Analysis: As China's economic pain increases, so does reform effort

BEIJING Sun Jul 14, 2013 5:22pm EDT

Construction workers wait for a bus after their workday at Pudong financial district in Shanghai July 8, 2013. China's resolve to revamp its economy for the long-term good will be tested this month when a slew of data show growth is grinding towards a 23-year low, with no recovery in sight. REUTERS/Carlos Barria

Construction workers wait for a bus after their workday at Pudong financial district in Shanghai July 8, 2013. China's resolve to revamp its economy for the long-term good will be tested this month when a slew of data show growth is grinding towards a 23-year low, with no recovery in sight.

Credit: Reuters/Carlos Barria

Related Topics

BEIJING (Reuters) - China's reform-minded leaders are more willing than ever to raise the pain threshold for the economy to push through long-term reforms, despite a protracted slowdown that has sparked calls for looser monetary policy.

Grim trade data for June last week fanned market talk of fresh steps to support an economy heading for its weakest growth this year in more than two decades. They increased after remarks by Premier Li Keqiang that the government will safeguard the "lower limits" for economic growth and employment and could be fuelled further by GDP data later on Monday.

But Beijing has no plans to budge.

Financial markets may have underestimated the leadership's tolerance for slower growth as it pushes to wean the economy off a reliance on exports and investment with reforms and deregulation to encourage more consumption, analysts say.

"The focus is still on reforms," said Xu Hongcai, senior economist at the China Centre for International Economic Exchanges (CCIEE), a well-connected think-tank in Beijing.

"The chances of a cut in interest rates or banks' reserve ratio look slim," Xu said. "Previously, when the economy was not good, local officials held out their hands for money from the central government. But now they have to embrace reforms as no money will be given."

Finance Minister Lou Jiwei appeared to back that view in comments last week, suggesting the government would not step in as it has done in the past.

"Structural adjustment is a painful thing," Lou was quoted by the semi-official China News Service as saying on the sidelines of U.S.-China talks in Washington. "It's impossible to adjust structures if you still want to feel very comfortable and maintain a very high growth rate."

However, Lou also sowed confusion over where the government's bottom line on growth might be. He was reported by the official Xinhua news agency on Friday as saying the 2013 target was 7 percent, implying a level below the official goal of 7.5 percent. However, the Xinhua report was later changed to show Lou said 7.5 percent.

Figures later on Monday are expected to show economic growth slipped in the April-June quarter to 7.5 percent from 7.7 percent in the previous quarter. Growth has already slowed in eight of the last nine quarters, data shows, as the economy hits the brakes after three decades of double-digit expansion.

"Even if we get some negative data surprise," said Wei Yao, China economist at Societe Generale in Hong Kong, "it wouldn't really change the policy stance immediately."

Many analysts believe the government will step in to support the economy if year-on-year growth slips in a quarter to 7 percent.

But Capital Economics argues the government is no longer so fixated on targets, noting that the 2013 target is "about 7.5 percent", not strictly 7.5 percent.

"If Lou was confused, this perhaps tells us something about how strictly we should interpret the annual growth target," it said in a note. "Officials may simply be less concerned with meeting the target than they were in the past".

What might change the government's mind is a sudden increase in the number of jobless. For now though government officials have said employment is stable, citing the fast-growing services sector and a demographic shift that reduces surplus rural workers.


Last month, President Xi Jinping said local government officials will not be judged solely on their record in boosting GDP but by achievements in improving people's livelihoods, social development and environmental quality.

Last week, the cabinet announced new measures to choke off fresh funding for industries gripped by excess capacity, channeling more funding towards advanced industries.

Premier Li, during a recent trip to southern Guangxi region, also said that the government will focus on reforms so long as growth stays within a reasonable range.

Ting Lu, an economist at Bank of America/Merrill Lynch, said one reason behind the government's resolve is that it is still dealing with the lingering hangover of a 4 trillion yuan ($652 billion) stimulus package implemented in 2008-2009, which resulted in piles of local government debt.

"For Premier Li and his cabinet, they will have to complete the unfinished 'exit strategy' in their first couple of years. In this regard, 'deleveraging' is unavoidable," he said in a research report.

If needed, Beijing has ample room to expand fiscal spending, by tapping into a war chest of about 3 trillion yuan ($488 billion) in savings, he said. It also has room to expand its fiscal deficit beyond the 2013 target of 2 percent, he said.

Finance Minister Lou has also said Beijing is juggling some budgets, cutting general expenditure and using the savings to cut taxes and promote employment.


A recent interbank cash crunch underscored the central bank's reluctance to pump more money into the economy. Banks have been told to better use the existing credit through financial innovations such as asset securitization.

"The liquidity crunch raised the government's concerns about financial risks and the problem of credit mis-allocation," said Zhang Bin, an economist at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS), a top think-tank in Beijing.

High on Beijing's reform agenda is to liberalize interest rates, which proponents say would help resolve deep-seated financial distortions, including a sprawling non-bank lending industry.

China's rigidly controlled interest rate regime is a major factor behind the rapid rise of shadow banking, as it suppresses returns on bank deposits, spurring savers to plow cash into higher-yielding off-balance-sheet wealth management products.

On the other hand, state firms with easier access to bank loans have relending the money they raise to cash-starved private businesses at much higher interest rates, fanning shadow banking activity.

As a vital step paving the way for freeing up rates, the government is set to unveil a long-awaited deposit insurance system later this year despite resistance from some state banks.

"The interest rate reform will be pushed forward. Banks' concerns won't stop it," said Guo Tianyong, an economist at Central University of Finance and Economics in Beijing.

An insurance system is seen as laying a foundation for interest rate liberalization, as a market-oriented interest rate could make smaller banks unable to compete with larger, better funded rivals, potentially putting depositors at risk.

The government may remove the floor on bank lending rates and further raise the ceiling on deposit rates, analysts say.

The key factor that will indicate a change in government thinking, analysts say, is if the slide in economic growth leads to big job losses. That could set off alarm bells for policymakers, worried about any threats to social stability.

"They face a dilemma - increasing leveraging will fuel debt risks. But if you allow the economy to slow further, the jobless problem will occur sooner or later," said Zhang at the CASS.

($1=6.14 yuan)

(Editing by Neil Fullick)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (15)
w3cubed wrote:
With the US annualized growth rate at 1.8% and the world’s around 3% China with a target around 7% without major unemployment problems looks damn good. That combined with goals like bettering livelihoods, care for the environment, and lowering taxes from a current western perspective looks similar to paradise, no?

Perhaps it’s time to reconsider where we’re going.

Jul 14, 2013 7:13pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Godzilla1960 wrote:
In the 1980s many Americans were in a panic about the inevitable dominance of the Japanese economy.

The Japanese economic bubble burst in 1991 and what followed was more than a decade of stagnation.

In this decade the new boogie-man for Americans is China. China is destined to be the next economic giant of the world, replacing the U.S.

Well, China is new at this capitalism business. It is lots of good times and fun during the boom. Let’s see how well they handle the bust.

Jul 14, 2013 7:19pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
Oro_Invictus wrote:
All of these reforms, thus far, have been relatively easy in comparison to end-term goals; that the CPC is patting itself on the back for this in spite of worsening economic conditions is not inspiring, to say the least. That they’re also touting their “far-sightedness” while engaging in an urbanization drive which, if “successful”, will result in an ecologically and socially unsustainable populace (the very image of “short-sightedness”) is mind boggling. Then again, logic never has been the CPC’s strong suit.

Jul 14, 2013 9:15pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

Track China's Leaders