California cop's mistaken fatal shooting of boy unfolded in seconds

SANTA ROSA, California Fri Oct 25, 2013 1:31am EDT

1 of 7. Andy Lopez Cruz holds trumpets in this undated family photo released to Reuters on October 24, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Lopez family photo/Handout

Related Topics

SANTA ROSA, California (Reuters) - No more than 10 seconds elapsed from the time sheriff's deputies spotted a 13-year-old California boy carrying what they thought was an assault rifle and the moment they shot him dead, only to learn afterward the gun was a plastic replica, police said on Thursday.

It took 16 seconds more for the two officers to call for medical assistance, according to the time line of events released by police investigating Tuesday's shooting in Santa Rosa, a suburb in northern California's wine country.

Andy Lopez Cruz, wearing a hooded sweatshirt, had been on his way to a friend's house clutching the imitation gun designed to shoot plastic pellets, police said. He died at the scene. A toy handgun also was found tucked in his pants.

An autopsy performed on Thursday found seven bullets struck the boy, and that two of the wounds were fatal. Investigators believe a total of eight rounds were fired by one of the two deputies who confronted the youth.

The officers involved in the shooting, two deputies of the Sonoma County Sheriff's Department, have been placed on administrative leave, and the incident was under investigation by the Santa Rosa Police Department and other law enforcement agencies.

But the tragedy has reignited calls in the community for creation of civilian review boards to examine such incidents.

"People have to do something," said Elbert Howard, a founding member of the Police Accountability Clinic and Helpline of Sonoma County. "He's a child, and he had a toy. I see that as an overreaction to shoot him down."

An advisory panel of the U.S. Civil Rights Commission urged Sonoma County to create civilian-review boards in 2000 following eight fatal officer-involved shootings in less than three years, but that recommendation went unheeded.

As many as 200 mourners gathered on Thursday around a makeshift memorial consisting of flowers, balloons, teddy bears and pictures of the boy at the site of the shooting.

Some held candles and signs that said: "What a tragedy, what a travesty."

Friends and family have described the boy as a well-liked eighth-grader who played the trumpet and basketball and had a good sense of humor.

Police Lieutenant Paul Henry issued a brief chronology of the killing that showed the shooting unfolded swiftly following an alert about a suspicious person in the area.

Four seconds later, the two officers radioed for assistance from other deputies. Then six seconds more passed before they notified dispatchers that shots had been fired. Police have previously said the deputies called for backup as soon as they noticed what appeared to be the military-style rifle.

According to that account, one of the deputies opened fire after the boy was twice ordered to put the gun down and instead turned toward the officers as the barrel of the weapon rose in their direction.

Police also have said the deputy who opened fire could not tell from the angle of his position that he was shooting at a child, but saw the gun and feared for his life.

The sheriff's department has refused to identify the deputies involved. Their lawyer has declined to comment.

"We want justice," the boy's father, Rodrigo Lopez, said during a silent vigil in front of Santa Rosa City Hall on Wednesday. "I don't want the same thing to happen to other families."

(Reporting by Ronnie Cohen; Editing by Steve Gorman and Lisa Shumaker)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (50)
TJexcite wrote:
Common sense gun control laws of California. Open Carry is now mostly illegal. Anyone carrying a gun is armed and dangerous criminal and treated as such. Until they prove that the gun is not a gun but a toy which would of happened faster than 12 seconds if there was by law the orange tip on the barrel.

Oct 25, 2013 2:02am EDT  --  Report as abuse
buddygreen wrote:
If the kid was ordered to drop his toy gun twice and the entire incident unfolded in sixteen seconds then the cop was drawing down on the child at the same time he was screaming drop the gun. I do not feel one bit safer knowing men with this poor of judgement are patrolling the streets in the name of public safety.

Oct 25, 2013 2:56am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Binderowner wrote:
Having lived through virtually the same scenario in several cities over the past 30 years, there’s absolutely no way to differentiate, in the extremely short period of time concerned (10 seconds) whether the “weapon” is real or a toy. And I for one am not going to attempt second-guessing a police officer, responding to a call, on his decision. He is the one putting his life on the line daily, trained to make these decisions again & again.
Do I sympathize with the community? Of course. But when the suspect was ordered to put the weapon down & instead turned toward the officers raising the weapon, that’s it. Even with an “orange tip”, there have been incidents where the real weapon has been modified in an attempt to conceal it’s actual identity.
The only solution is to teach our kids gun handling rules & emphasize the importance of following instructions to the letter when confronted by a Police Officer whether or not the weapon is real or a replica.
PLEASE, parents – TEACH YOUR KIDS & KEEP THEM ALIVE – you have that responsibility as a parent.

Oct 25, 2013 2:59am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.