Photo

Reuters Photojournalism

Our day's top images, in-depth photo essays and offbeat slices of life. See the best of Reuters photography.  See more | Photo caption 

Photo

Rage in Brazil

Mass protests erupt in the biggest cities of Brazil.  Slideshow 

Photo

The Afghan Army

The many faces of the Afghan National Army, which has taken over security of the country from NATO.  Slideshow 

Sponsored Links

Under pressure, Hungary PM drops contested voting rules

Related Topics

Hungary's Prime Minister Viktor Orban arrives at the EU council headquarters for an European Union leaders summit discussing the European Union's long-term budget in Brussels November 22, 2012. REUTERS/Eric Vidal

Hungary's Prime Minister Viktor Orban arrives at the EU council headquarters for an European Union leaders summit discussing the European Union's long-term budget in Brussels November 22, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Eric Vidal

BUDAPEST | Fri Jan 4, 2013 9:07am EST

BUDAPEST (Reuters) - Hungary's ruling Fidesz party abandoned plans to force voters to register for parliamentary elections before the 2014 poll, after the Constitutional Court threw out the measure saying it limited voting rights.

The Constitutional Court ruling and Friday's retreat represent a major blow to conservative Prime Minister Viktor Orban, who swept to power with a two-thirds majority in 2010 parliamentary elections but has since suffered a fall in public support.

But critics have said the measure imposed undue restrictions on a basic tenet of democracy and would discourage large groups of undecided or swing voters from casting their ballot.

The ruling was the second embarrassment in weeks for Orban who has so far held an iron grip on Hungarian politics. Thousands of students took to the streets of Budapest last month to protest against cuts in higher education.

Orban's Fidesz-Christian Democrat alliance approved a new voting system in November in one of the most hotly contested steps of a flurry of reforms that included a new constitution and a swathe of laws that critics say entrench Fidesz's power.

"Mindful of the practice of the European Court of Human Rights, the Constitutional Court has established that for those with Hungarian residency the registration requirement represents an undue restriction on voting rights and is therefore unconstitutional," the court said in a statement.

It added that voter registration for Hungarians outside the borders was justified.

The changes would have required 8 million domestic voters to register in person or online at least two weeks before elections in 2014. Voters currently only have to turn up at polling stations on election day to be identified from an existing state-run database and cast their vote.

The court also said some of the law's provisions on political campaigns imposed "severely disproportionate" restrictions on the freedom of opinion and the media.

Fidesz argued that voter registration was needed because in one of Orban's symbolic measures new voters of Hungarian descent living abroad had been given the right to vote. Fidesz estimated the number of these voters could reach half a million.

TURNAROUND

Minutes after the court ruling was published, Fidesz parliamentary group leader Antal Rogan told a news conference the party would back away from its plan to avoid a potential constitutional crisis.

"The voice of reason and a sense of political responsibility today requires a different move from us," Rogan said.

A survey by pollster Median conducted in September showed four in five people were opposed to the proposed registration.

Undecided voters make up about half of the electorate according to opinion polls, which showed Fidesz still leading the main opposition Socialists, albeit by a much smaller margin than at the last election in 2010.

"Fidesz wanted to focus on its core voters in the campaign via personal mobilization and the limitation of the use of the electronic media (radio and tv) ... the voter registration and the campaign ad limitations would have served this purpose," said Peter Kreko, an analyst at think tank Political Capital.

"The campaign will be more intense than they wanted ... and the new election system now will help Fidesz a lot less than they had expected (in 2014)."

(Reporting by Gergely Szakacs and Krisztina Than; editing by Ron Askew)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (2)
boreal wrote:
Like in most places where law and order rules all over the world, for one to be eligible to vote one must be registered. As a specific example, registration deadlines in the US vary from 10 to 30 days prior to election day throughout all states. So what is the REAL problem if in Hungary, to avoid election fraud they want to tighten up a bit the loosely controlled election rules and require voter registration? Perhaps the Hungarian Constitutional Court itself is running amok on a course towards Hungary’s self-destruction.

Jan 04, 2013 10:44am EST  --  Report as abuse
S_Harnad wrote:
INDEPENDENCE OF HUNGARIAN CONSTITUTIONAL COURT SOON TO END

After winning 53% of the popular vote, which translated into a Supermajority of 68% of parliamentary seats, giving Fidesz sufficient power to revise or replace the constitution, the party embarked on an extraordinary project of passing over 200 laws and drafting and adopting a new constitution — since followed by nearly 2000 amendments.

The new constitution has been widely criticized by the Venice Commission for Democracy through Law, the Council of Europe, the European Parliament and the United States for gathering too much power in the hands of the ruling party, Fidesz, for limiting oversight of the new constitution by the Constitutional Court of Hungary, and for removing democratic Checks and Balances in various areas, including the ordinary Judiciary, supervision of Elections and the Media.

On January 4 2012 the opposition took to the streets protesting the actions of the government of Viktor Orbán, who has rejected appeals from European Commission President Jose Barroso and Economic Affairs Commissioner Olli Rehn. The European Commission subsequently threatened punitive action against the Orbán government. Pro-government supporters held a much larger rally on the 21st of January, 2012, also supporting the new constitution.

On November 26, 2012, Fidesz used its Supermajority to pass legislation revising eligibility for voting. According to critics, this would make it harder to vote the party out of power. In January 2013, the current Constitutional Court of Hungary struck down the new electoral law, objecting to (1) the requirement that voters must register no later than 15 days before polling day, to (2) the proposal that political advertising must be restricted to the publicly run media and (3) to proposed bans on cinemas screening political ads during the campaign as well as bans on the publication of any election-related Opinion polls in the six days prior to election day. The court then ruled that this new law restricted voter rights to an unjustifiable degree and called it a grave violation of freedom of speech.

This January 2013 Constitutional Court of Hungary ruling that the new electoral law was unconstitutional was still decided by the current Court, in which the Fidesz appointees are not yet in the majority. But under the new constitution, with its younger mandatory retirement age for judges, all new judicial appointments are now in the hands of the Fidesz-appointed “President of the National Judicial Office,” Tünde Handó — a family friend of Prime Minister Orbán and the wife of József Szájer, a founding member of the ruling Fidesz party and the man credited with drawing up Hungary’s constitution on his iPad. As of April 2013 the majority of the Constitutional Court of Hungary will become Fidesz appointees. In the view of Princeton University international constitutional law scholar and Hungary specialist Kim Lane Scheppele: “it seems increasingly likely that the Hungarian government is heading toward the creation of a police state”.

Jan 05, 2013 8:36am EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.