SAP's cloud computing push stalls in Asia

FRANKFURT Fri Apr 19, 2013 6:06am EDT

Logo of German company SAP is pictured at the CeBit computer fair in Hanover, March, 6, 2012. The biggest fair of its kind will run to March 10, 2012. REUTERS/Fabian Bimmer

Logo of German company SAP is pictured at the CeBit computer fair in Hanover, March, 6, 2012. The biggest fair of its kind will run to March 10, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Fabian Bimmer

Related Topics

FRANKFURT (Reuters) - SAP AG's Asian business stumbled at the start of 2013 when top sales managers left the business software company, giving rivals an edge just as customers were switching from hardware to cloud computing.

The German company vowed to get its Asia Pacific business back on track after the problems pushed its first-quarter earnings and revenue below analyst forecasts. Its shares fell 2.8 percent on Friday.

SAP and rivals such as IBM and Oracle are dashing to meet surging demand for cloud computing, which allows clients to reduce costs by ditching bulky and costly servers for network-based software and storage in remote data centers.

With the cloud services market forecast to grow 18.5 percent this year to $131 billion worldwide, according to research firm Gartner, competition is fierce and software firms face a challenge to adapt.

"We had some leadership changes in the region. That is why we saw some misses in the quarter," said SAP's co-Chief Executive Jim Hagemann Snabe.

He promised the Asia Pacific region would be back on track in the second quarter as the sales pipeline looked good and important sales positions were now taken care of.

SAP shares were down 2.8 percent at 57.95 euros by 0932 GMT, while a broader index of European technology companies was down 0.7 percent.

The biggest disappointment in SAP's quarterly results was SAP's performance in the Asia Pacific Japan region (APJ), said Stacy Pollard, an analyst at JP Morgan.

Its software and cloud subscription revenue there declined 7 percent, lagging the Americas, where revenue jumped 49 percent, and Europe, the Middle East and Africa, where it grew 13 percent.

"While weakness from other software and IT services names over the last month had already pushed down expectations (and the SAP share price), we would still expect another 3 to 4 percent correction to shares today," Pollard said.


SAP software helps companies to manage supplies, human resources and customers relations. It is reducing its reliance on traditional business software to become a major player in cloud computing.

Snabe said the industry was transforming as customers turned to web-based software products.

"Hardware is in trouble," he told Reuters Insider.

SAP faces competition in Internet-based software from IBM and Oracle and nimbler rivals like Inc and Workday Inc. It spent $7.7 billion last year to buy Internet-based computing companies Ariba and SuccessFactors.

Its main competitor, Oracle, reported a 2 percent drop in software sales in its fiscal third-quarter ended in February.

SAP said it had snatched market share from Oracle and others as customers turn to cloud services, which are seen as less vulnerable to the global economic downturn as there are no upfront costs for program licenses, hardware or installation.

SAP said it still expected operating profit this year to be 5.85 billion to 5.95 billion euros ($7.65-7.78 billion) at constant currencies, up 12-14 percent from 5.21 billion in 2012.

"Given the ... weak results from competitors, we would not overemphasize the first-quarter results," said Oliver Finger, an analyst at DZ Bank, who rates the stock a "buy". "Moreover, the first quarter is traditionally the least important quarter for SAP and the company remains confident overall."

SAP's first-quarter operating profit excluding special items rose 8 percent to 901 million euros, missing an average forecast of 968 million in a Reuters poll of analysts.

Revenue was also up 8 percent at 3.64 billion euros, but missed even the most pessimistic estimate in the Reuters poll, where individual estimates ranged from 3.73 to 3.9 billion.

(Editing by Christoph Steitz and Tom Pfeiffer)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (2)
nose2066 wrote:
News story: “….ditching bulky and costly servers for network-based software and storage in remote data centers.”

The servers are expensive, but the big cost is in managing those servers – the staff costs.

The problem with any cloud computing system is: “Do you know where your data is? Do you know who has access to it? Do you know if the data is backed-up so that it is actually retrievable?”

I have had some exposure to “disaster recovery exercises” in a large enterprise setting. You pretend that there has been a “disaster” in your main computing facility and you attempt to restore your data at another (back-up) site. Sometimes that works and sometimes it doesn’t.

Apr 19, 2013 7:53pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
BrokenToaster wrote:
Cloud computing, equivalent to putting all eggs in one basket. I understand that cloud computing is cheaper, but I never liked the idea of storing YOUR data on ANOTHER person/companies system. Just like using your employer’s internet for personal e-mail, wouldn’t the Cloud company have the same right to your information whether private or not. (since you are using their service). Also, if you create work and store it on their cloud server do you lose rights to that work? (I ask because as a student, all papers we turn in are submitted to a database (to prevent selling the papers) and we lose the rights to our papers. (Meaning the students need the company/schools consent before they can publish their own written work). Is it the same with cloud-computing? Ether way, I prefer my own home network and pc over a dummy/work-station with constant reliance on internet. I guess I am just old school.

Apr 20, 2013 8:56pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.