Detroit bankruptcy case heads to Wednesday hearing on challenges

DETROIT Tue Jul 23, 2013 6:14am EDT

1 of 3. A sculptor of a giant fist in honor of American boxer and heavy weight champion Joe Louis sits at the intersection of Woodward and Jefferson Avenue in downtown Detroit, Michigan July 21, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/ Rebecca Cook

Related Topics

DETROIT (Reuters) - Labor unions trying to stop Detroit from cutting pensions filed a new challenge to the city in bankruptcy court as the federal judge overseeing the case said he would hear arguments on Wednesday.

U.S. Bankruptcy Court Judge Steven Rhodes agreed on Monday to a request by Detroit Emergency Manager Kevyn Orr to fast track a hearing on whether other courts can hear lawsuits against Detroit, while it seeks federal bankruptcy court protection.

Concerned that retirement benefits will be slashed, Detroit retirees, workers and pension funds have filed three lawsuits, including one backed by the United Auto Workers union, in state court in an effort to derail the biggest Chapter 9 municipal bankruptcy in U.S. history.

A Michigan court judge, for instance, has ordered Orr to withdraw the July 18 bankruptcy filing.

The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Council 25, which represents about 70 percent of Detroit's civilian workforce, on Monday argued if the other lawsuits were stopped, Orr, Michigan's governor and others would be able to continue to operate beyond state constitutional authority.

However, many legal experts said they expect Judge Rhodes to put the other cases on hold.

"Federal bankruptcy law generally trumps state law," and is designed to do so, said Stuart Gold, a Detroit-based bankruptcy lawyer at Gold Lange & Majoros PC.


If Orr's request to put those lawsuits on hold is granted, top Michigan state officials, Orr and others would also be protected from litigation regarding last Thursday's bankruptcy petition.

Detroit, a former manufacturing powerhouse and cradle of the U.S. automotive industry and Motown music, has struggled for decades as companies moved or closed, crime became rampant and its population shriveled by about 25 percent in the past decade to 700,000. The city's revenue failed to keep pace with spending, leading to years of budget deficits and a dependence on borrowing to stay afloat.

To remain in bankruptcy court, Detroit must prove that it is insolvent and that it made a good faith effort to negotiate with its creditors, including its employee pension funds, over the city's more than $18 billion of debt, which includes $5.7 billion in unfunded liabilities for healthcare and other retiree benefits and a $3.5 billion pension liability.

Orr told National Public Radio on Monday that the city is broke. "It doesn't matter what I say, it doesn't matter what we look back on, there's just no money," he said.

AFSCME leaders on Monday said that Orr had rebuffed efforts by unions to discuss the issues.

"Not once, did (Orr's) representatives sit down and seek to negotiate a solution with our union," Steven Kreisberg, national director for collective bargaining for AFSCME, told a news conference.

"Our members and our retirees were never given the opportunity to address the serious issues of the type of cutback that the emergency manager is seeking," he said.

Orr has not specified how much pensions or retiree health care will have to be cut, although his June 14 proposal to creditors called for "significant cuts in accrued, vested pension amounts for both active and currently retired persons."

Orr spokesman Bill Nowling said the unions were never promised negotiations. "We will meet with the unions if they ever put a counterproposal on the table."

Under Michigan's emergency manager law the city was not obligated to negotiate in collective bargaining with the unions, Nowling said. "It's a mischaracterization to say they were promised negotiations."

Pensioners could attempt to appeal to the federal district court any order by Judge Rhodes enforcing the stay of litigation against Detroit. But, because such an order would not be considered a final judgment under bankruptcy laws, the federal court could refuse to hear the appeal, Gold said.

In a declaratory judgment on Friday, Ingham County Circuit Court Judge Rosemarie Aquilina said the state law that allowed Michigan Governor Rick Snyder to approve the bankruptcy filing violated the Michigan Constitution. The governor cannot take actions that would violate constitutional protections for retirement benefits for public workers, she said.

Aquilina on Monday morning adjourned a hearing in another case brought by city pension plans with no action taken. The pension plans asked for the proceedings to be postponed one week to July 29.

The historic bankruptcy filing roiled the $3.7 trillion municipal bond market on Friday, sending prices lower and yields higher on some bonds. But the market, where states and cities like Michigan and Detroit borrow money, settled down and prices barely budged on Monday.

(Additional reporting by Karen Pierog, Jonathan Stempel, Nick Brown and Deepa Seetharaman, writing by Karen Pierog; Editing by Dan Burns, Nick Zieminski and Tim Dobbyn)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
alurlyrx wrote:
Everyone wants to be an exception. Of all the problems with corruption and mismanagement, unions are just as culpable. They asked for too much for too many. Nothing and no one should be an exception from the assets in the art museums to the greedy unions. After all, we’re all equal, remember?

With only 700,000 people left in Detroit, if you don’t live here, you shouldn’t have a say-so in the matter.

Jul 22, 2013 10:07pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
xyz2055 wrote:
This is why about the only place you see pensions any more is in government jobs represented by unions. Only 6% of private sector jobs are unionized today. In the private sector, most companies either provide some kind of 401k matching or actually put money into a side account. With the option to stop those activities if the company gets into financial trouble. This is what the government needs to do. Think of it as “Pay-Go”. They actually pay the money into similar types of accounts as they go along. When you retire whatever money is in those accounts is what you get.

Jul 23, 2013 2:09am EDT  --  Report as abuse
susette wrote:
There are so many reasons for the downfall of Detroit: and it is all the fault of the city Mayor Coleman Young. After that, everyone they elected had the idea that they could take from the coffers anything they wanted. Kilpatrick was only the last of the bunch. A true rat pack of ill-begotten leaders and council members. When you have a corrupt police force, and a dilapidated public safety net, what can be done? The schools are run down, the businesses are bilked for every dime they make, and no one in their right mind wants to come to a minority led hell hole. This used to be my home.

Jul 23, 2013 9:14am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

Full focus