* EU flights must still comply with ETS scheme
* Non-EU flights get one year's breathing room
* China favours "multilateral" UN framework
* Asia Airlines Assoc says EU still "negotiating with gun on
* EU carbon market rises ahead of draft proposal to bolster
By Barbara Lewis
BRUSSELS, Nov 12 The European Union will freeze
for a year its rule that all airlines must pay for their carbon
emissions for flights into and out of EU airports, the EU
executive said, following threats of international retaliation.
Flights within the European Union will still have to pay for
their carbon emissions. The year-long exemption will apply to
flights linking EU airports to countries outside the bloc, a
move welcomed by U.S. and Asian officials.
Climate Commissioner Connie Hedegaard said she had agreed
"to stop the clock" to create a positive atmosphere for
international talks on an alternative global plan to tackle
"But let me be very clear: if this exercise does not deliver
-- and I hope it does -- then, needless to say, we are back to
where we are today with the EU ETS (emissions trading scheme).
The United States, China and India have put intense pressure
on the European Union. Debate in the U.S. Congress is set to
resume this week on legislation to counter the EU rules.
"While I am pleased the EU has temporarily suspended its
efforts to unilaterally impose a tax on our airlines flying over
U.S. and international airspace, the EU's announcement does not
rule out future efforts to tax foreign carriers," said Senator
John Thune, who led efforts in the U.S. Senate to block the law.
China likewise also opposed what it said was the EU's
unilateral move and prefers to work under mechanisms such as the
U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).
"China always maintains that under the multilateral
mechanism, such as the UNFCCC, ... international cooperation
should be carried out to tackle climate change," Chinese Foreign
Ministry spokesman Hong Lei told reporters in Beijing.
"We should oppose unilateral measures."
EU member states must still formally endorse the
Commission's proposed freeze. Hedegaard said she had told
representatives of all 27 member states of the plan but could
not say how long the EU approval process might take.
German Environment Minister Peter Altmaier said the decision
was justified. "It made clear that the EU is holding on to its
view, but at the same time it is also in the position to stick
to its international commitments and actions," he said.
"GUN ON THE TABLE"
Some airline associations welcomed Monday's announcement,
but said the moratorium meant EU carriers operating flights
within the bloc could be at a competitive disadvantage.
Association of Asia Pacific Airlines (AAPA) Director General
Andrew Herdman described the freeze as "long overdue" but said
it might not go far enough.
"The implied threat of an automatic snapback in a year's
time means that the EU will still be seen by some as negotiating
with a gun on the table," Herdman said in a statement.
Environment campaigners said the European Union was giving
up too much, too soon. But they said opponents could no longer
blame the European Union for any lack of progress at the U.N.'s
International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), which is
seeking an alternative global deal.
"The Commission, with today's decision, has moved further
than necessary, given the little progress made so far at ICAO
level," said Bill Hemmings, programme manager at campaign group
T&E. "There is no excuse for inaction left."
Herdman also said the ICAO was the right forum for a global
agreement. "The alternative would be disastrous -- a patchwork
of overlapping national schemes and punitive taxes."
The European Union agreed on its law after more than a
decade of talks at the ICAO failed to find a way to curb
aviation emissions. It always said it would modify its
legislation if the ICAO could deliver an alternative.
Hedegaard said the ICAO had made good progress at a meeting
in Montreal on Friday.
Efforts have intensified since the start of this year, when
the EU's requirement for all airlines to buy carbon emissions
began to take effect.
The law is being phased in slowly, which means the first
bills would only be sent out in April 2013 after the calculation
of this year's emissions. Any airline that does not submit
carbon allowances by then would face stiff fines.
The proposed year-long waiver -- meaning no carbon payments
before April 2014 for international flights -- gives the ICAO
until its general assembly in late 2013 to reach a global deal.
The cost of the EU's aviation law is minimal, at 1 to 2
euros per passenger per flight, given the weakness of the EU
Emissions Trading Scheme, on which the carbon price has sunk
under a glut of surplus permits following the region's economic
The cost to aviation, though, is expected to rise. On
Monday, the Commission also published draft legislation to
temporarily withdraw some surplus allowances.