Monte Paschi loses at least $293 million on derivative trade: source

ROME/MILAN Tue Jan 22, 2013 7:29pm EST

Related Topics

ROME/MILAN (Reuters) - Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena, Italy's third biggest lender, will book a loss of at least 220 million euros ($293 million) from a three-year-old derivative deal in its 2012 results, a source close to the matter said on Tuesday.

The loss is the latest setback for Monte dei Paschi, which requested 3.9 billion euros in state aid to plug a capital hole stemming from its government bond portfolio and hedging bets gone wrong.

The 220-million-euro loss is linked to a 2009 derivative deal with Japanese bank Nomura, the source said, confirming a report in Italian daily Il Fatto Quotidiano.

The newspaper said the existence of the trade, which was given the name "Alexandria," was only discovered by Monte dei Paschi's new management last October.

Giuseppe Mussari, the former chairman of Monte dei Paschi now serving as head of Italy's banking association ABI, resigned on Tuesday evening after Nomura said he had personally approved the derivatives deal.

Il Fatto Quotidiano said accountancy firm Pricewaterhouse and financial advisor Eidos were now making checks to establish the size of the loss linked to the contract, quoting an anonymous source as saying it could amount to 740 million euros.

Neither Pricewaterhouse nor Eidos were immediately available for comment.

Monte dei Paschi was already on track to end 2012 deeply in the red, having reported a 1.66 billion euro loss in the first nine months of last year.

Its shares fell 5.7 percent on Tuesday to 0.2775 euros.

"This latest news was unexpected and it's prompting significant selling orders on the stock," said a Milan trader.

The Tuscan lender, the world's oldest bank, said in a statement the derivative contract was one of several structured transactions it was reviewing. A 2008 derivative trade with Deutsche Bank is also thought to be under scrutiny, analysts and banking sources say.

Deutsche Bank said last week that trade, dubbed Santorini, had been subject to its rigorous internal approval procedure.

In November, Monte dei Paschi raised its request for state aid by 500 million euros to 3.9 billion euros, citing a possible hit from past transactions as it sought to hedge its exposure to Italian sovereign debt.

The review of those deals is due to be submitted to Monte dei Paschi's board by mid-February and the bank will provide a timely indication about any impact on its accounts, it said.

"ACTED FAIRLY"

Nomura said the Alexandria derivative contract was "fully reviewed and approved prior to execution at the highest level within MPS", including by the Italian bank's board, its then chairman Mussari and by KPMG, the auditor at the time of the Alexandria derivative deal.

"Nomura acted fairly and responsibly with the client at all times, and strongly refutes any suggestion to the contrary," the Japanese bank said in its statement.

Mussari stepped down as head of the Italian banking lobby late on Tuesday but denied any wrongdoing.

"I made this decision convinced that I have always respected the rules of our association, but at the same time I did not want to harm in any way our association," Mussari said in his resignation letter, which was obtained by Reuters.

In separate statements, Monte dei Paschi denied that its board had examined the deal and KPMG said it was never made aware of the trade.

A second source close to the situation said the deal with Nomura in 2009 was made to restructure a position in distressed structured credit assets.

Under the asset swap deal, in which typically fixed and floating rate investments are exchanged, Monte dei Paschi changed its underlying exposure from structured credit assets to investment-grade government bonds, which seemed at the time a less risky profile, the source said.

In a report on Monday, Societe Generale said that of Monte dei Paschi's 24-billion-euro Italian government bond portfolio, 18 billion euros had been "swapped" thanks to 2009 deals. Those transactions wrongly bet on a rise in Euribor interest rates, which instead fell, triggering a loss for Monte dei Paschi.

Il Fatto Quotidiano said the transaction with Nomura included two 30-year repo deals. It said Siena prosecutors already investigating Monte dei Paschi over its pricey acquisition in 2007 of small lender Antonveneta - also orchestrated by Mussari - were looking into the trade to see whether any crimes had been committed.

"Nomura was one of a number of banks approached to de-risk the positions held by MPS that they had previously purchased from (German bank) Dresdner," Nomura said.

"Nomura won the mandate based upon the competitive pricing of its restructuring proposal."

Monte dei Paschi had to request state aid last June as it was one of only four European lenders that failed to meet tougher capital requirements set by the European Banking Authority.

Its 3.3-billion-euro capital shortfall was due not only to its huge exposure to Italian government bonds, whose prices fell sharply during the euro zone debt crisis, but also to the losses on derivative contracts linked to those bond holdings.

Mussari was replaced at the helm of Monte dei Paschi last year by Alessandro Profumo, the former chief executive of UniCredit, Italy's largest bank by assets.

(Additional reporting by Stephen Jewkes; Editing by Paola Arosio, Mark Potter, Sophie Walker and Nick Zieminski)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

California state worker Albert Jagow (L) goes over his retirement options with Calpers Retirement Program Specialist JeanAnn Kirkpatrick at the Calpers regional office in Sacramento, California October 21, 2009. Calpers, the largest U.S. public pension fund, manages retirement benefits for more than 1.6 million people, with assets comparable in value to the entire GDP of Israel. The Calpers investment portfolio had a historic drop in value, going from a peak of $250 billion in the fall of 2007 to $167 billion in March 2009, a loss of about a third during that period. It is now around $200 billion. REUTERS/Max Whittaker   (UNITED STATES) - RTXPWOZ

How to get out of debt

Financial adviser Eric Brotman offers strategies for cutting debt from student loans and elder care -- and how to avoid money woes in the first place.  Video