Spain's Bankia shows recovery signs after record loss

MADRID Thu Feb 28, 2013 11:21am EST

Bankia Chairman Jose Ignacio Goirigolzarri attends a news conference in Madrid February 28, 2013. REUTERS/Juan Medina

Bankia Chairman Jose Ignacio Goirigolzarri attends a news conference in Madrid February 28, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Juan Medina

Related Topics

MADRID (Reuters) - Rescued Spanish lender Bankia (BKIA.MC) reported tentative signs of recovery, even as huge writedowns on bad property assets led it to post the country's biggest ever corporate loss of 19.2 billion euros ($25.2 billion).

Bankia, at the heart of Spain's banking crisis since it requested a state bailout in mid-2012, said on Thursday it would return to profit this year, after deposits rose at the end of 2012 and it began cutting costs.

But the bank faces a big challenge in a country gripped by recession and battling to reduce its government deficit, with even healthier peers fighting rising bad debts.

"The clean-up has been very significant but Bankia's main business, like much of the banking sector, is in Spain and the outlook is complicated," BPI analyst Javier Barrio said.

Bankia's relatively upbeat stance came as Spanish telecoms group Telefonica (TEF.MC) also showed signs of a domestic turnaround after a painful restructuring and thousands of layoffs.

Undermined by a property market crash, Spain's banks drove the country to seek just over 40 billion euros from its European partners last year to help clean up its financial sector.

Bankia was rescued less than a year after listing on the stock market, leaving tens of thousands of ordinary Spaniards who had invested out of pocket and furious.

The bank took nearly 24 billion euros of provisions on soured property loans and assets last year in a bid to wipe the slate clean. It has dumped those assets into a government-backed "bad bank" set up as part of Spain's deal with Europe.

"It will be a complex year, a year of challenges," Chief Executive Jose Ignacio Goirigolzarri told a news conference.

Bankia shares were down 3.7 percent to 0.29 euros at 1500 GMT, 92 percent below the 3.75 euros at which the bank's listing was priced.


Goirigolzarri said Bankia was now stable, cutting costs "at great speed" and aiming to give the government credible options to recover its money by the end of 2014 or 2015.

The bank - in the midst of a fresh marketing campaign under the slogan "Let's start at the beginning" - is targeting a return on equity of over 10 percent for then and aims to post an 800 million euros profit for 2013.

Non-performing loans (NPL) dipped to 13 percent of its loan portfolio in December, from 13.3 percent three months before.

But Bankia's NPL ratio is still much higher than the average in Spain of 10.4 percent and does not include the troubled property deals now in the bad bank.

Bankia said the high ratio, which could grow slightly in 2013, was down to a very prudent analysis of its loan portfolio, 90 percent of which was lending to individuals and small and medium-sized enterprises at the end of 2012.

Executives also warned low interest rates would weigh on Bankia's income.

Bankia will be around 70 percent government-owned once it completes a capital hike from European funds, while 350,000 small shareholders, many of whom participated in its 2011 listing, will end up with a 1 percent stake or less.

The bank has yet to convert preference shares and subordinated debt into capital, as it imposes losses on holders of those securities as part of its rescue.

That process is likely to keep the lender in the public eye as small investors campaign to get their money back, sparking demonstrations across Spain, while some angry clients try to take their cases to an arbitration panel for mis-selling cases.

"They've managed to scare off clients and kill the golden goose," said Antonio Barahona, 75, who invested his life savings in 68,000 euros of Bankia preference shares. A 40-year client of the bank and its former incarnations, he now does no business with Bankia and is trying to take it to court.

Bankia and its parent group BFA, which holds the firm's stakes in various Spanish companies, requested 18 billion euros in European aid last year. Bankia must now shrink its balance sheet by about 60 percent as a condition of the rescue. It is also cutting about 4,500 jobs and closing offices.

The Bankia-BFA group posted a yearly loss of 21.2 billion euros, saying this would drop to 19.4 billion if gains from a pending exchange of hybrid securities were taken into account.

($1 = 0.7628 euros)

(Additional reporting by Sonya Dowsett; Editing by Mark Potter and David Holmes)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
dareconomics wrote:
There was news today from both of Europe’s most fashionable zombie banks. Spanish Bankia is ready for a turnaround after yet another round of massive write-downs, and Italian Monte dei Paschi is set to receive €4.07bn in rescue loans from the Italian government.

As an observer of several banking crises, I have noticed that they follow a pattern following certain rules as they progress.

Previous bad news is always trumpeted as the end of the crisis. Yet, write-downs will grow as will the amount of state aid necessary to keep the bank in business. How quickly people forget the last banking crisis in the United States. For over a year, banks would announce billions of dollars in write-downs but with the caveat that non-performing assets had stabilized. They hadn’t, and the TARP rescue program was needed to prevent Bank of America and Citigroup, among others, from failing.

All forecasts inevitably miss to the downside. Attempting to predict future performance is very challenging, so people believe that we should cut bankers a little slack here. Yet, their forecasts during a crisis are always optimistic. No one ever surprises to the upside. This bias tends to prove that optimistic numbers are being issued in an attempt to stabilize the firm’s equity and debt prices.

Despite a poor economic climate, bank management will always claim that the bank is about to return to profitability. Spain and Italy are both mired in recession. Economic contraction reduces demand for financial services while simultaneously raising default rates. Yet, Bankia is convinced that it will post a profit this year. We’ll see.

Banks in the thick of a crisis follow these three rules, which serve as a prelude to nationalization. Based on what we have witnessed so far, how long before Bankia and MPB become wards of the state?

Feb 28, 2013 1:13pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.