Egypt tweaks roadmap, may see presidential vote held first

CAIRO Sun Dec 1, 2013 6:34pm EST

1 of 12. A soldier rides on an armoured personnel carrier (APC) at Tahrir Square after clashes with pro-Mursi protesters in Cairo December 1, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Amr Abdallah Dalsh

Related Topics

CAIRO (Reuters) - Egypt's political transition was pitched into uncertainty on Sunday when a draft constitution was amended to allow a presidential election to be held before parliamentary polls, indicating a potential change in the army's roadmap.

The roadmap unveiled when the military ousted Islamist President Mohamed Mursi in July said a parliamentary election should take place before the presidential one.

But the draft finalized on Sunday by the 50-member constituent assembly avoids saying which vote should happen first, leaving the decision up to President Adly Mansour, seen as a front for army rule since he was installed to head the interim administration.

The draft also says the "election procedures" must start within six months of the constitution's ratification, meaning Egypt may not have an elected president and parliament until the second half of next year.

A major milestone in Egypt's political roadmap, the constitution must be approved in a referendum expected this month or next. Amr Moussa, chairman of the constituent assembly, said the draft constitution would be handed to Mansour on Tuesday.

Moussa, former Arab League secretary general, was a candidate in the presidential election won by Mursi last year.

The draft reflects how the balance of power has shifted in Egypt since the secular-minded generals ousted Mursi, the country's first freely elected head of state, after mass protests against him and the Muslim Brotherhood.

The new constitution could lead to an outright ban on Islamist parties and strengthens the political grip of the already powerful military establishment that has put itself squarely back at the heart of power since toppling Mursi.

The assembly finished voting on the draft after talks on the order of next year's elections stretched late into Sunday night.

The changes follow debate fuelled by concern that weak secular parties are not ready for parliamentary elections, sources familiar with the discussions have said.

Seeing army chief Abdel Fattah al-Sisi as the front-runner for president, some assembly members wanted the presidential election held before legislative polls or even at the same time so that a strong presidential candidate can forge an electoral alliance for the parliamentary race.


Sisi led the July 3 overthrow of Mursi and is widely seen as the lead candidate for the presidency.

While Brotherhood sympathizers hold him responsible for the deaths of hundreds of Mursi supporters killed in a crackdown on the movement, other Egyptians see him as the kind of strong man needed to restore stability after three years of turmoil.

Sisi has been lionized by state media since toppling Mursi.

As they wait for Sisi to make his intentions clear, none of the candidates defeated by Mursi in last year's presidential election, such as Moussa, have declared they will run. However, Hamdeen Sabahi, a leftist who came third, has strongly hinted he would like to.

A spokeswoman for his Popular Current, Heba Yassin, said holding the presidential election ahead of the parliamentary vote would meet the demands of people who took to the streets against Mursi on June 30 to demand an early presidential vote.

Mursi's Brotherhood won all elections after President Hosni Mubarak's downfall in 2011, drawing on its position as Egypt's best-organized party to defeat leftists and liberals in parliamentary and presidential polls.

But the state has cracked down hard on the Brotherhood since Mursi's ouster, arresting thousands of its supporters including many of its leaders. The group says it wants nothing to do with the army-planned transition.

The draft constitution widens the already broad privileges enjoyed by the army by requiring the approval of the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces for the choice of a defense minister to serve for two full presidential terms from the moment the document is ratified.

It does not indicate how the minister of defense could be sacked or who has the authority to fire him.

It also allows the military to try civilians in military courts - a holdover from previous constitutions that is strongly opposed by democracy activists. The draft does, however, specify the crimes for which a civilian can be tried by the military.

The constitution will replace one signed into law by Mursi last year after it was passed in a referendum. The new text strips out Islamist-inspired additions introduced by the Islamist-dominated assembly that drafted it.


Mursi's fall set off the bloodiest bout of internal strife in Egypt's modern history.

Armed attacks on the security forces have become commonplace, and some 200 policemen and soldiers have been killed in what the government casts as a war on terrorism waged by Islamist militants. The Brotherhood says it is peacefully resisting the army takeover.

In a reminder of the simmering tension, security forces fired teargas in Cairo's Tahrir Square to disperse anti-government protesters. It appeared to be the biggest protest by Brotherhood supporters in Tahrir Square since Mursi's downfall.

"The people want to topple the regime," chanted several hundred protesters. "With our blood and souls we sacrifice for you, Islam," chanted some. One scaled a lamp post to hang a picture of Mursi.

Others flashed the four-finger hand sign denoting sympathy with the hundreds of Mursi supporters shot dead by the security forces when they broke up their Cairo sit-ins on August 14.

Army vehicles moved in to drive the demonstrators away and later sealed off the square completely. Some passersby shouted abuse at the protesters, others waved in support. Earlier, protesters set a police truck ablaze near Cairo University.

The government says it is determined to implement a law passed last week that heavily restricts protests. Criticized by the United States, the law has hardened fears of pro-democracy campaigners about the future of political freedoms in Egypt.

Ahmed Maher, one of two leading secular activists detained for calling protests in defiance of the law, was released on Sunday. The other, Alaa Abdel Fattah, was ordered detained for a further 15 days. Both are symbols of the historic 2011 uprising that led to Mubarak's downfall.

(Additional reporting by Omar Fahmy, Asma Alsharif and Sayyed Shaesha; Writing by Tom Perry; Editing by Alistair Lyon and Philip Barbara)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
franknolo wrote:
Unfortunately, the Egyptian military made a very bad decision to expell Morsi in the way that they did.

When you compare the death tolls of Islamist violence and Secular Violence in Egypt, you can very clearly see that the seculars generally kill and violate the rights of more people than the Islamists. No one is perfect, but the numbers say it all. Islamists are generally violent when they are being illegally repressed. Even then, their acts of violence do not have anywhere near the death toll that secular violence produces. If you compare 70 tourists killed at luxor, which was the highest profile Gamaa attack in Egypt, compared to over a thousand killed at Rabaa Mosque by the Egyptian military, it is clear that secularists are more suceptible to a lack of restrain in using violence than islamists.

Dec 01, 2013 9:32am EST  --  Report as abuse
samdishman wrote:
The military coup is demonising the islamists and pushing them to one left option,,,non peaceful!The brutal heavy handed handling of peaceful demonstrations will back fire!The majority of the 90 million nation is against the corruption and torture committed by the police under the false umbrella of highly politicised justice system! Most do not respect the interim government and lost respect for the justice system,most hate the police!The justice system charges are insane,crazy and just nonsense! General SiSi is portrayed to be murderer and killer by millions of Egyptians as he is using the tanks and military power to quell demonstrations and silence any opposition!The court is always ready with slamming pre written very harsh statements( widely believed to be mandated by the security police) against any different opinion of theirs!The country is robbed by few who are billionaires and the rest have to endure the rough life with what is left from the elites! Egypt is spending the money on killing it’s own citizens instead of feeding, treating and educating them!

Dec 01, 2013 10:02am EST  --  Report as abuse
Burns0011 wrote:
In the short term, this is true. In the short term.

In the long term, religiously-dominated governments inevitably fall into a viciously nasty tyranny where the rights of the people are non-existent and anyone can be accused of being ‘non-religious’, held, tortured, and killed on a whim of the inevitable religious police.

Religious regimes also end up destitute and corrupt, unless they’re lucky enough to be sitting on some of the worlds most easy to reach oil fields; in which case they’re just incredibly corrupt.

Dec 01, 2013 1:06pm EST  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.