In Iran, age mellows some former captors of U.S. hostages

ANKARA Thu Apr 3, 2014 4:04am EDT

EDITORS' NOTE: Reuters and other foreign media are subject to Iranian restrictions on their ability to film or take pictures in Tehran. Iranian women walk past a mural outside the former U.S. embassy in Tehran November 4, 2009. REUTERS/Raheb Homavandi

EDITORS' NOTE: Reuters and other foreign media are subject to Iranian restrictions on their ability to film or take pictures in Tehran. Iranian women walk past a mural outside the former U.S. embassy in Tehran November 4, 2009.

Credit: Reuters/Raheb Homavandi

Related Topics

ANKARA (Reuters) - Three decades after hardline students occupied the U.S. embassy and took diplomats hostage for 444 days, many of the now middle-aged revolutionaries are among the most vocal critics of Iran's conservative establishment, officials and analysts said.

The role of the students is back in the spotlight following the appointment of a new U.N. ambassador who may have participated on the fringes of the siege, the event that led Washington to sever ties with Tehran shortly after the 1979 Islamic revolution.

The U.S. State Department, which has yet to approve a visa for Hamid Abutalebi, said it had raised "serious concerns" with Iran about his nomination for the post.

But Iran hopes the case can be resolved, while Abutalebi has played down his role in the hostage crisis, suggesting he was just a translator.

"He is one of Iran's most prominent and senior diplomats. We hope there will be an agreement (to his appointment) in the normal way," Iran's deputy Foreign Minister Hossein Amir Abdollahian told reporters in Kuwait.

Abutalebi has held postings in Europe and was appointed deputy director of political affairs in the office of President Hassan Rouhani in September. Friends say that like many of his fellow former student activists, he is now pro-reform.

But hardline U.S. lawmakers said on Tuesday they were concerned about his selection and called on the Obama administration to do what it can to prevent him from taking up the post in New York.

People who know Abutalebi said he was part of the student group that occupied the embassy, although not among the core activists inside the embassy who captured and held the hostages.

Lawyers for the former captive embassy workers have said the ex-hostages are angry about the nomination of Abutalibi, a man they say was involved in the crisis, and want him barred from New York.

But some analysts and officials argue that with the passage of time, most of the leaders of the 300 or so radicals whose action galvanized world attention have become outspoken advocates of the need to reform Iran's Islamic political system.

"They are simply middle-aged Iranians who now even advocate close ties with the West," said a senior Iranian official, who asked not to be named.


Some paid for their change of opinion with arrest, seen by security hawks as a threat. Some won prominence under former reformist President Mohammad Khatami, but moved to the political margins under his hardline successor Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

As students, almost all of the hostage takers were active in the revolution that overthrew Iran's U.S.-backed shah. But years later, the ranks of the hostage takers also gave birth to a movement for reform of Iran's Islamic system, analysts said.

Like many ordinary Iranians, the former students opposed powerful hardliners who considered any talks about normalizing ties with "the Great Satan" anathema.

Many Iranians are not anti-American. Thanks to the Internet and illegal satellite television, U.S. popular culture is influential among young Iranians.

However, the pro-reformist ex-hostage takers are limited in their ambitions. They are committed to the Islamic Revolution, but want to reform the establishment within that framework.


"They are not pro-Western, though they support engagement with the West. They do not want revolution but want an evolution," said analyst Hamid Sedghi.

Among the hostage takers were Abbas Abdi, an adviser to Khatami, who in 1998 met former hostage Barry Rosen in Paris.

Abdi made no apology and said the past could not be altered. Instead "we must focus on building a better future", he said.

In 2002 Abdi was arrested for having carried out a poll in collaboration with U.S. firm Gallup which showed that three quarters of Tehran's citizens favored a thaw with Washington.

Reform leader Saeed Hajjarian survived an assassination attempt in 2000 by unidentified people but was gravely injured and has not recovered. Khatami's younger brother Mohammad Reza and his deputy foreign minister Mohsen Aminzadeh were also among the hostage takers.

While some of the group have disappeared from politics, others are still ardent defenders of Iran's strict religious rule and defiance of the international community.

"Some of them still believe the embassy takeover helped strengthen anti-American fervor in Iran," said analyst Hamid Farahvashian. "But most of them believe in reforms."


Ahmadinejad's disputed re-election in 2009 ended an era in which former hostage-takers held key positions in government and parliament.

Disagreements between former hostage takers and hardliners came to the fore after the 2009 vote, which the opposition said was rigged and ignited eight months of violent street unrest.

In a comment widely taken as a reference to the turmoil, former hostage taker Masumeh Ebtekar wrote on her blog Persian Paradox: "Those who were all devotees and trustees of the Islamic Revolution ... felt that the Islamic Republic is facing a serious challenge to its basic principles and values."

Ebterkar, who was Iran's vice-president under Khatami, a post she resumed under Rouhani, was the public face of the siege, serving as a spokeswoman for the hostage-takers.

Aides to reformist candidates were jailed in the post-election unrest, including former hostage takers Mohsen Mirdamadi and Aminzadeh, on charges including "acting against national security" and "propaganda against the system".

Mirdamadi was sentenced to six years in prison and a 10-year ban on political and media activities. He was temporarily released in December 2013. Aminzadeh, sentenced to six years in jail in 2010, was freed in 2013 after 10 months in hospital.

"The slogans that carried us forward as revolutionary students in 1980 might no longer hold all the answers to the problems of today," wrote Ebtekar.

Ebrahim Asgharzadeh, who was also a spokesman for the hostage takers, has also hinted he is no longer a hardliner.

"Now I am more experienced and more realistic," Asgharzadeh, a former member of Tehran's city council, was quoted as saying by Iranian media. "I no longer take radical actions and I believe gradual reforms last longer than radical changes."

Since Rouhani took office in August, Washington and Tehran have taken tentative steps toward improving relations. But Iran's most powerful figure, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, continues to give speeches larded with denunciations of "the Great Satan" to reassure hardliners.

(Additional reporting by Sylvia Westall in Kuwait; Writing by Parisa Hafezi; Editing by William Maclean and Giles Elgood)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (4)
ChangeIranNow wrote:
For those still trying to pedal the line that Iran is becoming a beacon of moderation in the region under President Rouhani, it must be deflating to learn that Iran is to appoint one of the 1979 U.S. embassy hostage takers as its new ambassador to the United Nations. Of course this is really just one more reason to question either the judgment or the integrity of those who continue to insist that Rouhani’s Iran is a state that the West can do business with.

Apr 03, 2014 2:21am EDT  --  Report as abuse
notsosmart wrote:
Is the US going to question doing business with Iran as long as it questions doing business with its’ neighbor Cuba?

Apr 03, 2014 3:44am EDT  --  Report as abuse
7625vhmbnm wrote:
The purpose of the Iranian author’s article is to put a new face on the radicals, including the UN ambassador designee. This then will enable the designee to get his visa and life will go on. Many Americans were not born when these animals attacked our embassy and held 52 American hostages for 444 days, but many Americans do remember…and they remember with anger and disdain for his ilk. Unfortunately, we had a pacifist for President, otherwise this act would have been met with severe military action.

Apr 06, 2014 11:52am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.