* Living wage, union battle cry, is hard to define
* Companies cannot afford big rises because of costs, prices
* Typical mining family may spend 5,000 rand a month, about
By Ed Stoddard and Benon Oluka
JOHANNESBURG, July 10 "A living wage" is the
battle cry of South Africa's Association of Mineworkers and
Construction Union (AMCU) as it and rival unions plunge into pay
talks this month with mining houses.
But what is a living wage for a South African miner?
Finding a definition, no easy task, has become the goal of
an increasingly militant labour force demanding pay increases
ranging from 15 to 150 percent, which mining companies can ill
afford as precious metals prices tumble and costs surge.
Wage negotiations in the gold sector kick off on Thursday.
The issue is complicated by many variables and by the
difficulty of defining fair pay for work that may often require
only low levels of skill but is very tough and dangerous.
"It's difficult to put a number on a living wage," said
Boitumelo Sethlatswe, a researcher at the South African
Institute of Race Relations.
"It depends how many people are in your household, and are
there people in your household with access to social grants such
as for old age pensions and child support," she said.
AMCU, which has emerged as the dominant union on the
platinum belt and made inroads into gold after poaching tens of
thousands of members from the once unrivalled National Union of
Mineworkers (NUM), certainly has a number in mind.
It has submitted demands to South African gold producers,
which include AngloGold Ashanti and Harmony Gold
, calling for a more than doubling of the monthly basic
wage for entry-level miners to 12,500 rand ($1,300) from 5,000
It wants a similar increase from Anglo American Platinum
, the world's top producer of that metal. NUM's demands
to gold producers are for raises of between 15 and 60 percent.
That sounds steep but probably does not seem unreasonable if
you go underground - in hot, difficult and potentially lethal
conditions - to toil for just a few hundred dollars a month.
But the basic wage is not the whole picture.
According to South Africa's Chamber of Mines, the main body
representing the industry, basic wages in the gold sector are
supplemented by other benefits, cash and non-cash, which can
translate into 8,800 rand a month in costs to a company.
These take the form of meals, housing, and other allowances.
Bonuses and overtime can take the total up to 11,000 rand a
month. Mining houses have not waded into the debate about what a
living wage is, but looking from the perspective of the cost to
companies, they have said they simply cannot afford big rises.
EIGHT MOUTHS, TWO FAMILIES
One way to look at the issue is through a rough profile of a
South African mine worker. NUM, which claims to be the biggest
union in the shafts at 300,000 strong, says its typical member
is male, aged in his 30s, and has eight dependants.
The Studies in Poverty and Inequality Institute (SPII), a
Johannesburg think tank, has compiled a list of average monthly
purchases in South Africa for a household of 3.4 members.
Included in this list is almost five kg of brown bread, 10
kg of the staple maize meal, plus meat, sugar, vegetables,
cooking oil and other necessities.
Reuters has checked the prices and amounts on the list at a
supermarket chain in Johannesburg which targets mostly
lower-income earners, and has multiplied by almost three to
assume a household of nine - a miner plus eight dependants.
This provides a very rough estimation of what a household of
such size would typically spend to meet basic nutritional and
A household of 3.4 members would pay around 1,830 rand a
month for the items and quantities calculated by SPII.
Multiplied by around 2.65 to assume a typical miner plus the
eight people who rely on him brings the figure to 4,850 rand, or
roughly the basic wage at the bottom of the scale.
This would hardly suggest a living wage as it does not
include school fees, transport or other costs associated with
the daily grind, not to mention amenities and savings.
Of course, meals are provided to miners, but dependants
would still consume the bulk of the required monthly items.
Then there is the question of those who rely on the pay
cheque and their potential sources of income. South Africa is a
rarity on the continent in having a basic social welfare net.
This includes an old age pension of 1,540 rand a month and
child grant support grants of 260 rand per child.
So if a miner's whole package was, say, around 9,000 rand a
month and he or she had two children and at least one parent on
pension, the total family income would be around 11,000 rand a
month. This would meet basic needs but not much beyond that.
Inflation is currently running at under six percent but food
inflation is almost 6.5 percent and accelerating, which will
further strain the budgets of low-income households.
Complicating matters is the fact that the mine labour force
remains largely a migrant one, drawn from remote and
impoverished rural areas and neighbouring states such as
Lesotho. Many miners have two families, one in the village and
one where they work.
Many are subsistence farmers who supplement their cash
income by growing crops or raising cattle and other livestock.
The minimum wage for farm workers is 105 rand a day or only
around 2,100 rand a month, a reflection of the view that rural
dwellers can survive on less cash than their urban counterparts.
This all excludes a family's desire to own a television,
cell phones and other amenities. Such consumption often requires
lower-income households to borrow from micro lenders at
exorbitant interest rates - one factor behind high wage demands.
So it is easy to see why the target of a "living wage" would
be built around the goal of 12,500 rand a month.
The problem is that gold's decade-long bull run has come
crashing down and the spot price has lost around 25
percent so far in 2013. Platinum prices also remain
depressed while mining costs have been soaring, crushing profit
According to South Africa's chamber of mines, the sharp fall
in the bullion price pushed about 60 percent of the country's
gold mines into loss-making territory in the first half of 2013,
spelling doom for the industry.
Major South African gold producers have among the weakest
pretax profit margins in the industry.
Harmony Gold, which gets more than 90 percent of
its output from South Africa, keeps less than 10 percent of its
sales as pretax profit, according to Thomson Reuters StarMine.
The African National Congress government, which has key
labour allies including the NUM, has talked less about a living
wage and more about the need to preserve jobs in an industry
that has shed hundreds of thousands over the past two decades.
Defining a living wage, and understanding where the figure
comes from, are probably easier goals than paying one.