(Repeats with no changes to text)
--Clyde Russell is a Reuters columnist. The views
expressed are his own.--
By Clyde Russell
LAUNCESTON, Australia, Aug 25 Something doesn't
quite add up with China's rising steel production, but falling
coal output and imports so far this year.
China's raw steel output was 480.76 million tonnes in the
first seven months of 2014, up 2.7 percent from the same period
a year earlier, according to data from the National Bureau of
However, imports of metallurgical, or coking, coal used to
make steel were down 12.6 percent to 36.01 million tonnes in the
first seven months of the year, according to customs data.
Given that imports only meet roughly 10 percent of China's
coking coal needs, it's essential to look at domestic coal
Total coal production in China in the first seven months of
the year was 2.163 billion tonnes, a decline of 1.45 percent on
the same period in 2013, with July's output down 1.63 percent
from the same month last year, according to data from the China
Coal Transport and Distribution Association.
What isn't clear is the breakdown of thermal to coking coal
within those broader production figures.
This means that while overall coal output is lower in 2014,
it may be that coking coal's share of this has risen relative to
thermal coal, which would offer an explanation for the mismatch
between rising steel output and lower domestic coal output and
However, a closer examination of the figures shows that
coking coal output would have to have made major gains to
account for the discrepancy.
To produce the 480.76 million tonnes of steel would take
about 370.2 million tonnes of coking coal, using the World Coal
Association's average of 770 kilograms of coking coal to one
tonne of steel.
Taking away imports of 36.01 million tonnes, this means that
domestic coking coal would have to have supplied about 334.2
million tonnes to the steel sector.
China has for the past two years produced coking coal to
thermal coal at a ratio of close to 1 to 7.
If this ratio is applied to the 334.2 million tonnes of
coking coal the steel industry would have needed from domestic
sources in the first seven months of the year, it would suggest
total coal output of 2.339 billion tonnes.
This is 176 million tonnes more than has been reported,
implying that the ratio of coking coal to thermal coal has
dropped to around 1 to 6.5.
It's entirely possible that this is indeed the case, given
the additional coking coal mine capacity that has been added in
Shanxi province, the top domestic supplier of the steel-making
A Standard Chartered report from April last year estimated
that 111 million tonnes of coking coal capacity would be added
to Shanxi mines in the three years from 2013 to 2015, with the
bulk coming in the first two years.
The only other plausible explanation is that coking coal
demand has been partially met from reducing stockpiles.
Greater efficiencies at steel plants is also a possibility,
but this would likely have made only a marginal difference to
consumption of coking coal.
What is most likely is that the additional coking coal
demand has been met from domestic sources, despite seaborne
prices falling to their lowest level in seven years.
COKING COAL COST PRESSURES
The question then becomes as to whether Chinese coking coal
miners can continue to increase output, or whether they are
being subject to the same profitability issues currently being
suffered by their global counterparts.
Estimates from analysts vary, but the consensus is that at
least 30 percent of global coking coal production is loss-making
at the current Asian spot price of about $113 a tonne.
This may rise to as much as 50 percent if the cost of
sustaining capital is added in, and miners are starting to
respond by idling output, particularly in North America.
Canada and the United States have been the second- and
third-ranked coking coal exporters behind Australia, with those
three countries accounting for about 90 percent of global
seaborne trade in recent years.
About 70 percent of Chinese coal mining companies are making
losses, according to the China Coal Industry Association.
This suggests that Chinese miners are worse-off than their
global counterparts, and are thus unlikely to be able to
increase output by significant amounts under the current pricing
If steel output continues to grow, it becomes increasingly
likely that additional coking coal demand will have to be met by
imports, with the current weak prices a further incentive for
steel mills to source from overseas.
(Editing by Joseph Radford)