• Most Popular
  • Most Shared

Obama and Clinton trade charges in speech flap

NILES, Ohio
Mon Feb 18, 2008 6:34pm EST

NILES, Ohio (Reuters) - Democrats Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton traded charges on Monday over Obama's uncredited use of a friend's lines in a speech, one day before the presidential contenders meet in a critical showdown in Wisconsin.

Barack Obama

Pointing toward Tuesday's primary, the two camps battled over a recent Obama speech using words from Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick -- a friend and political ally of Obama. Obama said he should have credited Patrick but dismissed the controversy as no big deal.

Clinton spokesman Howard Wolfson said the use of the lines called into question Obama's rhetoric -- one of the Illinois senator's biggest selling points.

"Senator Obama is running on the strength of his rhetoric and the strength of his promises and, as we have seen in the last couple of days, he's breaking his promises and his rhetoric isn't his own," Wolfson said.

The exchanges came before Tuesday's votes in Wisconsin and Hawaii, which will allocate a combined 94 delegates to the August convention that selects the Democratic presidential nominee in November's election.

Polls show a tight race in Wisconsin as Obama tries to extend his string of eight straight victories in Democratic nominating contests, which have given him a lead in the race for pledged convention delegates.

Obama, who was born in Hawaii, is favored to win in that state.

Republican front-runner John McCain earned the endorsement of former U.S. President George H.W. Bush, the father of the current president, at a Houston meeting.

The elder Bush said he was annoyed by conservative attacks on the party's almost certain nominee and called their criticism "grossly unfair."

"You know, if you've been around the track you hear these criticisms and I think they are grossly unfair. He's got a ... sound conservative record but he's not above reaching out to the other side," Bush said at a joint news conference with the Arizona senator.

Some conservatives distrust McCain for his moderate views on illegal immigration and campaign finance reform and for voting against President George W. Bush's tax cuts in 2001 and 2003. McCain, hoping to mend fences with conservatives, now wants to make the cuts permanent.

Later, aboard his campaign plane, McCain said he would be glad to have the current president campaign on his behalf "under any circumstance." Bush has suffered from low approval ratings, particularly among independent voters whom McCain would hope to attract in the November election.

SPEECH CONTROVERSY

The Obama and Clinton speech flap stemmed from a Democratic party dinner in Milwaukee on Saturday, when Obama refuted Clinton's criticism he is all words and no action. "Don't tell me words don't matter," Obama said.

"'I have a dream' -- just words? 'We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal' -- just words?'" Obama said at the dinner. The lines drawn from U.S. history were similar to a Patrick speech from his successful 2006 Massachusetts campaign for governor.

Obama, talking to reporters on a Monday morning trip to Ohio before returning to Wisconsin, said Patrick had suggested he use the lines and they frequently traded ideas.

"I was on the stump. He had suggested that we use these lines and I thought they were good lines," Obama said, adding he should have acknowledged Patrick as the author.

"I'm sure I should have -- didn't this time," he said. "I really don't think this is too big of a deal."

Obama's campaign released a list of quotes from Clinton using some of Obama's catchphrases, and Obama cited some to reporters.

"When Senator Clinton said it's time to 'turn the page' in one of her stump speeches, or said she's 'fired up and ready to go,' I don't think anybody suggests that somehow she's not focused on the issues she's focused on," he said, adding he doubted Ohio or Wisconsin voters cared about the controversy.

Both camps tried to manage expectations about the contest. Clinton, a New York senator, had cut back her campaign schedule in the state but extended it again on Monday, and planned to campaign through the day.

Clinton touted her economic plans and Obama did the same during a stop in Ohio. Ohio and Texas vote on March 4 in must-win contests for Clinton as she tries to reverse Obama's momentum.

A new CNN poll showed a statistical dead heat in Texas, with Clinton holding a 50 percent to 48 percent edge on Obama -- well within the poll's margin of error.

(Additional reporting by Caren Bohan and Jason Szep; Editing by David Wiessler)

(To read more about the U.S. political campaign, visit Reuters "Tales from the Trail: 2008" online at blogs.reuters.com/trail08/)



More from Reuters

A Greenpeace activist dressed as one of the "Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse" rides outside the parliament building during a brief protest in Copenhagen December 13, 2009.   REUTERS/Christian Charisius

The face of climate protest

Protesters around the globe called for an end to global warming as climate talks in Copenhagen entered their sixth day.  Video 

    President Barack Obama (R) meets with financial services industry leaders in the Roosevelt Room of the White House in Washington December 14, 2009. REUTERS/Larry Downing

    Obama takes "fat cats" to task

    Backed by Americans outraged by multi-billion dollar bailouts, President Obama met with a dozen of Wall Street's top bankers in a bid to crack down on the so-called "fat cats" largely held responsible for the financial crisis.  Full Article 

    Lockheed Martin Chief Executive Robert Stevens answers a question during the Reuters Aerospace and Defense Summit in Washington December 14, 2009.  REUTERS/Molly Riley

    Lockheed eyes deals

    The future demands of cybersecurity make that sector one of many the aerospace giant sees as an acquisition target in the coming year.  Full Article