of St. Nicholas without resorting to racism.

Dec 06, 2012 1:00pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.