German firm blocked shipments to U.S. distributor after drug sent for executions

Fri Oct 11, 2013 5:13am EDT

Related Topics

(Reuters) - A German manufacturer confirmed on Thursday that it took the extraordinary step of suspending shipments of a widely used drug to a U.S. distributor this year after 20 vials were mistakenly sent to the state of Missouri to be used in executions.

Drugmaker Fresenius Kabi said shipments of the anesthetic propofol were halted to a Louisiana distributor for 4 1/2 months through mid-March because the company feared the European Union would ban export of the drug altogether if it was used in executions.

"We felt it was important to make sure it was restricted to the healthcare professionals," said Geoffrey Fenton, a U.S. spokesman for the firm.

Propofol, which is mostly made in Europe, is administered about 50 million times a year in the United States during various surgical procedures, according to the manufacturer.

The Death Penalty Information Center said Missouri had been expected to become the first U.S. state to use the drug in an execution scheduled for October 23.

The death penalty is banned in the European Union, and the 28-country bloc, of which Germany is a part, bans the export of drugs for use in executions.

Fresenius Kabi said it had stopped shipments to Louisiana distributor Morris & Dickson LLC from November 1, 2012 to mid-March, 2013 after the U.S. firm inadvertently sent a carton containing 20 vials to Missouri's department of corrections.

The German company confirmed it had suspended the shipments a day after Missouri announced that it would return the drugs to the distributor. Missouri is taking the unusual step some 11 months after the distributor frantically pleaded for the return of the vials, according to emails recently made public.

A leading death penalty expert, Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, said he had never heard of a drug firm suspending shipments to a distributor over their possible use in U.S. executions.

The move shows how U.S. states and suppliers of drugs are coming under strong pressure from big pharmaceutical companies, especially in Europe, not to use supplies in executions.

The campaign against the death penalty has forced death-penalty states to change the drugs they use in lethal injections, find new supplies of existing drugs, or buy drugs from lightly regulated compounding pharmacies.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Missouri Foundation filed a lawsuit against the Department of Corrections on October 4 in an attempt to obtain information about the state's supply of propofol.

According to one of the documents posted on the ACLU's website the distributor mistakenly sent propofol to the department of corrections on September 26 or 27, 2012.

A salesperson for the distributor spent the "entire day" on November 1 at the state prison in Bonne Terre, Missouri, attempting in vain to retrieve the propofol, according to an email sent to George Lombardi, director of the department of corrections, from Dale Kelley, vice president of purchasing at Morris & Dickson.

In the email, Kelley said Fresenius Kabi had suspended distribution of propofol to Morris & Dickson, a move that would "cause irreparable harm to the medical community which we serve."

The email said the suspension would affect thousands of patients in need of the anesthetic at more than 600 hospitals in the Midwest and southern United States.

"Please - Please - Please HELP ...this system failure - a mistake - 1 carton of 20 vials - is going to affect thousands of Americans," he wrote.

The salesperson was told that approval to give the drug back had to come from Lombardi or Missouri Governor Jay Nixon, according to the email from Kelley to Lombardi.

The suspension did not end up restricting supply of propofol in the United States because Fresenius Kabi delivered the drug directly to hospitals rather to the distributor, Fenton said.

An audit was conducted of Morris & Dickson to ensure the sale of the drug to prisons would not happen again and then supplies to the distributor were resumed, he said.

Fresenius Kabi sells propofol to a total of 14 U.S. distributors, which agree not to sell the drug to jails and prisons, Fenton said.

Missouri state officials did not respond to requests to comment about the incident.

The state had been expected to use propofol for the execution of convicted murderer Allen Nicklasson scheduled for October 23, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

(This story has been corrected for paragraph 6 to read '28-country' instead of '27-country', and to the company's Reuters Instrument Code)

(Additional reporting and writing by Brendan O'Brien; Editing by Greg McCune)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (6)
WhyMeLord wrote:
OMG, Germans against executions; what’s this world coming to?
Like locking the door after the horses are out, but it’s a start.
The dealth penalty’s a crime against humanity; it’s barbaric at best.
Life without parole at least offers a chance of their rehabilitation.
Along with rehabilitation, redemption might follow if given a chance.
Only the most depraved societies advocate “an eye for an eye”.
It’s high time to abandon such primative justice and embrace progress.

Oct 10, 2013 12:27am EDT  --  Report as abuse
anotherview wrote:
A complete justice system requires the death penalty for the worst crimes. Let us hope the supplies of prescription drugs used to execute the condemned ones continues to flow for their intended legal purpose.

Let us hope further that the social engineers who would impose their defective view of justice to thwart due justice fail in their engineering, so that justice may prevail.

Next, we advocates of the necessity of the death penalty should support all efforts to speed the death penalty process in the interests of justice. The opponents of the death penalty work to stall this process by starving it of funds to fulfill its purpose. Society has an interest in bringing a swift outcome to the death penalty, as a matter of doing justice for all concerned, including the condemned ones.

Oct 11, 2013 11:00am EDT  --  Report as abuse
unionwv wrote:
German politicians rightly resent America meddling in their domestic policy. Practice what you preach, Deutschland.

Oct 11, 2013 11:10am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.