UPDATE 3-EU, China resolve solar dispute - their biggest trade row by far

Sat Jul 27, 2013 8:25am EDT

* EU and China agree minimum import price near spot price

* China allowed to provide almost half EU solar consumption

* Deal follows six weeks of talks to avoid wider trade war

By Robin Emmott and Ben Blanchard

BRUSSELS/BEIJING, July 27 (Reuters) - China and the European Union defused their biggest trade dispute by far on Saturday with a deal to regulate Chinese solar panel imports and avoid a wider war in goods from wine to steel.

After six weeks of talks, the EU's trade chief and his Chinese counterpart sealed the deal over the telephone, setting a minimum price for panels from China near spot market prices.

European solar panel makers accuse China of benefitting from huge state subsidies, allowing them to dump about 21 billion euros ($28 billion) worth of below-cost solar panels in Europe last year, putting European firms out of business.

Other European industries that have accused China of dumping have faced imports of about 1 billion euros a year.

Europe planned to impose hefty tariffs from Aug. 6 but, wary of offending China's leaders and losing business in the world's No. 2 economy, a majority of EU governments - led by Germany - opposed the plan, which led to the compromise deal.

"We found an amicable solution," EU Trade Commissioner Karel De Gucht said. "I am satisfied with the offer of a price undertaking submitted by China's solar panel exporters," he said, referring to the minimum price for China's imports.

Chinese Commerce Ministry Spokesman Shen Danyang welcomed the deal, hailing a "positive and highly constructive outcome".

An EU diplomatic source said that in the solar agreement, the agreed price was 0.56 euro cents per watt, near the spot price for Chinese solar panels in July in Europe, according to solar exchange pvXchange.

Under the terms of the deal, China will also be allowed to meet about half Europe's solar panel demand, if taken at last year's levels. EU consumption was about 15 gigawatts in 2012, and China will be able to provide 7 gigawatts without being subject to tariffs under the deal, the EU source said.


That did not satisfy some EU solar manufacturers who said the minimum import price agreed still constitutes dumping and accused the European Commission of breaking EU law by failing to protect European industry.

European solar panel manufacturer association EU ProSun said it will go to the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg to challenge the deal.

"Even the biggest EU trade conflict ever must still be resolved on the basis of the applicable law," said EU ProSun's president, Milan Nitzschke.

However, China has sold solar panels for as little as 0.38 cents a watt, according to the European Commission, which handles trade issues for EU states, and tariffs would also hurt EU panel installers, who benefit from cheaper Chinese panels.

Chinese manufacturers such as U.S.-listed Trina Solar , Yingli Green Energy and Suntech Power Holdings are among those exporting to Europe.

Chinese solar panel production quadrupled between 2009 and 2011 to more than the world's entire demand as it took advantage of a growing market for renewable energy in the face of concerns about climate change.

But the global financial crisis and ensuing euro zone crisis have forced European governments to withdraw generous subsidies for solar energy. That, along with Chinese imports pushing down prices, have sent many European solar companies into bankruptcy.

German group Conergy filed for insolvency this month.

Still, those concerns have become secondary to the much larger EU-China trade relationship at stake over the panels dispute.

Europe is China's most important trading partner, while for the EU, China is second only to the United States. Chinese exports of goods to the bloc totalled 290 billion euros last year, with 144 billion going the other way.

Responding to the EU's move to impose duties, China launched an anti-dumping inquiry into European wine sales, which may have led to exporters in France, as well as Spain and Italy, being hit with retaliatory duties.

EU and Chinese diplomats now expect that case to be dropped as a goodwill gesture, although officials declined to comment on Saturday.

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (3)
TomMariner wrote:
How about shifting the profits of solar electricity generation from the panels to the installation, maintenance and electricity sales by only local companies. And take a page from the Chinese economic playbook and require that anyone supplying parts to firms in the EU (and US) constantly divulge their technology as a price to sell their solar chips?

Then, Oh please, give us cheap, subsidized, no-profit parts to energy generation — when you decide you have lost enough, let us know and we’ll sell you some back!

If we don’t, we all know the end to this story — its the reason that we regulate monopolies — they will undercut everybody as long as there is an everybody — then the skies the limit. Oh, and just like the manned space program — whoever develops the technology learns and gets to play the next round.

Jul 27, 2013 3:38pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
DavidBergeron wrote:
China has much lower labor cost and can clearly beat the pants off of any EU solar modules supplier. The EU manufactures could not/can not compete with China and resorted to a trade tariffs to selfishly protect their profits. I thank China for coming to the rescue of the common man, because we ‘commoners’ are being forced to buy expensive solar power due to laws promoted by an immoral solar industry. China’s lower cost provide some solace for those of us who are being blundered by the greedy solar lobby. Very glad to see the EU and US solar manufactures vanishing. Hopefully once the’re gone, the mandates for solar will also evaporate, and solar companies can compete honestly for our business.

Jul 27, 2013 4:44pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
kafantaris wrote:
Too bad the U.S. could not come up with a similar solution.
Consistently the E.U. has shown forward thinking and swift execution on sticky trade and banking issues that have plagued the U.S. for years.
Time for us here to end the infighting and get things done. The E.U. is showing us the way. Enough with divisive politics and those who gain from it. They should be marginalized — as a matter of public policy.
And let us not forget that the primary reason S&P had reduced our credit rating was because we could not agree on anything on the running of our government.

Jul 28, 2013 8:57am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.