House Republicans favor helping children of illegal immigrants

WASHINGTON Tue Jul 23, 2013 7:37pm EDT

A man stands behind a banner at a 24-hour vigil calling on Congress to pass immigration reform in Los Angeles, June 27, 2013. REUTERS/Lucy Nicholson

A man stands behind a banner at a 24-hour vigil calling on Congress to pass immigration reform in Los Angeles, June 27, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Lucy Nicholson

Related Topics

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Republicans in the House of Representatives started to coalesce on Tuesday around the idea of legalizing the children who were brought to the country by their parents, marking their first step toward dealing with the millions of undocumented foreigners living in the United States.

Under pressure from members of their own party, religious groups and Hispanics, House Republicans are bucking their traditional position of opposing citizenship for illegal immigrants, saying those children should be given a reprieve.

"They surely don't share the culpability of their parents," House Judiciary Committee Chairman Bob Goodlatte said at a hearing to examine the issue.

But Goodlatte, whose committee is in charge of writing immigration laws, made it clear he did not think the parents should get a pass.

"I do not believe that parents who made the decision to illegally enter the U.S. while forcing their children to join them should be afforded the same treatment as these kids," he said.

The majority of Republican lawmakers believe that giving the illegal immigrant population a route to citizenship is akin to rewarding lawbreakers. Although they agree with Democrats that the country's immigration system does not work, they are deeply divided on how to change the laws.

Of the estimated 11 million foreigners living in the country illegally, around 2 million entered under the age of 16, experts have said.

Goodlatte is working with Eric Cantor, the second-ranking Republican in the House, on legislation to give young illegal immigrants a way to earn citizenship, an approach that could be similar to a Democratic bill they voted against in 2010.

Cantor and Goodlatte have not said when they will introduce the legislation, and it is unlikely they will do so before members hear from their constituents during the month-long August break.

They also have not provided details on their bill or said how it might differ from the Senate's treatment of these children as part of a larger immigration bill.

At the House Judiciary subcommittee hearing, Republican after Republican representative spoke about how it was unfair to lump the undocumented youth with their parents, who broke the law when they crossed the border illegally.

SERVING IN THE MILITARY

Jeff Denham of California suggested that the undocumented children be required to serve in the military to earn legal status in the United States, while Ted Poe of Texas called them special children who should be treated in a special way that would bring them into society because they did not have the intent to break the law.

The Republican chairman of the immigration subcommittee, Trey Gowdy, said the children who were brought to the United States have not committed a crime.

The hearing was stacked with witnesses sympathetic to the undocumented youth, a sign of how Republicans' positions have shifted from the last time Washington debated overhauling the immigration system during the George W. Bush administration.

Republican Representative Steve King, who is vehemently opposed to legalizing any of the undocumented foreigners, asked when would the United States start enforcing the law - though he said the illegal youth's plight tugged "at his heart" as well.

TEARING FAMILIES APART

Known as DREAMers, the undocumented children have already rejected the House Republican approach, saying it will tear their families apart and discriminate against the rest of the undocumented population in the United States.

"Our parents sacrificed everything for our future and we will not leave them behind," Cristina Jimenez, 29, whose parents brought her to the United States illegally from Ecuador when she was 13, said outside the hearing room.

Gowdy and fellow Republican Representative Raul Labrador expressed frustration over how the DREAMers were pushing for citizenship for all of the undocumented foreigners. They said there were people that warranted more scrutiny and that other foreigners working in the United States do not automatically become citizens.

The Senate, with the support of 14 Republican members, has already passed an immigration bill that would increase work visas, bolster security at the U.S.-Mexico border and provide a 13-year path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants.

House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi is considering a way to force the House to act on the Senate bill. Speaking to a small group of political donors late on Monday, Pelosi outlined a strategy that would require a minimum of 25 Republicans to join Democrats to move the Senate bill in the House.

It is a strategy that traditionally has been difficult for the minority party in the House to pull off successfully.

(Additional reporting by Roberta Rampton; Editing by Cynthia Osterman,; Eric Walsh and Philip Barbara)

FILED UNDER:
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (31)
Warof2010 wrote:
Are we really that stupid?

First, if citizenship is granted to the children of illegal immigrants, there will be fraud out the gazoo. Illegal immigrants have been living here, using false, and stolen, documents, ever since they arrived in our country. They are masters at beating the system. Why should we even open the door to this bureaucratic nightmare.

Even now, in anticipation of amnesty, the number of illegal immigrants crossing our border is rapidly escalating, with increasing numbers of children among them. So many that the DHS/CBP is refusing to make the numbers available.

Second, to grant the children of illegal immigrants citizenship, with Chain Migration being what it is, the whole family, including their distant relatives, will be here in short order. For every poor, and uneducated, illegal immigrant granted citizenship during the 1986 Amnesty, 5 more, poor, and uneducated relatives followed.

Do we really want to continue importing poverty?

We already have 50 million of our own people in poverty, dependent on our entitlement systems. Why in the world are we thinking about importing even more poor, and uneducated, illegal and legal immigrants, to compete with them for jobs and social benefits?

Are we really that stupid?

citizenship is the highest honor our country can bestow,
reserved for those who follow the rules and wait in line

Jul 23, 2013 2:45pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
xyz2055 wrote:
First off they are already here. Secondly, the U.S. is the only home that those born here have ever known. You would be deporting them to a country that many have never even been to. This is a complex situation and there are no easy answers, unless you’re just a red neck jerk.

Jul 23, 2013 2:52pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
USAPragmatist wrote:
@Warof2010, nice xenophobic rant with no basis in reality, to quote you ‘Even now, in anticipation of amnesty, the number of illegal immigrants crossing our border is rapidly escalating, with increasing numbers of children among them. So many that the DHS/CBP is refusing to make the numbers available. ‘ WRONG, see this link and many others…http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/04/12/america-is-losing-as-many-illegal-immigrants-as-its-gaining/ Net Immigration is negative or zero.

You did have one thing right ‘citizenship is the highest honor our country can bestow,’ To bad we cant revoke it from people like you that demostrate their hate by spreading lies and mistruths. I would rather have a hard-working hispanic have citizenship then people like you.

Jul 23, 2013 2:53pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.