China, Japan exchange barbs over action by warplanes in East China Sea

TOKYO Sun May 25, 2014 4:02am EDT

A Chinese SU-27 fighter flies over the East China Sea, in this handout photo taken May 24, 2014 and released by the Defense Ministry of Japan May 25, 2014. REUTERS/Defense Ministry of Japan/Handout via Reuters

A Chinese SU-27 fighter flies over the East China Sea, in this handout photo taken May 24, 2014 and released by the Defense Ministry of Japan May 25, 2014.

Credit: Reuters/Defense Ministry of Japan/Handout via Reuters

TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan and China on Sunday accused each other's air forces of dangerous behavior over the East China Sea, with Japan saying Chinese aircraft had come within a few dozen meters of its warplanes.

Japan's defense minister accused Beijing of going "over the top" in its approach to disputed territory. China's defense ministry said Japanese planes had carried out "dangerous" actions during its joint maritime exercises with Russia.

Tensions have been running high between China and its neighbors over Beijing's assertive stance on claiming land and sea territory.

Japan's defense ministry said Chinese SU-27 fighters came as close as 50 meters (170 feet) to a Japanese OP-3C surveillance plane near disputed islets on Saturday and within 30 meters of a YS-11EB electronic intelligence aircraft.

"Closing in while flying normally over the high seas is impossible," Defense Minister Itsunori Onodera told reporters in comments broadcast on TV Asahi.

"This is a close encounter that is outright over the top."

Onodera said Japan conveyed its concerns to the Chinese side through diplomatic channels. He also said the Chinese planes were carrying missiles.

A ministry official said it was the closest Chinese warplanes had come to aircraft of Japan's Self-Defense Force.

China's defense ministry said jets were scrambled in the East China Sea on Saturday after Japanese aircraft entered its air defense zone during maritime exercises with Russia.

The ministry said the Japanese aircraft had entered the zone

despite "no fly" notices being issued ahead of the exercises. China declared its air defense zone last year despite protests by Japan and the United States.

"Japanese military planes intruded on the exercise's airspace without permission and carried out dangerous actions, in a serious violation of international laws and standards, which could have easily caused a misunderstanding and even led to a mid-air accident," the statement said.

China had proposed urgent talks, it said, and demanded that Japan "respect the lawful rights of China's and Russia's navies ... and stop all reconnaissance and interference activities. Otherwise Japan will bear any and all consequences from this".


China lays claim to Japanese-administered islets in the East China Sea, known as Senkaku in Japanese and Diaoyu in Chinese. It is also pressing its claim to almost all the South China Sea, brushing aside claims by several southeast Asian states.

China's proclamation last November of an air defense zone covering disputed islands and areas in the South China Sea has raised concerns that a minor incident could quickly escalate.

Sino-Japanese ties have long been strained by allegations in China that Japan has not properly atoned for its wartime aggression and by the spat over the uninhabited islands.

Japan scrambled fighter jets against Chinese planes 415 times in the year ended in March, up 36 percent on the year, while in waters near the disputed islands, patrol ships from both countries have been playing cat-and-mouse, raising fears of an accidental clash.

Japanese land, sea and air forces joined last week to simulate the recapture of a remote island, underscoring Tokyo's concerns about the security of the islets.

Tensions between China and its neighbors have also risen sharply in the South China Sea in recent weeks, following the deployment of a Chinese oil rig in waters also claimed by Vietnam. The deployment sparked anti-Chinese riots in Vietnam.

The Philippine foreign ministry this month accused China of reclaiming land on a disputed reef in the South China Sea and said it appeared to be building an airstrip.

(Reporting by Kiyoshi Takenaka and Osamu Tsukimori and Paul Carsten in Beijing; Editing by Ron Popeski)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (47)
Rhino1 wrote:
Well, here we go again. At the end of the 20th century you could have thought the human kind had finally learned how to live fairly peacefully together. Well, there is always the US, of course, meddling where oil can be found, but all in all it looked like humanity had left WORLD WARS behind.

Not so, apparently.

China, being run mostly by soulless apparatchiks, seems to be set to start all over again. Just alone all the hate propaganda against Japan on Chinese television shows that China is not ready yet to be part of a more advanced human race scenario. The most surprising thing about this fact is that China has been one of the greatest and most advanced nations in the world for many hundreds of years, IN THE PAST.

For all the young generations in this world this means of course they might after all go through what their parents had to go through 80 years ago.

On the bright side, didn’t Goethe say something like “war is the father of all things”?

May 25, 2014 1:24am EDT  --  Report as abuse
Bakhtin wrote:
The Chinese are doing everything they can to provoke an international incident, so they can howl about being attacked by Japan and use it as an excuse to attempt a military attempt on Japan’s Senkaku Islands.

It matters because the defence treaty with the USA is defence only – not attack. China has to fire the first shot, and they know this so they provoke, provoke, provoke.

May 25, 2014 1:31am EDT  --  Report as abuse
YesNoMaybeSo wrote:
@ Rhino1 Yes it is sad, we go round and round. War might be the father of all things bad perhaps. If you look at each conflict, the result only leads to the next conflict, really doesn’t solve anything.

May 25, 2014 1:37am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.