Ukraine war crimes trials a step closer after Red Cross assessment

GENEVA Tue Jul 22, 2014 5:32am EDT

Related Topics

GENEVA (Reuters) - The Red Cross has made a confidential legal assessment that Ukraine is officially in a war, Western diplomats and officials say, opening the door to possible war crimes prosecutions, including over the downing of Malaysia Airlines MH-17.

"Clearly it's an international conflict and therefore this is most probably a war crime," one Western diplomat in Geneva told Reuters.

The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) is the guardian of the Geneva Conventions setting down the rules of war, and as such is considered a reference in the United Nations deciding when violence has evolved into an armed conflict.

"Within the U.N. system, it's the ICRC that makes that determination. They are the gate keepers of international humanitarian law," said one U.N. source.

The ICRC has not made any public statement - seeking not to offend either Ukraine or Russia by calling it a civil war or a case of foreign aggression - but it has done so privately and informed the parties to the conflict, sources told Reuters.

"The qualification has been shared bilaterally and confidentially," ICRC spokeswoman Anastasia Isyuk told Reuters on Friday. "We do not discuss it publicly."

The designation as a war - either international or civil - changes the game legally, because it turns both sides into combatants with equal liability for war crimes, which have no statute of limitations and cannot be absolved by an amnesty.

Suspects may also be arrested abroad, since some countries apply "universal jurisdiction" to war crimes.

Without the designation, Ukrainian government forces would be responsible for protecting civilians and infrastructure under international human rights law, while separatists would only be liable under Ukraine's criminal laws.

"It changes their accountability on the international stage," said Andrew Clapham, director of the Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights. "This makes individuals more likely to be prosecuted for war crimes."

Dutch prosecutors have opened an investigation into the crash of Malaysia Airlines flight MH-17 on suspicion of murder, war crimes and intentionally downing an airliner, a spokesman said on Monday. [ID:nL6N0PW2VI]

Based on the Law on International Crimes, the Netherlands can prosecute any individual who committed a war crime against a Dutch citizen. The 298 people who were killed when the plane was downed over Ukraine included 193 Dutch citizens.

Russian President Vladimir Putin said in May that the country had collapsed into civil war, while Ukraine regards the conflict as a war involving Russian aggression.

(Reporting by Tom Miles; editing by Stephanie Nebehay/Jeremy Gaunt)

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see
Comments (5)
Liamocean1 wrote:
It’s too bad the Red Cross didn’t get involved sooner. Thousands have died at the hands of the Kiev government and the Right Sector who are notorious for false flag attacks. They burned 48 people alive in Odessa and the Red Cross never lifted a finger nor did Amnesty International. I will never give another penny or drop of blood to either organization. Pure hypocrisy that they only get involved now. It is shameful.

Jul 22, 2014 5:23pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
@ liamocean1: too bad the Red Cross didn’t get involved sooner by prosecuting the Kreliminist puppet known as Yanukovych.

Jul 22, 2014 8:24pm EDT  --  Report as abuse
nose2066 wrote:
Speaking of war crimes, down in Libya, wasn’t the former government leader, Muammar Gaddafi captured, so he became a “prisoner of war”. And wasn’t he then tortured and killed? I’m not sure that combatants are supposed to do that with “prisoners of war”.

Jul 23, 2014 8:14am EDT  --  Report as abuse
This discussion is now closed. We welcome comments on our articles for a limited period after their publication.