• Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Canada grain farmers sue railways for overcharging

Fri Nov 6, 2009 1:09pm EST

Stocks

   

* Allege they were overcharged more than C$1 billion

* Filed in Saskatchewan court; suit needs court approval

* Second class action on same issue

VANCOUVER, British Columbia, Nov 6 (Reuters) - A small group of Western Canada farmers is suing the country's two big railways, alleging they have been charged at least C$1 billion ($934.5 million) too much for grain shipments since 1983.

The five grain producers filed the class action lawsuit against Canadian National Railway Co (CNR.TO) and Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd (CP.TO) in a Saskatchewan court on Oct. 15, court documents show.

A CN spokeswoman said the matter is before the courts and the company had no further comment.

CP is reviewing the suit, a spokeswoman said, declining further comment.

Since 1983 Canadian grain farmers' freight rates have been capped by the government, which allows CP and CN to charge rates that cover only their costs.

The suit alleges that both railroads claimed costs that were "ineligible or much higher than those incurred". It cites a 2007-08 Canadian Transport Agency review that it says found the railways pocketed C$72 million after charging three times too much for hopper-car maintenance.

"As a result, CN and CP wrongfully overcharged farmers by more than a billion dollars for transporting their grain," the suit says.

A similar class action suit was filed against CN and CP last December by another Canadian farmer.

The court still needs to approve the case as a class action.

($1=$1.07 Canadian) (Reporting by Nicole Mordant; editing by Peter Galloway)



More from Reuters

Protestors wait outside the U.S. Capitol as the U.S. Senate prepares to vote on U.S. President Barack Obama's healthcare overhaul in Washington

States take aim to block plan

As the Congress once again rallies to pass healthcare reform legislation, momentum is growing in many states to pass laws to block the changes.   Full Article 

Construction workers build one of a number of new single family homes in a subdivision outside San Diego as new home construction returns to San Marcos, California

It's all in the family

Homebuyers are increasingly counting on their extended families to cut costs and get a bigger bang for their mortgage dollars.  Full Article 

Pioneering feminist Gloria Steinem being interviewed in Beverly Hills, California March 16, 2010. REUTERS/Mario Anzuoni

Elusive equality

Huge strides have been made in women's rights over the past 40 years. So why is Gloria Steinem still unsettled?  Full Article | Video