Hedge fund buying doubles Minneapolis Grain Exchange seat prices

CHICAGO, April 28 Mon Apr 28, 2014 5:46pm EDT

CHICAGO, April 28 (Reuters) - Hedge fund manager Murray Stahl has bought 13 percent of the seats on the last independent U.S. grain exchange, doubling prices and fueling speculation he may want a platform to trade his fund's products or even to cash in on a potential takeover, industry sources said on Monday.

The Minneapolis Grain Exchange (MGEX) survived rounds of consolidation among global exchanges that created giants like CME Group, based in Chicago, and ICE, a network of exchanges including the New York and Euronext stock markets.

Founded in 1881, MGEX is still owned by members who pay for a seat which allows them to trade and vote on exchange rules.

Its only widely-used contract is booming - spring wheat futures have set volume and open interest records this year as Canadian growers turn to Minneapolis to hedge risk following the break-up of the Canadian Wheat Board's grain monopoly in August of 2012.

That could make the exchange an attractive bid target, traders say. Just 18 months ago, CME paid $126 million for the Kansas City Board of Trade and its hard red winter wheat contract in a move to bolster its lucrative grains franchise.

Stahl, who is chief executive of New York based hedge fund Horizon Kinetics, declined to speak to Reuters for this story.

In a recent conference call with his fund investors, Stahl in comments on the internet called the MGEX investment "strategic," given the consolidation within the industry as well as its potential as a platform for Horizon products.

"As a real estate investment by itself, the exchange's building might have some merit and then, more importantly, it includes the exchange itself," Stahl said, adding in later questions that his board seat would not preclude it being a platform for index or structured products of Horizon.

MGEX's chief executive, Mark Bagan, suggested that the recent boom in the spring wheat contract and much stronger participation from Canadian growers and grain handlers was a clear attraction for Stahl.

"Everyone realizes the higher your volume, the more profitable you are," Bagan told Reuters.

As a member-owned derivatives exchange, the 133-year-old MGEX is regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, not the Securities and Exchange Commission. It also boasts approved "clearing" facilities, like its larger rivals, that allow trades to be tracked by regulators.

Stahl has now amassed through his funds 53 out of a total 402 seats on MGEX, or 13 percent, according to exchange data, and holds a seat on the board which he took last October.

Now, MGEX is proposing the limit on seat ownership be raised to 35 percent from 20 percent, according to a circular to members seen by Reuters, although voting rights will still be capped at 20 percent for any one owner under rules from the federal regulator.

With the cost of an MGEX seat doubling to $195,000 in a year as Stahl has been buying, that would put a 20 percent stake at roughly $15.7 million. To buy 20 percent of the massive CME would cost roughly $4.8 billion at today's prices.

Asked if Stahl planned to launch investment indexes on MGEX, the exchange's chief executive, Bagan, told Reuters: "That would be news to me." (Editing by Diane Craft)

Comments (0)
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.