• Most Popular
  • Most Shared

CORRECTED - EU fines firms $260 mln for chemicals price fixing

Wed Nov 11, 2009 5:36pm EST

Stocks

   

* 24 companies hit by fines over 'heat stabiliser' cartel

* Commission issues fines totalling 173 mln euros

* Swiss group Ciba fined total of 68 mln euros; to appeal

* Price-fixing began in 1987, continued until 2000 (Corrects description of Chemson company in paragraph 3 to Austrian, not Australian)

By Luke Baker

BRUSSELS, Nov 11 (Reuters) - The European Commission issued fines totalling 173 million euros ($260 million) to 24 companies on Wednesday for belonging to a cartel that fixed prices for heat stabilisers.

The biggest fine was issued to Swiss group Ciba (BASF.DE), which was told to pay a total of 68.4 million euros for coordinating the pricing of two kinds of heat stabiliser -- chemicals which are involved in making PVC and packaging products heat resistant and more rigid.

Dutch group Akzo (AKZO.AS) was fined a total of 40.6 million euros, France's Elf Aquitaine (TOTF.PA) was ordered to pay 28.6 million and British-U.S. group Elementis (ELM.L) 32.5 million. An Austrian firm, Chemson, was fined 3.8 million.

"The companies' elaborate precautions to cover their tracks did not prevent the Commission from revealing the full extent of their determined efforts to rip off their customers," EU Competition Commissioner Neelie Kroes said in a statement.

"These companies must learn the hard way that breaking the law does not pay and that repeat offenders will face stiffer penalties."

U.S. corporation Chemtura (CEMJQ.PK) was found to have participated in the cartel but had its fines cancelled because it brought the price-fixing issue to the Commission's attention.

Arkema (AKE.PA), a firm owned by Elf Aquitaine, had its fines increased by 90 percent as it had taken part in previous such cartels, the Commission said.

BASF, the German company that owns Ciba, said it would appeal the fine, citing a statute of limitations. It said Ciba had sold the firm that engaged in the price-fixing 10 years ago.

Elementis also said it would appeal the fine, while AkzoNobel, owner of Akzo, said it was reviewing the decision and pointed out that it had two months to lodge a court appeal.

The Commission's decision is another sign that competition boss Kroes is determined to show she is a consumer champion and will root out corporate malpractice as she prepares to end her five-year term in office.

Her investigation into the companies' activities began in February 2003 after Chemtura lodged an application for immunity. The price-fixing began in 1987 for tin stabilisers and 1991 for what are known as ESBO stabilisers and continued until 2000.

"For both products, the companies fixed prices, shared customers, allocated markets and exchanged commercially sensitive information," Kroes said.

The main decisions for setting up both cartels were taken at the Zurich offices of a Swiss company, Treuhand, the Commission said. Treuhand was fined a total of 348,000 euros.

Heat stabilisers are added to PVC products to improve their thermal resistance and overall rigidity. They are used in packaging for food, in credit cards, bottles and coatings.

The European heat stabiliser market was worth about 121 million euros at the time of the infringements, according to the Commission.

For a factbox on the EU's highest cartel fines, please double click on [ID:nL7320506].

(Additional reporting by Frankfurt and Amsterdam bureaux) ($1=.6674 Euro) (Editing Simon Jessop and David Cowell)



More from Reuters

Chairman of the Federal Reserve Ben Bernanke testifies before the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee on Capitol Hill in Washington July 22, 2009. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque
John Kemp:

The Fed needs a new storyline

It's irrelevant whether the Fed sells its assets back to the market. What matters is whether and when it's prepared to raise rates.  Commentary 

A worker drives a Toyota Motor Corp's newly assembled Prius hybrid vehicle onto a trailer near the company's plant in Toyota, central Japan February 9, 2010.REUTERS/Yuriko Nakao
Reuters Breakingviews:

Toyota's troubles in overdrive

The cost of Toyota's recall nightmare is nothing compared to the price of fixing its battered reputation.  Commentary