Your Money: The "Apple Tax" - America's costly obsession

NEW YORK Mon Dec 10, 2012 3:21pm EST

A customer is helped by an Apple employee while looking over the iPad mini after the device went on sale at Apple's retail store in Palo Alto, California November 2, 2012. REUTERS/Robert Galbraith

A customer is helped by an Apple employee while looking over the iPad mini after the device went on sale at Apple's retail store in Palo Alto, California November 2, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Robert Galbraith

Related Topics

NEW YORK (Reuters) - With the "fiscal cliff" looming, taxpayers are wringing their hands about all sorts of things. Income taxes might rise, dividends might get walloped, lifetime gift-tax exemptions might get slashed.

But when it comes to immediate impact on their wallets, maybe they should be thinking about something else entirely: The Apple tax.

Americans are shelling out big bucks annually to outfit the entire household with Apple products. And they are spending hundreds - if not thousands of dollars - more each year for the unexpected Apple "taxes" -- add-ons that lock them into the Apple system: iTunes downloads for music, movies and games, along with subscriptions and accessories.

Then there are the replacement costs for lost or broken equipment. For a family with multiple children, each with their own technological needs, the total annual bill can get downright ugly -- like going over a familial "fiscal cliff."

Just ask Sam Martorana. A human-resources specialist for the airline WestJet, Martorana's Vancouver household consists of three people and no less than nine Apple products. Between himself, husband Ron, and stepson Evan, they own three MacBooks, two iPhones, two iPads, and two iPods.

"Oh my God, do I have to total it all up?" asks Martorana, 40. "It's so depressing. I'd say we spent at least $5,000 on all that stuff, including $700 in the past year alone. I totally have a weakness. I fell in love, and that was it."

Martorana is hardly alone in forking over so much money to the tech juggernaut. In 2011, the average amount U.S. households spent on Apple products was $444, according to Morgan Stanley analyst Katy Huberty.

That figure has been rising smartly every year. In 2010 it was $295. Back in 2007, it was only $150.

And we might only be seeing the beginning. If Apple rolls out its own HDTV, as expected, Huberty sees annual Apple spending by households doubling, to $888 by 2015.

Apple products are a must-have this holiday season. A Reuters-Ipsos poll finds that one-third of consumers are thinking about buying a tablet computer - and most of them want an iPad or an iPad mini. About one-quarter of those polled say they'll cut back on other holiday purchases this year to afford these pricey gadgets.

The analogy of an Apple tax might sound facetious, but think about it. Median U.S. household income was $50,054 in 2011, according to the Census Bureau. That means a sizable chunk of that is getting diverted to Apple headquarters in Cupertino.

Remember, this is not something that consumers are being forced to pay. They are dipping willingly into their own pockets, because they're essentially slaves to the devices.

"For so many children, the acquisition of an iPad, iPhone or iTouch has replaced the first bicycle or the first driver's license," says Paco Underhill, founder of consulting firm Envirosell and author of several books on consumer behavior including "Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping."

"I have an image of the 9-year-old clutching his first phone like a teddy bear when he goes to sleep at night," he says. "I credit Apple with foresight to recognize what the connectivity process means to people. It's one of the few companies to understand that technology is no longer technology. It's an appliance."

Reno mom Jessica Torres is very familiar with those modern-day "appliances." In 2011 alone Torres' family splurged on a new iPhone, an iPad, an iMac, a MacBook, an iPod Touch (and bought her husband's mom an iPad for good measure).

With two daughters, age 3 and 9, Torres' purchases are likely to ramp up even more in years to come. "We easily spent over $5,000 last year on Apple products," says Torres, who runs the blog "We've sent them a lot of money over the years. I'm definitely an addict."

Customers like Torres are fueling Apple's eye-popping earnings, which were $8.2 billion for the fiscal fourth quarter. That was up from $6.6 billion a year earlier, and amazingly still qualified as a ‘miss,' which demonstrates just how high expectations are for the company.

"People spend more and more as the products are perceived to be better and better," says Michael Gartenberg, research director at technology consulting firm Gartner. "Aspirational products tend to make more family members want to own, and that's why we see Apple products on so many holiday wish lists that are crossing age, gender and other demographics."

As for Martorana, his family's indentured servitude to Apple looks like it will continue indefinitely. He is looking to replace his MacBook with a newer model within a year or so, which he guesses will cost at least another $1,300. While he loves the products unreservedly, he sees no way out of the annual Apple tax.

"With my MacBook, iPad and iPhone, everything is linked," says Martorana, who laments that Apple products are so popular that they never seem to go on sale. "All of my music and photos are in their iCloud. So I don't know if I'd even be able to switch to another product, even if I wanted to. Apple definitely has its hooks in me."

(The writer is a Reuters contributor. The opinions expressed are his own.)

(Editing by Lauren Young; Editing by Dan Grebler)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (56)
matthewslyman wrote:
Here’s what I do whenever I have one of these moments (or more usually, BEFORE I spend): PUT TOGETHER a PRAGMATIC LIST of PROs & CONs —
• What am I paying (including time spent maintaining & administering the devices), and
• what will the marginal benefits be, compared with a range of alternatives (including, the alternative of no purchase)?
Some people are putting these lists together and finding they don’t need this stuff (surprise — there’s probably already an mp3 player and FM radio on your bottom-of-the-range mobile phone!)
Others are pragmatically evaluating that they need these devices — if your choice is between carrying around two brief-cases full of legal documents (which are continually being changed) or carrying an iPad, there’s no contest.

Dec 10, 2012 3:24pm EST  --  Report as abuse
cyke1 wrote:
I don’t see why apple would make a tv, look at profits of all the tv makers right now? Most them lose money on their tv’s, and only a hand full make a profit but its barely even a profit. TV market has so much competition and now apple with its consistent over pricing which on avg is 60-100% more other devices in the category. Apple won’t sell their TV’s at such market up cept to the most loyal of fanboyz. You would be better off with another tv set + apple tv (god forbid). Apple is already having problems keeping up on phone side, pretty stupid to waste money on something they be lucky to break even. TV are cheap and replaceable, with apple expensive and replaceable model. Most people won’t even bother.

Dec 10, 2012 3:42pm EST  --  Report as abuse
JimT46 wrote:
Apple Tax? Are you kidding me? A tax is when someone puts a gun to your head and says “Pay up or we take you to jail and seize your possessions!” A tech company gets it’s income the honest way, it puts out a product that people love. Enslaved? You aren’t kidding, are you? Good lord! I won’t stoop to the level of defining slavery as I know you aren’t that stupid. Definitely too tasteless to not make the comparison, though. Grown ups make financial decisions and live with them. They make necessary changes as needed. You are talking about emotional children who just can’t say “No!” and blaming Apple for their immaturity. We have become a nation of citizens in search of a nanny. Very sad.

Dec 10, 2012 3:43pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.