U.N. watchdog urges Vatican to pursue sex criminals

GENEVA Fri May 23, 2014 12:25pm EDT

Saint Peter's Basilica at the Vatican is silhouetted during sunset in Rome, March 11, 2013. REUTERS/Paul Hanna

Saint Peter's Basilica at the Vatican is silhouetted during sunset in Rome, March 11, 2013.

Credit: Reuters/Paul Hanna

GENEVA (Reuters) - The United Nations watchdog on torture urged the Vatican on Friday to cooperate with civil authorities in prosecuting all cases of suspected sexual abuse by pedophile priests and to set up its own individual complaints mechanism.

Rape and sex crimes can amount to torture or cruel treatment and the Vatican must prevent and punish such abuses, the U.N. Committee against Torture said. It had already found that sexual abuse amounted to torture in some 50 countries, officials said.

"The Holy See says sexual abuse is not torture. Well, sexual abuse, including rape, can be torture, or cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment," Felice Gaer, a committee member, told Reuters Television. "We say whether it's cruel treatment or torture depends on the facts of the case."

It was the second time this year that a U.N. human rights body has criticized how Roman Catholic officials have handled the decades-long sexual abuse of minors by priests.

Victims accuse the Vatican of still protecting abusers and covering up sex crimes, failing to punish perpetrators, refer them to the authorities or provide adequate compensation.

The Vatican told the committee this month that the Church's accusers were "fossilized in the past" when public attitudes were different. Archbishop Silvano Tomasi said the Church had developed model child protection policies over the last decade that other states and institutions might emulate.

The U.N. Committee against Torture, which examined the Holy See's record, said Vatican officials should monitor priests and "stop and sanction" conduct that violates the U.N. treaty against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.

It rejected the Vatican's position that the Holy See has jurisdiction only in the tiny Vatican City State.

"It is very important to know that the Convention applies outside of the four corners of the Vatican City State. That it is very important for the Vatican to take steps, they haven't been taking, to prevent many grave incidents, particularly regarding sexual abuse of minors including in some cases grave abuse and rape," said Gaer, an American lawyer.

Any priest suspected of sexual abuse should be immediately suspended pending investigation and should not be transferred to another diocese to avoid punishment, the U.N. committee said.

The Vatican should "take effective measures to ensure that allegations received by its officials concerning violations of the Convention (against Torture) are communicated to the proper civil authorities to facilitate their investigation and prosecution of alleged perpetrators".

"For too long, the Vatican has been able to deny and deflect attention from its role in enabling, perpetuating, and covering-up these serious crimes around the globe. But the increasing attention international human rights bodies are paying to this crisis shows the Vatican's days of impunity are numbered," Barbara Blaine, president of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP), said in a statement.


The U.N. committee, composed of 10 independent experts, said that the Holy See had a responsibility under the treaty that extended to its officials working worldwide.

It voiced concern at the case of Father Joseph Jayapaul, a priest formally accused of sexually abusing youth in Minnesota in the United States, who has returned to his native India.

It called on the Vatican to investigate Polish Archbishop Joseph Wesolowski and ensure that if warranted he is criminally prosecuted or extradited to face charges of alleged abuse in the Dominican Republic.

Wesolowski was recalled last August to the Vatican, which said a month later that it would cooperate with authorities investigating him on suspicion of pedophilia.

The U.N. committee voiced deep concern at reports by many victims that they have been unable to obtain redress and at a "refusal" by four religious orders that ran the Magdalene laundries in Ireland to contribute to a compensation fund.

Women, many unmarried mothers, sent to the laundries were made to work in slave-like conditions, and were often subject to cruel and degrading treatment as well as abuse, the U.N. Committee on the Rights of the Child said in February.

In a statement on Friday, the Holy See said that the U.N. torture committee had not found it in violation of the treaty and had recognized its "important efforts to prevent sexual abuse against minors and others".

"The Holy See condemns sex abuse as a serious crime and a grave violation of human dignity," it said, adding that it would

give "serious consideration" to the U.N. recommendations.

Miguel Hurtado, a Spaniard sexually abused as a youth by his local priest, welcomed the latest U.N. probe and findings.

"They have said that the church has to be more transparent, that they have to report child abuse to the authorities, that bishops who cover up sex crimes have to be fired said that victims have a right to compensation," Hurtado told Reuters Television. "That's what we have been saying for decades."

(additional reporting by Morade Azzouz; editing by Ralph Boulton)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
Comments (1)
Physician wrote:
I do not know what happened to my comment from yesterday. As a physician who has met many who have been sexually abused by priests, I do know that those who are accusing the church are not fossilized in the past, as Archbishop Tomasi wants everyone to believe. The policies that have been developed, that Tomasi is so proud of, only work if they are followed. Sadly, they are not being followed and children remain at risk around the world. The fact that Pope Francis is protecting Archbishop Wesolowski from facing charges of sexually abusing young boys in Poland and in the Dominican Republic, where he was papal nuncio, is a bad omen of what is to come. If Pope Francis prefers to protect the sexual predator clergy, more of the clergy will be predators, since they see that they will be free from accountability to the law, and more children will be at risk of being raped. How can Pope Francis ignore the command of Jesus to protect the innocence of children? How can the predators be protected instead of being made accountable to criminal law? It is the police, not the church, who have the right and duty to investigate the crimes and criminals of the church. As a Catholic, I am grateful that the United Nations is investigating the Roman Catholic Church, and letting the world see how irresponsible the church is. The church is only a church, and does not deserve to have state status nor diplomatic immunity, which it has been abusing for years.
Sincerely, Dr Rosemary Eileen McHugh, M.D., M.Spir., Chicago

May 24, 2014 10:09am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.