Russian banks in euro zone could face curbs on ECB borrowing as sanctions bite

Wed Aug 6, 2014 8:55am EDT

* ECB debates how to implement sanctions against Russia

* Unclear how sanctions affect ECB market operations

* ECB Governing Council to discuss issue on Thursday

By Eva Taylor

FRANKFURT, Aug 6 (Reuters) - Major Russian banks active in the euro zone could face caps or even exclusion from borrowing from the European Central Bank as it examines how European sanctions against Moscow affect its operations.

Euro zone banks use the ECB to manage their day-to-day liquidity flows and relied on the central bank almost exclusively when interbank markets dried up at the height of the global financial crisis as trust among banks evaporated.

Being able to tap central bank refinancing operations is crucial for banks, especially when others may not be willing to lend to them. The ECB's decision will therefore be decisive for the sanctioned Russian banks' European business operations.

"The intention is clear: the EU subsidiaries in their legitimate business should not be negatively impacted. That is the thrust of the regulation and I am not hearing many people say otherwise actually. We'll see if the ECB goes beyond that," said a source familiar with the discussions.

Among the banks in question are the Austrian arms of Russia's two largest banks, Sberbank and VTB Bank, which the ECB thought so significant it decided to supervise them directly when it takes on banking oversight in the euro zone in November.

Sberbank is run by German Gref, an ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin, and VTB is majority-owned by Russia. Sberbank's Austrian unit declined to comment when contacted by Reuters for this story.

VTB Bank referred to a statement in which it said neither its Austrian unit nor its subsidiaries in Germany and France were targeted by the sanctions. It added that their operations were unaffected.

The ECB could decide to freeze transactions between the euro zone subsidiaries of the affected Russian banks and the euro system, introduce caps on how much funding they can take, or leave things as they are and monitor capital flows to ensure funds are not being passed on to the Russian parent companies.

"The ECB will take all necessary steps to prevent circumvention of the EU restrictive measures, in the context of its monetary policy operations," an ECB spokesperson said.

Russia is Austria's ninth-biggest trading partner. Positioned on the edge of the Iron Curtain that divided Europe until 1989, Austria was a gateway to the eastern bloc and became a base for doing business with the former Communist countries.

Even if mainly a legal issue for the ECB, the development shows how difficult it has become for the central bank to keep out of politics given the depth and complexity of financial interconnections and at a time when it is taking on more responsibility to bring Europe back to growth.

The policy-making Governing Council is set to discuss the issue informally on Wednesday and then formally at its policy meeting on Thursday. Whether it will take a decision then is not clear yet, several people with knowledge of the debate said.

LEGAL MAZE

At the heart of the problem is the legal text of the sanctions the European Union released last week against Russia for its role in Ukraine's political crisis.

The sanctions say among other things that EU nationals and companies can no longer buy or sell new bonds, equity or other financial instruments with a maturity of more than 90 days issued by major state-owned Russian banks or those acting on their behalf.

The ECB has to comply with the new legislation agreed by European countries, but the legal text does not clearly define which transactions are restricted. ECB experts are working on the matter.

The ECB held a conference call on Friday. So far, euro zone subsidiaries and branches of the Russian banks in question have remained eligible counterparties in the euro system, but the ECB is keeping an eye on their capital flows.

"What we also don't want is for these banks to become increasingly dependent on the ECB," the source said. "We do see that in the markets some counterparties are cutting down their exposure limits, also to the subsidiaries.

"As far as we can tell, so far they haven't had any actual constraints on their business - but who knows how this will all pan out?" (Additional reporting by Michael Shields in Vienna; Editing by Ruth Pitchford)