Deutsche Post wins review of EU state aid probe decision

FRANKFURT Thu Oct 24, 2013 7:13am EDT

The sign of German postal and logistics group Deutsche Post DHL is pictured on a lorry at a branch office in Fuerstenfeldbruck near Munich June 18, 2012. REUTERS/Michaela Rehle

The sign of German postal and logistics group Deutsche Post DHL is pictured on a lorry at a branch office in Fuerstenfeldbruck near Munich June 18, 2012.

Credit: Reuters/Michaela Rehle

FRANKFURT (Reuters) - Deutsche Post DHL won a small legal victory on Thursday in a years-long battle with the European Union over state aid allegedly received from the German government.

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) said it was asking the EU's second-highest court to review its 2011 rejection of a challenge by the company against the reopening of a probe into possible state aid.

Deutsche Post, Europe's biggest mail and express delivery company, welcomed the ECJ's decision.

"It's a small step towards a victory. Now the next step is for the lower court to decide if our challenge has a legal substance," a spokesman for the company said. He added that the ruling had no immediate impact on any demands to repay aid.

Since Deutsche Post's privatization in the 1990s, European regulators have waged legal battles with the German government over whether the company got preferential treatment compared with competitors.

In 2002, the Commission ordered Deutsche Post to repay 572 million euros ($788.36 million)of state aid that the company used to subsidize its loss-making parcels business in the 1990s. The ruling was annulled later that year.

The Commission launched a fresh push in 2007 to investigate possible aid beyond that sum following complaints by U.S.-based United Parcel Service and other rivals.

Deutsche Post tried to have that investigation shut down, arguing at that the matter had already been concluded with the 2002 decision.

But the General Court in December 2011 threw out Deutsche Post's challenge. The following month, the Commission said Deutsche Post would have to repay German authorities between 500 million euros and 1 billion euros in aid that it found breached state aid rules.

The ECJ said on Thursday, however, that there was a legal error in the General Court's reasoning in 2011 and that Deutsche Post should have been able to challenge the widened probe.

(Reporting by Maria Sheahan and Marilyn Gerlach; Editing by Victoria Bryan/Jeremy Gaunt)