Plea deal still possible in Ariel Castro case of kidnapped women: lawyers

CLEVELAND Wed Jul 24, 2013 12:28pm EDT

1 of 2. Ariel Castro, 53, walks into the court room with his head down for a pre-trial hearing on charges including rape, kidnapping and murder in Cleveland, Ohio July 24, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Aaron Josefczyk

Related Topics

CLEVELAND (Reuters) - An agreement is still possible for former Cleveland school bus driver Ariel Castro to plead guilty to some charges such as kidnapping and rape of three women to avoid a public trial scheduled to start on August 5, lawyers for both sides said on Wednesday.

Castro, 53, is accused of imprisoning and brutalizing the three women in his home for about a decade. He has pleaded not guilty to 977 charges including 512 counts of kidnapping and 446 counts of rape.

He is also accused of aggravated murder for beating and starving one of the women to force her to miscarry, a charge which could carry the death penalty.

Gina DeJesus, 23, Michelle Knight, 32, and Amanda Berry, 27 were freed from Castro's home in a rundown area of Cleveland on May 6, along with a 6-year-old girl Castro fathered with Berry during captivity.

At a hearing on Wednesday, Cuyahoga County Judge Michael Russo asked lawyers for both sides if they were still working toward a possible plea agreement to resolve the case. They replied yes.

Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Tim McGinty said he was ready to go to trial as scheduled on August 5 but lawyers for Castro protested that they would not have enough time to review the evidence against their client.

"How are we supposed to defend this gentleman?" Castro's lawyer Craig Weintraub asked.

Defense lawyers left the court on Wednesday without speaking to reporters, but they have repeatedly said they would like to reach a plea agreement to avoid trial.

Legal experts have said an agreement would avoid putting the three women through the ordeal of testifying to the horrors they allegedly faced during years of confinement.

Michael Benza, former prosecutor and senior lecturer at Case Western Reserve University School of Law, said both sides are "posturing" in the Castro case.

"It (the early trial date) could create a real legal problem for the prosecution. They have to turn over certain evidence to the defense and if it goes to trial without the evidence a conviction can be overturned," Benza said.

Ohio Attorney General, Mike DeWine said the state had tested and turned over 110 pieces of evidence to prosecutors in the case, and are expecting to hand over 62 more items this week.

Of the 110 pieces of evidence turned over, 99 were tested for DNA, 10 for latent prints and 11 underwent firearms-related testing, according to DeWine.

DeWine said all testing essential to the case will be done by August 5.

"This is a priority for this office," DeWine told reporters. "We are paying overtime to get it done."

County prosecutors could still bring another indictment against Castro that includes the death penalty.

(Reporting by Kim Palmer; Editing by Greg McCune and Chris Reese)

FILED UNDER:
We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (3)
CephasKeith wrote:
Castro Girls
It is unreal to think that the three young ladies were held for 10 years against their will. It is inconceivable that over 4,000 or so days there was only one opportunity of escape. This is ludicrous. These ladies are able–bodied. To any reasonable person, there must have been instances when Mr. Castro could have been overpowered whether physically or by some weaponry. There was a kitchen with all sorts of gadgets which could have been used. Mr. Castro must have used the washroom during these 4,000 days which could have been an opportunity to overpower him. One must also consider the other daily routines like cooking. Who did the cooking? This must have been another opportunity to at worst start a fire which would have attracted outside attention and fire emergency. These and other considerations would suggest that these young ladies were not held against their will. Perhaps they were initially but it soon became a consensual arrangement. Mr. Castro and these ladies had a good thing going; it could be an illicit sex arrangement or some other activity from which these ladies benefited until something went very wrong. This is another instant where “the law is an ass”. Imagine almost 1,000 charges against Mr. Castro. His lawyers would certainly have a field day exposing the activities of Castro and his ladies of complicity.

Jul 25, 2013 8:02pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
CephasKeith wrote:
Castro Girls
It is unreal to think that the three young ladies were held for 10 years against their will. It is inconceivable that over 4,000 or so days there was only one opportunity of escape. This is ludicrous. These ladies are able–bodied. To any reasonable person, there must have been instances when Mr. Castro could have been overpowered whether physically or by some weaponry. There was a kitchen with all sorts of gadgets which could have been used. Mr. Castro must have used the washroom during these 4,000 days which could have been an opportunity to overpower him. One must also consider the other daily routines like cooking. Who did the cooking? This must have been another opportunity to at worst start a fire which would have attracted outside attention and fire emergency. These and other considerations would suggest that these young ladies were not held against their will. Perhaps they were initially but it soon became a consensual arrangement. Mr. Castro and these ladies had a good thing going; it could be an illicit sex arrangement or some other activity from which these ladies benefited until something went very wrong. This is another instant where “the law is an ass”. Imagine almost 1,000 charges against Mr. Castro. His lawyers would certainly have a field day exposing the activities of Castro and his ladies of complicity.

Jul 25, 2013 8:02pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
CephasKeith wrote:
Cleveland Kidnap
It is unreal to think that the three young ladies were held for 10 years against their will. It is inconceivable that over 4,000 or so days there was only one opportunity of escape. This is ludicrous. These ladies are able–bodied. To any reasonable person, there must have been instances when Mr. Castro could have been overpowered whether physically or by some weaponry. There was a kitchen with all sorts of gadgets which could have been used. Mr. Castro must have used the washroom during these 4,000 days which could have been an opportunity to overpower him. One must also consider the other daily routines like cooking. Who did the cooking? This must have been another opportunity to at worst start a fire which would have attracted outside attention and fire emergency. These and other considerations would suggest that these young ladies were not held against their will. Perhaps they were initially but it soon became a consensual arrangement. Mr. Castro and these ladies had a good thing going; it could be an illicit sex arrangement or some other activity from which these ladies benefited until something went very wrong. This is another instant where “the law is an ass”. Imagine almost 1,000 charges against Mr. Castro. His lawyers would certainly have a field day exposing the activities of Castro and his ladies of complicity.

Jul 25, 2013 8:02pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.

Pictures