LONDON Britain's Carphone Warehouse CPW.L and Dixons Retail DXNS.L are winning over investors to a merger that will create a powerhouse in consumer electricals retailing, they said on Thursday, as they both posted big increases in annual earnings.
Last month, the two firms agreed an all-share merger to create Dixons Carphone, a company that would be worth 3.6 billion pounds ($6.1 billion) at Wednesday's closing prices and tap into the convergence of smartphones and consumer electronics in people's lives.
The May 15 announcement prompted a 10 percent slide in Dixons' share price and an 8 percent fall in Carphone's.
Some analysts and investors were disappointed with targeted annual cost savings and synergies of at least 80 million pounds by 2017-18, while some were also concerned by a possible top-heavy management structure and the perceived defensive nature of the deal in the face of online competition.
Shares in both firms have since rallied strongly, however, and are up 3 percent over the last month.
“The share price has come right back, so we’re pretty comfortable that investors are happy with the story,” Seb James, Dixons' CEO and the CEO designate of the merged group, told reporters on Thursday.
James and Carphone CEO Andrew Harrison both said the deal made financial sense if it was considered purely on the basis of combined profits and forecast synergies.
"That's even if you don’t believe the reason we’re actually doing the deal, which is the strategic coming together of someone who is brilliant outside the home and someone who is great within the home," said Harrison.
James added: "It's easier for investors to put in their spread sheets things that are concrete. It's our job to dream about the future."
One of Carphone's top 10 investors told Reuters he had been unimpressed with the presentation of the deal on May 15 but had been convinced of its strategic rationale after a further meeting with management.
"The lessons learned were don't talk wavy, talk numbers, talk concrete strategy," said the investor.
Carphone, Europe's largest independent mobile phone firm and Dixons, Europe's No. 2 consumer electricals retailer, said the merger was on track with the expected timetable. On Wednesday it received the unconditional approval of the European Commission.
Shareholders will vote on the merger at meetings on July 17, with shares in Dixons Carphone due to start trading on Aug. 7. The deal would create a firm with turnover of about 12 billion pounds, 2,900 stores and 45,000 staff. The combined group is likely to enter Britain's FTSE 100 index of leading companies.
Carphone reported annual earnings up 59 percent, driven by growing sales of superfast 4G mobile broadband phones, while Dixons' profit increased 76 percent, helped by demand for tablet computers, kitchen gadgets and big-screen televisions.
Dixons, home to the Currys and PC World chains in Britain, Elkjop in Nordic countries and Kotsovolos in Greece, also said its new fiscal year had started well, with TV sales boosted by the soccer World Cup and early glimmers of a consumer recovery.
It made an underlying profit before tax of 166.2 million pounds in the year to April 30, beating company guidance of about 160 million pounds.
Carphone made headline earnings per share of 18.4 pence for the year to March 29 - in line with company guidance of 17-20 pence. It is paying a final dividend of 4 pence, making 6 pence for the year, up 20 percent.