Shell feared disaster days before Alaska rig grounding: official

ANCHORAGE, Alaska Tue May 21, 2013 4:08am EDT

A Shell logo is seen at a petrol station in London January 31, 2013. REUTERS/Luke MacGregor

A Shell logo is seen at a petrol station in London January 31, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Luke MacGregor

Related Topics

ANCHORAGE, Alaska (Reuters) - Days before a Shell drillship went aground in the storm-tossed Gulf of Alaska, it was clear that towing failures could spell disaster for the vessel, the crew and the marine environment, a company official told a U.S. Coast Guard panel on Monday.

The Kulluk, having completed preliminary drilling on an exploration well in the Beaufort Sea, broke away from its tow lines, and support vessels attempting to regain control of the drillship developed their own engine and mechanical problems, Norman Custard, Royal Dutch Shell's Alaska emergency response leader, told the panel.

Custard said he began planning for a crew evacuation on December 27, four days before the Kulluk grounded off Kodiak Island.

"My first and foremost concern was those 18 people on board," Custard said in the opening day of the Coast Guard hearing into the grounding, which capped an Arctic drilling season so filled with setbacks that Shell delayed further operations until next year.

Crew members were eventually evacuated by a Coast Guard helicopter on December 29, he said.

Shell has spent at least $4.5 billion since 2005 acquiring offshore Arctic leases and preparing to explore in remote basins believed to hold vast oil riches. But the company has yet to complete an exploration well in either the Beaufort Sea, off northern Alaska, or the Chukchi, off the northwestern coast. Legal, environmental and marine woes have stalled its progress.

Shell still has no timeline for when it will resume drilling, after saying in February that it would not drill in 2013, said company spokesman Curtis Smith, who was at Monday's hearing.

The hearing, expected to last two weeks, will delve into the series of maritime mishaps that culminated in the Kulluk grounding, Coast Guard officials said. It is part of a formal marine-casualty investigation launched in January by Rear Admiral Thomas Ostebo, head of the Coast Guard in Alaska.

"This is not a criminal investigation. This is simply a fact-finding mission," said Coast Guard Petty Officer Kip Wadlow.

Other probes may result in civil or criminal charges. The Department of Justice is considering sanctions for violations that other agencies say occurred on both of Shell's Arctic drillships. A Department of Interior investigation of its entire Alaska drilling program has already led to recommendations for new and stricter Arctic-specific regulations.

Shell's second Alaska drillship, the Noble Discoverer, was cited by the Coast Guard and Environmental Protection Agency for numerous safety and environmental deficiencies. The two rigs are getting repaired in separate shipyards in Asia.

ConocoPhillips has shelved drilling plans for 2014 at its Chukchi leases. Statoil, which also has Chukchi leases, has yet to present a drilling plan to U.S. authorities.

The Coast Guard's Kulluk investigation is expected to take months to conclude, Petty Officer Wadlow said.

Other Shell officials will testify in coming days, as will officials from its contractors and other groups. The Department of Interior's Bureau of Safety and Environment Enforcement and the National Transportation Safety Board are also participating.

(Editing by Braden Reddall)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (1)
User21 wrote:
this one will go down with the other breaking news headlines from the past weather and whether it is natural gas or oil, prices and disasters are connected…..

US GAS: Futures Drop To Fresh 10-Year Low After Storage…

Wall Street Journal – Apr 19, 2012

By David Bird Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES NEW YORK (Dow Jones)–Natural gas futures prices dropped to fresh 10-year lows at mid-morning Thursday after US …
Natural gas futures hold slim gains,…‎ National Post
US GAS: Futures Near Flat After Tuesday’…‎ Fox Business
Natural gas price hits another 10-year…‎ BusinessWeek
National Post – CBS News
all 24 news articles »

Natural gas futures drop 10% in trading – Toledo Blade

Toledo Blade – Dec 28, 2005

As Columbia Gas of Ohio prepares to implement its highest rate request ever, natural gas futures plunged 10 percent yesterday, the largest one-day drop in …
Wow Lodlness Business .Natural Gas…‎ Lodi News-Sentinel
Natural Gas Has Biggest Drop in Almost…‎ Bloomberg
Associated Press Archive: Natural gas…‎ Associated Press Archive ($2.95)
Bangor Daily News – Buffalo News
all 37 news articles »

Natural gas futures drop nearly 5% – MarketWatch

MarketWatch – Dec 9, 2005

SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) — Natural-gas futures fell nearly 5% Friday, retreating from record levels above $15 that were brought on by winter weather, …

US GAS: Futures Drop Sharply As Supply Glut Weighs On…

Wall Street Journal – Jan 31, 2012

By Christian Berthelsen Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES NEW YORK (Dow Jones)–Natural gas futures Tuesday plummeted 7.8%, the biggest one-day percentage decline in …
Exxon Mobil profit grows despite natural…‎ Houston Chronicle
US GAS: Futures Settle 4.8% Lower Ahead…‎ Wall Street Journal
US GAS: Futures Continue Slide On Warm…‎ Wall Street Journal
all 12 news articles »

Oil Falls More Than $5 as Natural Gas Tumbles, Economy…

Bloomberg – Jul 17, 2008

Natural gas dropped more than 7 percent after a government report showed that … Futures are up 75 percent from a year ago. Futures have dropped almost $18 …
Oil, natural gas prices still falling:…‎ Herald-Times
Natural gas tumbles, oil follows – The…‎ Boston Globe
Oil price dips $15 in 3 days; natural…‎ Sarasota Herald-Tribune
Commodity Online – Fox News
all 97 news articles »

US gas: Futures drop as traders focus on demand decline…

Dairy Herd Management – Sep 2, 2011

NEW YORK (Dow Jones)–US natural gas futures plummeted Friday, declining for the second straight day as cooler East Coast weather forecasts and weak …

Natural Gas Futures Drop After Bigger-Than-Forecast Supply…

BusinessWeek – Sep 30, 2010

30 (Bloomberg) — Natural gas futures fell, capping a second quarterly decline in the past three quarters, after a government report showed that US …
Natural Gas Premium Drops to Record Low…‎ BusinessWeek
all 7 news articles »

Natural Gas Futures Drop as Data Shows Weaker Industrial…

BusinessWeek – May 17, 2011

By Christine Buurma and Moming Zhou May 17 (Bloomberg) — Natural gas futures slipped in New York for the first time in four days on concern that demand for …
Natural gas futures tumble on reduced…‎ Stock Markets Review
Natural Gas Futures Advance on Outlook…‎ BusinessWeek
US gas: Natural gas futures retreat,…‎ Dairy Herd Management
OIL Marketer – National Post
all 11 news articles »

Natural Gas Futures Drop as US Inventories Rise to Record -…

BusinessWeek – Nov 10, 2010

10 (Bloomberg) — Natural gas futures fell for the first time in five days after a government report showed that US stockpiles rose to a record last week. …

Natural gas, oil futures drop –

Boston Globe – Jan 6, 2006

January 06, 2006|AP WASHINGTON — Natural gas futures fell to a 4 1/2-month low yesterday, beaten down for the third straight day because of a mild start to …
New York Gas Falls a 3rd Day, Below…‎ Bloomberg
Natural gas down 7% at close on…‎ MarketWatch
Oil slips below $63 following inventory…‎ CNNMoney
all 12 news articles »

Crude oil falls over $2; natural gas drops – MarketWatch

MarketWatch – Dec 13, 2007

By Moming Zhou SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) — Crude-oil futures dropped more … Natural-gas futures also fell although data showed US inventories fell for …
Oil retreats over $2 from previous…‎ MarketWatch
all 55 news articles »

Natural-gas futures drop as much as 7% – MarketWatch

MarketWatch – Feb 12, 2007

SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) — March natural gas dropped to a low of $7.29 per million British thermal units Monday, dropping nearly 7% to touch its lowest …

Crude oil futures drop after crossing $135 a barrel -… – May 23, 2008

June natural gas futures rose 5.7 cents to settle at $11.697 per 1000 cubic feet . The Energy Department said natural gas inventories rose last week by 85 …

Natural Gas Futures Drop in New York, Reversing 2.2%…

BusinessWeek – Mar 15, 2012

By Naureen S. Malik on March 15, 2012 Natural gas for April delivery on the New York Mercantile Exchange fell 0.2 cent to $2.282 per million British thermal …
US GAS: Futures Gain As US Gas Inventori…‎ Wall Street Journal
US GAS: Futures End Down A Tad After…‎ Wall Street Journal
US GAS: Futures Fall Ahead Of Gas Invent…‎ Wall Street Journal
Reuters – Reuters
all 18 news articles »

Natural Gas Futures Drop After Report Shows Production Gain…

BusinessWeek – Jan 28, 2011

28 (Bloomberg) — Natural gas futures declined in New York after the Energy Department said US production of the fuel rose for a fourth month in November. …

Natural Gas Futures Drop After Report Shows Ample Supplies …

BusinessWeek – Dec 9, 2010

9 (Bloomberg) — Natural gas futures dropped from a four-month high after a government report showed adequate supplies of the heating fuel to meet …
Natural Gas Declines for Second Day as…‎ Bloomberg
all 6 news articles »

Oil Futures Drop Despite Lower Inventories – TheStreet – Sep 12, 2009

Prices on the January contract slumped as much as 3.4% before dropping $1.95, or 2.7%, … January natural gas futures had strengthened in recent days, …
US Natural Gas Fund Short Selling Rises…‎ Bloomberg
all 26 news articles »

Natural Gas Futures Drop After All-time High .

Today’s News-Herald – Sep 2, 2000

In other markets, natural gas futures fell after briefly touching an all-time high and gold rose. An extended heat wave and prospects for more of the same …

Oil touches one-month low on jobs report Futures Movers -…

MarketWatch – Jul 2, 2009

August crude futures dropped $2.58, or 3.7%, to settle at $66.73 a barrel on the … Meanwhile, natural-gas futures also fell Thursday after data showed US …

Oil futures drop, log small weekly gain – MarketWatch

MarketWatch – Aug 26, 2005

Storm worries helped lift the benchmark contract for natural-gas futures above $10 … But prices dropped $1.36, or 2%, late in the session to close at a …

Natural-gas futures drop 7%; crude ends 2% lower – MarketWat…

MarketWatch – Jan 25, 2007

SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) — February natural gas closed at a nearly one-week low of $6.905 per million British thermal units Thursday, down 51.6 cents, …

US GAS: Futures Drop On Modest Inventory Decline –

Wall Street Journal – Feb 9, 2012

By Jerry A. DiColo Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES NEW YORK (Dow Jones)–Natural gas futures turned lower Thursday after a government report showed a modest drop in …
Crude oil futures drop on Greek jitters…‎ MarketWatch
US GAS: Futures Rise On Forecasts For…‎ Wall Street Journal
UPDATE 3-US natgas futures mostly end…‎ Reuters UK
all 13 news articles »

Crude futures gain, but natural-gas prices drop – MarketWatc…

MarketWatch – Dec 20, 2006

At the same time, natural-gas futures dropped to a fresh, two-year low under $7 per million British thermal units on the eve of a government supply update. …

Natural Gas Futures Drop After Bigger-Than-Forecast Supply…

BusinessWeek – May 26, 2011

By Moming Zhou May 26 (Bloomberg) — Natural gas futures dropped from a three- week high after a government report showed that US inventories increased more …

… Press Archive : Crude prices fall as US supplies build;…

$2.95 –
Associated Press Archive – Sep 29, 2004

Contributing to the drop in prices was word of a tentative agreement between the … Meantime, the price of natural gas futures surged, rising by nearly 9 …

Forecasts Of A Warming Send Gas Futures Down .

Toledo Blade – Jan 3, 2001

The decline was the biggest oneday drop in the 11 years that nat ural gas futures have been traded on the New York Mercantile Exchange. Natural gas for …

Natural gas down 3.8% as supply drop less than expected -…

MarketWatch – Mar 4, 2010

The natural-gas futures contract for April delivery fell 18 cents, or 3.8%, … to end at $2.23 a gallon, while heating oil futures also dropped 2 cents, …
Natural-gas and crude-oil futures finish…‎ MarketWatch
NYMEX-Crude down on dollar’s rise,…‎ Reuters UK
all 64 news articles »

Crude halts two-day drops; natural gas up on inventories…

MarketWatch – Feb 7, 2008

1, more than a drop of 170 billion cubic feet expected by analysts at Global Insight, a research firm. March natural gas futures gained 11.3 cents to $8.107 …

Natural gas rallies as inventories fall for second week -…

MarketWatch – Dec 17, 2009

NEW YORK (MarketWatch) — Natural-gas futures closed more than 5% higher Thursday, after a report showed weekly US stockpiles dropped sharply as cold …
Natural gas jumps on further drop in…‎ MarketWatch

Miami Herald, The : BUSINESS BRIEFS

$2.95 –
Miami Herald – Dec 28, 2005

Natural-gas futures plunged 10 percent Tuesday, settling at their lowest level in three-and-a-half months amid forecasts calling for mild US weather over …

Natural-gas futures end 7% lower; crude prices fall under…

MarketWatch – Jan 25, 2007

By Myra P. Saefong, MarketWatch SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) — Natural-gas futures dropped 7% Thursday, sending the benchmark contract to its lowest level …

Dallas Morning News, The : Gas bills to drop 13%Atmos…

$2.95 –
Dallas Morning News – Oct 11, 2006

Since then, production has recovered, and storage facilities filled up during the summer, causing prices to drop. On Tuesday, natural gas futures closed at …

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel : Natural gas futures surge to…

$2.95 –
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel – Dec 9, 2003

The last time natural gas futures closed at this level was March 7, … activity and the precipitous drop in the value of the dollar this year. …

Crude Futures Drop Slightly

Argus-Press – Jul 10, 2004

August natural gas futures fell cents to 6.141 per 1000 cubic feet. August gasoline futures rose 7.71 cents, or percent, on the week, reaching a month high …

US GAS: Futures Drop On Mild Weather –

Wall Street Journal – Feb 21, 2012

By Jerry A. DiColo Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES NEW YORK (Dow Jones)–Natural gas futures fell Tuesday, retreating after a sharp surge higher last week as traders …
US GAS: Futures Drop As Focus Returns…‎ Wall Street Journal
US GAS: Futures Slip As Storage Data…‎ Wall Street Journal
US GAS: Futures Higher Ahead Of US…‎ Wall Street Journal
CBS News
all 8 news articles »

Natural-gas futures tumble over 5% – MarketWatch

MarketWatch – Aug 21, 2009

September natural-gas futures dropped 15.50 cents, or 5.2%, to $2.791 per million British thermal units in electronic trading on Globex. …
Natural-gas futures tumble 5.6% to end…‎ MarketWatch
Natural-gas futures tumble to end at 7…‎ MarketWatch
CORRECT: Oil rises; natural-gas prices…‎ MarketWatch
all 11 news articles »

Crude futures drop amid clouds over Wall Street – MarketWatc…

MarketWatch – Jan 28, 2010

On Thursday, natural-gas futures fell after the Energy Department said US inventories of natural gas fell by 86 billion cubic feet in the week ended Jan. …

Enterprise’s Repair of Independence Pipeline May Cut Gas…

Bloomberg – Jun 4, 2008

After Enterprise announced the resumption of service yesterday, natural gas futures dropped as much as 1.6 percent to $12.06. “With crude oil backing down …

Natural Gas Futures Decline on Forecasts of Milder Weather …

BusinessWeek – Jan 27, 2011

27 (Bloomberg) — Natural gas futures dropped for a third day in four in New York on signs of milder weather that may limit demand for the heating fuel. …
Natural Gas Drops for a Third Day on…‎ BusinessWeek
Natural Gas Futures Fall to Four-Week…‎ BusinessWeek
Natural Gas Futures Rise First Day in…‎ BusinessWeek
BusinessWeek – BusinessWeek

May 21, 2013 9:10am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.


California's historic drought

With reservoirs at record lows, California is in the midst of the worst drought in decades.  Slideshow