New rules help stock exchanges fight back against "dark pools"

Fri Apr 4, 2014 11:20am EDT

Related Topics

* EU plans to limit anonymous trading in "dark pools"

* Anonymous dealing has helped new venues grow rapidly

* LSE eyes intraday auction to win back big orders

By Alistair Smout and Clare Hutchison

LONDON, April 4 (Reuters) - The European Union's plan to cap the number of shares that can be traded anonymously could give traditional stock exchanges such as Deutsche Boerse and the London Stock Exchange the chance to win back some of the ground they have lost to new rivals.

Anonymous dealing in private venues known as "dark pools" has been a major source of growth for new electronic share trading companies such as Chi-X Europe and Liquidnet.

But EU regulators are concerned such venues could be open to market manipulation and that they take away liquidity from public exchanges, potentially making them more volatile.

As a result, they have drafted a set of reforms that will limit the proportion of a company's shares that can be traded anonymously to 8 percent.

That could give traditional exchanges an opportunity to win back business, which some are already exploring.

Last month, the London Stock Exchange (LSE) said it was looking at introducing a "mid-session auction," as a way of offering investors some of the advantages of anonymous trading, while remaining within the new regulations.

"Potentially, it would affect the way we do business if it became popular and provided significant liquidity," said Christopher Hughes, equity dealer at Royal London Asset Management, of the LSE's proposal.

Traditional exchanges were hit hard by a series of EU reforms in 2007 which sought to promote competition in equities trading. The reforms led to the rise of new dealing venues which offered a wide range of trading options, often at a lower cost for investors, including anonymous trading in "dark pools."

These proved popular among investors who complain that when they execute a large order on a public exchange, other dealers can see what they are doing and so can move the price against them. In "dark pools," investors place buy or sell orders anonymously, and are matched up automatically.

Following the market liberalisation, the LSE has seen its share of European equities trading drop from a leading position of around 18 percent to 11.7 percent, according to Thomson Reuters EMSR data.

Meanwhile, Chi-X Europe has captured 16.8 percent of the market, with 16.9 percent of that due to "dark" orders.

TABB Group, a consultancy, has estimated "dark pool" trading is equivalent to 11 percent of the European stock market.

Traditional exchanges have tried to compete by creating their own anonymous trading venues or striking partnerships with those run by others. The LSE, for example, has its Turquoise platform, while Swiss stock exchange operator SIX Group has partnered with "dark pool" operator Liquidnet since 2011.

But now regulators are clamping down on anonymous trading, traditional exchanges are looking at new ways to win back customers wanting to execute big orders.

THE AUCTION OPTION

The LSE believes an intraday auction could be one such way.

During the auction, normal trade would be suspended and buyers and sellers would be able to place orders, with an algorithm used to determine the price.

This could offer an advantage over "dark pools," where buyers and sellers submit the price at which they would like to trade, but may not be able to get the deal done if they cannot find a counterparty prepared to do business at that price.

"When you hit the 8 percent cap (for anonymous trading)... what are the alternatives for executing larger trades if you don't have a dark pool, or access to one? An intraday auction is one option," Brian Schwieger, LSE's head of equities, said.

"This is how we're offering an alternative to dark pools; this is how we're responding to that."

The LSE, which already conducts auctions at the opening and closing of business, said its proposal was in response to demand from clients and that it was currently open for consultation.

The new EU rules are due to be implemented by the end of 2016. But because analysts are unsure exactly how much anonymous trading takes place, it is hard to gauge their likely impact.

Certainly, the operators of "dark pools" are confident they will remain popular, not least because they allow investors to trade at any time, in contrast with a time-limited auction.

"We've seen that it's relatively hard for exchanges to attract large institutional liquidity and execute (orders) in size," said Per Loven, head of international corporate strategy at Liquidnet Europe.

"You see a somewhat higher size in the auction than you do in continuous trading, but nevertheless, there is a reason that asset managers are using platforms like ours that are dedicated institutional block liquidity."

Royal London Asset Management's Hughes also said he would continue to use "dark pools". (Writing by Alistair Smout; Editing by Mark Potter)

FILED UNDER:
Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.