GM faulty-switch cases sent to New York court
NEW YORK (Reuters) - A federal judicial panel ruled on Monday that lawsuits against General Motors Co from customers who say they suffered economic damages from a recall over faulty ignition switches will be heard in New York.
The cases will be sent to U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman in the Southern District of New York, according to the ruling from the U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, which considers requests to consolidate related lawsuits in U.S. federal courts.
More than 80 lawsuits have been filed by customers who allege that their cars lost value as a result of the recall, which began in February. GM had asked that the cases be consolidated and transferred to New York, the same district in which it filed for bankruptcy and emerged from it in 2009.
GM is asking the federal bankruptcy court in Manhattan to determine whether claims brought by plaintiffs over the recall are blocked by the terms of its bankruptcy sale order, which created “new GM” and largely barred liability against the new company for the pre-bankruptcy conduct of “old GM.”
The order does not affect lawsuits over personal injuries or deaths alleged to have been caused by the vehicles.
Plaintiffs’ lawyers suing the company had also asked that the cases be consolidated but disagreed on where. The forums they suggested were Los Angeles – where litigation against Toyota Motor Corp over acceleration issues was transferred – as well as Miami, New Orleans, San Francisco and Texas.
In its order on Monday, the panel said that the Manhattan district was the most appropriate choice, since it was the same district that handled GM’s bankruptcy, as well as the bankruptcy of Delphi Automotive Plc, a GM supplier that made the switch at issue. Delphi has been named a defendant in some of the cases.
Several judges in New York, including Furman, “have some familiarity with the common defendant and its prior bankruptcy proceedings,” the panel wrote.
The panel, which travels around the country, heard oral arguments on the request in Chicago.
Greg Martin, a GM spokesman, said via email that the order affirmed the company's belief that the New York court is the most appropriate venue for the cases.
An attorney for some of the plaintiffs, Steve Berman, said in an email that he was “happy to be (in New York), as we hear this judge is terrific.”
A representative for Delphi did not immediately respond to requests by email for comment.