Renault could turn Russia crisis to its advantage

Wed Aug 27, 2014 11:27am EDT

* Renault sources more locally, so less exposed to rouble

* Investment in previous slump paid off in years after

* No plans to review, postpone vehicle development in Russia

By Laurence Frost

MOSCOW, Aug 27 (Reuters) - Renault, the major carmaker with most at stake in Russia, could turn a market crisis to its advantage as Moscow considers a subsidy scheme to steady demand and a weaker rouble undermines rivals that make fewer parts locally.

The French carmaker, alliance partner Nissan and their Russian subsidiary AvtoVAZ were among those showing new models at the Moscow auto show this week amid escalating tensions between Russia and the West over Ukraine that have already sent Russian car sales into a steep decline.

Renault bought into AvtoVAZ, maker of the Lada, in 2008 and increased its holding to a controlling stake this year.

While not ruling out production cuts if the slump persists, Renault's Russia chief has no plans to review or postpone vehicle development, believing a previous move to invest during a downturn in 2009 was vindicated when Russia became one of the carmaker's most profitable markets in the following years.

"Now isn't the time to make bad decisions not to do things," Bruno Ancelin told Reuters in an interview on the sidelines of the auto show. "It's precisely when the market is disrupted that you should invest."

The Russian car market is down 10 percent so far this year, and the outlook worsened with last month's downing of a passenger jet over Ukraine - blamed on pro-Russia separatists - which triggered a new volley of Western sanctions against Russia's banks and oil sector.

Leading forecaster LMC Automotive slashed its full-year Russian car sales forecast in response, predicting a decline of 15.8 percent instead of the 10.5 percent previously expected.

Concerns over Russia, Renault's third-biggest market, have also weighed heavily on Renault's shares, which are down 10.7 percent since it published first-half earnings on July 29.

LOCAL PARTS ADVANTAGE

But Renault and the Lada brand it indirectly controls enjoy the benefit of a relatively high proportion of parts supplied from inside Russia and billed in roubles - while rivals such as Ford are squeezed by mounting import costs. The rouble is down about 10 percent against the U.S. dollar so far this year.

"There's no question Renault-Nissan did a good job getting ahead of most of the foreign industry on localisation," said Ted Cannis, chief executive of Ford Sollers, the U.S. carmaker's Russian joint venture.

"But we're going to close the gap faster than they imagine," he told Reuters.

According to 2013 data, Ford sources just 30 percent of parts in roubles for its Russian-built Focus model. By comparison, the Renault-badged Logan sedan and Sandero hatchback achieved a 75 percent localisation rate, with the Renault Duster offroader at 66 percent and Lada Largus at 62 percent.

Volkswagen's Russian-made cars came in at 50 percent rouble-billed content. General Motors, whose sales have also lost ground, was trailing at 20 percent, excluding some shared production with AvtoVAZ.

Government sales subsidies under consideration may be accompanied by import restrictions, according to Russian press reports, potentially making life even harder for those importing vehicles or parts.

With or without new import barriers, any swing in favour of domestic brands would stand to benefit Renault and Nissan through AvtoVAZ, which is Russia's largest carmaker. Together, the three companies control 30 percent of the Russian market.

"We're using the patriotism to strengthen our regions where we are already strong," AvtoVAZ boss Bo Andersson said.

"With new products we are also attracting customers in Moscow and St Petersburg," the Swedish-born chief executive added, citing Lada market share gains in both cities.

The GM veteran took over in January and immediately set about cutting 7,500 jobs at Lada, which is betting on new models such as the XRay SUV unveiled this week to stem a steady decline in market share. New budget hatchbacks were also unveiled by Renault and Nissan's Datsun brand.

Lada expects to begin recovering lost market share next year on the strength of the new launches, Andersson told Reuters.

Andersson this week cut planned production by another 25,000 vehicles as he pursues a goal to return AvtoVAZ to breakeven this year from a 7.9 billion rouble ($218 million) loss in 2013, despite the market tailspin.

The slump itself may be softened or even reversed if Moscow unveils significant new subsidies to prop up demand. Auto executives including Renault's Ancelin said they believed an announcement was imminent.

"We've had good discussions off and on over the last month or so and I think something's coming and sooner rather than later," Ford Sollers chief Cannis also said.

Carmakers are pushing for "broad-based" sales subsidies on vehicle trade-ins, he added, rather than a repeat of credit subsidies that reduce car financing costs but had little effect when offered last year.

Any market support is likely to favour domestic production over imports, Cannis added, "given the current climate".

It could also play heavily to Renault's strengths.

"If there's some government support and the market turns out to be going up then that's potentially very good for Renault-Nissan," London-based Barclays analyst Michael Tyndall said.

"If Russia turns out to be not quite the disaster the market's expecting, you'd expect some sort of relief rally."

(1 US dollar = 36.1660 Russian rouble) (Additional reporting by Maria Kiselyova and Gleb Stolyarov; Editing by Andrew Callus and Mark Potter)

A couple walks along the rough surf during sunset at Oahu's North Shore, December 26, 2013. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque

Find your dream retirement town

Florida? Hawaii? Reuters has teamed up with Zillow to give you the power to customize a list of your best places to retire.  Video | Full Article