Israel, U.S. divided over Iranian nuclear enrichment deal

JERUSALEM Wed May 7, 2014 1:24pm EDT

Related Topics

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Israel insists Iran be denied uranium enrichment capabilities under a potentially imminent nuclear deal, a demand that risks opening a new Israeli-United States rift, officials said on Wednesday.

The dispute, a major topic for a visit to Jerusalem by U.S. National Security Adviser Susan Rice on Wednesday and Thursday, appeared part of Israeli efforts to weigh in on world powers' difficult talks with Tehran before a July 20 date for a deal.

Though not at the table, Israel matters in Western capitals given its fear of a nuclear-armed Iran and threats to attack its arch-foe preemptively if it deem diplomacy a dead end.

A November interim accord easing sanctions on Iran made clear Washington and five other world powers would let it enrich uranium on a reduced scale under a final agreement distancing it from the means to make a bomb. But Israel wants the Iranians to be stripped of all disputed nuclear projects.

Highly enriched uranium can fuel nuclear warheads. Iran says it seeks peaceful atomic energy and medical isotopes only.

"Are we going to agree on enrichment? No," an Israeli government adviser briefed on Rice's visit told Reuters.

"We would be happy to see July 20 pass without a deal," the adviser said, adding that there was worry in Israel that Obama, facing possible gains by Republican rivals in the mid-term U.S. elections of November, might be tempted to accommodate Iran now.

This view seems unlikely to go down well with Obama, a second-term Democrat who has sparred in the past with Israel's right-wing prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, over strategies for Iran and peacemaking with the Palestinians.


The adviser described Israel's hard line as sincere but declarative, rather than a prelude to a new Middle East war, and a signal to supporters in the U.S. Congress to keep up pressure on U.S. President Barack Obama not to compromise with Iran.

Rice tweeted that she was "looking forward to robust and intensive consultations" in Israel and that the allies' security cooperation "has never been stronger". On Tuesday, White House spokesman Jay Carney said her visit to Israel would not produce any new developments regarding Iran.

Russia, which is among the six world powers negotiating with Iran, said parts of the final agreement could be agreed at a scheduled meeting in Vienna next week.

Some Western diplomats and experts privately acknowledge forcing Iran to halt all uranium enrichment activities, as stipulated in U.N. Security Council resolutions, is unrealistic given the scale of the program and resistance from Tehran.

Speaking on condition of anonymity, a U.S. official said Rice came to Israel "representing the six powers", adding: "The question of enrichment, how many (uranium purification) centrifuges Iran should keep, is the big one."

The U.S. official voiced confidence that a deal with Iran, if achieved, would prevent its heavy water facility at Arak from producing significant amounts of plutonium - another fissile material that could be used for nuclear warheads.

While that would be welcomed by the Israelis, their main focus has long been Iran's build-up of uranium stocks which might allow it to refine enough fuel for a bomb in short order.

Israel, widely assumed to have the region's only atomic arsenal, was angered last month when U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry suggested cautious openness to a nuclear deal that would keep Iran 6 to 12 months from the weapons threshold.

A former Israeli security official said Tehran would be five years away from the threshold if the demand for a full Iranian nuclear rollback were met. But the Israeli advisor said the government had not presented any such formulation.

"I've not seen or heard anything about what our 'acceptable' threshold would be," the adviser said. "But I do know that less than a year would be unacceptable."

(Writing by Dan Williams; Editing by Tom Heneghan)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (3)
bbsnews wrote:
Israel should realize. President Obama is using the Iran deal to checkmate its client state that is totally out of control and a threat to the region if not the world. Israel, the tiny little rogue state represents an inordinate threat considering its size and actual value in the world community. So Israel must be restrained and a nuclear breakout capability by Iran is the best way to do it. Israel should have made peace ala the Arab Peace Initiative. Now it’s hard ball and President Obama has plenty of time to impose a solution. Spin that vulture…

May 07, 2014 12:36am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Prasunger wrote:
Russia, the country which illegally annexed part of the neighboring European sovereign state just couple of months ago, steers through her agents and armed forces a domestic conflict in that state clearly leading to a civil war; the country that is openly preparing to tear off another piece of territory of its neighbor – this country is welcomed by the “great powers” into the group negotiating with Iran – another aggressor who is supporting Mohammedan terrorism all over the planet and openly planning to wipe off the map another state? Wow, its like appointing fox a chicken coop security guard…

May 08, 2014 3:57am EDT  --  Report as abuse
bbsnews wrote:
prasunger, that crazy “wipe off the map stuff” has been debunked ad nauseum. By bringing it up you show yourself to be ignorant of that reality. The fact is, the state of Iran has NEVER threatened to attack Israel. This is simply a fact that can be easily verified. It’s one of the great Western hoaxes. On the other hand, barely a day goes by without Bibi and Israel threatening Iran with various attacks. Bibi is trying to protect his crumbling colonial enterprise from coming unraveled. A Quiotic endeavor because the world is now well aware of Israel’s numerous Crimes Against Humanity.

May 08, 2014 11:57am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.