Exclusive: China tried to convince North Korea to give up nuclear tests - source

BEIJING Tue Jun 4, 2013 6:54am EDT

Choe Ryong-hae (C), director of the General Political Bureau of the Korean People's Army (KPA) of North Korea, walks with Chinese Ambassador Liu Hongcai (2nd R) before departing Pyongyang airport for China, in this May 22, 2013 picture released by the North Korea's KCNA news agency in Pyongyang. REUTERS/KCNA

Choe Ryong-hae (C), director of the General Political Bureau of the Korean People's Army (KPA) of North Korea, walks with Chinese Ambassador Liu Hongcai (2nd R) before departing Pyongyang airport for China, in this May 22, 2013 picture released by the North Korea's KCNA news agency in Pyongyang.

Credit: Reuters/KCNA

BEIJING (Reuters) - China told an envoy of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un that Pyongyang should stop conducting nuclear and missile tests, but the North showed little sign of heeding the request, said a source with knowledge of the talks held late last month.

Kim dispatched Choe Ryong-hae, vice chairman of the country's top military body, to explain North Korea's recent actions but he got a lukewarm reception from his Chinese hosts, said the source, who has close ties to Beijing and Pyongyang.

North Korea's 30-year-old leader took power in December 2011 and has carried out two long-range rocket launches and a nuclear weapons test since then. He also embarked on a months-long campaign of threats against South Korea and the United States.

"(North) Korea has not mellowed," said the source, who did not attend the meetings but has since spoken to both sides to which he has regular access.

Choe, nominally a general but with no known military experience, is the Korean People's Army's top ideologue. He showed up in Beijing in full military regalia, in contrast to his suited Chinese counterparts.

Experts have said the three-day visit was an attempt by North Korea to mend fences with its only major diplomatic ally, which has been critical of Pyongyang.

After the meetings, in which Choe eventually held talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping, North Korea promised to take "positive steps for peace" while China repeated its mantra of wanting "calm and restraint" on the Korean peninsula.

FOCUS ON ECONOMY, NORTH TOLD

Beijing tried to convince Pyongyang to stop its nuclear and missile tests, which "put China in a difficult position and are not conducive to (North) Korea", the source said. China advised North Korea to focus on rebuilding its ruined economy instead, something it has said before.

North Korea's recent actions drew international condemnation and put Beijing under pressure, especially from Washington, to rein in Pyongyang. It also helped reinforce an American strategy of rebalancing its security policies toward the Asia-Pacific.

China is North Korea's biggest trade partner and aid donor. Choe was shown a special enterprise zone during his visit, but he did not raise the issue of aid during his talks, the source added.

Asked if Pyongyang had agreed to halt nuclear tests, the source said that for the North: "It hinges on necessity."

North Korea has repeatedly said it will never abandon its nuclear weapons, calling them its "treasured sword".

The source did not say if Beijing spelt out any consequences should the North conduct further tests.

Choe met officials from the Chinese government, the military and ruling Communist Party.

China has grown increasingly frustrated with Pyongyang. It agreed to new U.N. sanctions after Pyongyang's latest nuclear test in February, and Chinese banks have curbed business with their North Korean counterparts in the wake of U.S. sanctions on the country's main foreign exchange bank.

A former senior U.S. official said Beijing's insistence that North Korea halt testing would be in line with recent signs it was running out of patience with Pyongyang.

"What I've heard from talking to Chinese officials and American officials who are talking to them is that top Chinese officials now emphasize that the principal goal is to terminate the nuclear weapons program of North Korea," the ex-official said.

"Usually, in the past that's been buried (by the Chinese)."

Choe presented a hand-written letter from Kim to Xi. Chinese media gave no details of its contents at the time, but the source close to Pyongyang and Beijing described it as "terse".

Kim stressed in his letter that "the traditional friendship created by the older generation of revolutionary leaders should not waver at any time", said the source.

China has backed North Korea since Mao Zedong sent Chinese troops to bolster Communist forces under then North Korean leader Kim Il-sung - Kim Jong-un's grandfather - during the 1950-53 Korean war.

The nuclear and rocket tests and verbal threats were partly aimed at forcing the United States and South Korea to sign a permanent peace treaty with North Korea to replace the armistice agreement that ended that conflict, the source said.

HANDSHAKES, NOT HUGS

North Korea felt the reception Choe got was lukewarm, said the source. It was the most important visit to China by a North Korean delegation since the young Kim's uncle, a kingmaker among Pyongyang's ruling elite, visited Beijing in late 2012.

"There was no bear hug between Wang Jiarui and Choe when they met," the source noted, referring to the Chinese Communist Party's International Department minister, who is responsible for dealing with foreign political parties. Such greetings have been a tradition between North Korean and Chinese leaders, who once saw their relationship as "close as lips and teeth".

China has repeatedly urged North Korea to return to the so-called six-party talks, which are aimed at getting Pyongyang to give up its nuclear weapons.

Choe told the Chinese this format did not work. In 2009, Pyongyang said it would never return to the talks, which also included South Korea, the United States, Japan and Russia.

North Korea would instead seek bilateral talks with the various parties first, said the source, without elaborating.

Abandoning its nuclear weapons program could not be a prerequisite for talks, Choe told his hosts.

That makes talks with Washington a non-starter since U.S. officials say North Korea must take meaningful steps on denuclearization before there can be dialogue.

KIM FIRMLY IN CHARGE, CHINESE TOLD

Choe told his Chinese hosts that Kim had consolidated his power since the death of his father, Kim Jong-il, in December 2011, through the weapons tests and war threats that saw Pyongyang put its armed forces on alert this year.

There has been repeated speculation that the North's young leader had been challenged by some elements in the military, although these assessments have been impossible to verify given the closed nature of North Korea.

"Through mobilizing troops, Kim Jong-un wanted to see who obeyed and who refused to obey his command," the source said.

Just under a year ago, Kim ousted Vice Marshal Ri Yong-ho, North Korea's leading military figure, as army chief of staff. A couple of days later North Korean media named Kim as marshal of the army.

"Many (officers) have been rounded up or sacked. Ri Yong-ho was arrested on counter-revolutionary crimes," the source said. He declined to say if Ri was jailed or executed.

"There had been some opposition to Kim Jong-un when he was named marshal. He has gotten rid of this."

(Additional reporting by Matt Spetalnick in Washington. Writing by Dean Yates. Editing by David Chance and Mark Bendeich)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (5)
breezinthru wrote:
I don’t believe very much of what China and North Korea are saying. North Korea could not have made such rapid advances in expertise without China’s direct assistance. Neither could it have produced the equipment it needed in order to fill a vast underground centrifuge center.

Apparently, no one at the State Department is confronting them regarding the past, but it should be an indication that what they are saying now is just the new cover story.

If China is willing to cut of all aid including food aid
1. if there is another test or
2. if another long range missile test occurs or
3. if China’s intelligence service determines that the nuclear weapons program is continuing

then I will believe what China is saying.

Until then, I will believe what North Korea is saying, that they will never give up their Treasured Sword.

For now, I think China is lying.

Jun 04, 2013 9:05am EDT  --  Report as abuse
emu wrote:
I think china is getting seriously pissed off now.

Yes, preventing a US from dominating china’s backyard is a valid strategic goal and, so far, north korea has played that role by preventing a unified US friendly korea from existing.

But if north korea becomes /the cause/ for ever more or larger US fleets in the south china sea and a more capable and US integrated military in south korea, china may come to the conclusion that a unified but lightly armed korea weakens US dominance more than a rabid north korea.

Jun 04, 2013 10:08am EDT  --  Report as abuse
ARJTurgot2 wrote:
I believe all that is here, it’s what’s not here that is significant. The saber rattling has been consistent with an internal dispute, a consolidation of power. And China won’t act directly, that’s not its style and Kim is still useful. But other people in NK can also be useful. Kim either sucks it up and obeys, or he’s gone inside a year.

Jun 04, 2013 10:13am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

Full focus