• Most Popular
  • Most Shared

UPDATE 1-Whole Foods denied hearing request in FTC fight

Fri Nov 21, 2008 7:10pm EST

Stocks

   

(Adds Whole Foods and other comment, background)

Stocks  |  Global Markets  |  Funds News  |  ETFs News  |  Private Capital

WASHINGTON, Nov 21 (Reuters) - Whole Foods Market Inc (WFMI.O) lost a bid on Friday for a larger panel of judges to review an appeals court decision that threw into question the legality of its completed merger with former rival Wild Oats.

The U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia said in a brief order that it would not revisit its July decision, which revived the Federal Trade Commission's effort to block premium grocer Whole Foods' effort to buy Wild Oats.

A three-judge panel ruled on July 29 that a district court judge had erred when he refused to grant an FTC request for an injunction to block the deal.

Whole Foods then asked for an "en banc" hearing, which would have involved all of the appeals court's judges.

Whole Foods spokeswoman Kate Lowery said that most of Wild Oats had already been absorbed into Whole Foods. "The vast majority of the stores have already been converted to Whole Foods," said Lowery.

The judges who heard the appeal also issued an amended opinion that retains the injunction against the merger going forward.

"The D.C. Circuit Panel's amended ... decision increases our confidence that the Whole Foods-Wild Oats merger will ultimately be upheld as lawful," said Paul Denis, an attorney for Whole Foods Market.

"Whole Foods Market expects to continue vigorously defending the administrative proceeding initiated by the FTC, even though we believe it is an unfair process and a violation of the company's due process rights," said Denis.

The FTC had no immediate comment.

"It would have been a win for them if they had got the en banc appeal. But they didn't," said a source familiar with the FTC's thinking.

The FTC tried to challenge the merger in 2007, but a federal district judge refused to issue a preliminary injunction stopping the merger. It was finalized in August 2007.

The commission is one of two agencies that assesses whether mergers violate antitrust law.

Earlier this month, private equity firm Green Equity Investors bought preferred shares in Whole Foods for $425 million, which could give the fund about a 17 percent stake in the company if converted into common shares. Whole Foods plans to use the proceeds to pay down debt and to maintain long-term liquidity amid a slowing economy that has hurt its business. (Reporting by Diane Bartz, editing by Gary Hill)



More from Reuters

Photo

Fox, Time Warner Cable ink temp deal to avoid blackout

NEW YORK (Reuters) - Time Warner Cable and News Corp's Fox Networks agreed to a brief extension of their current carriage contract on Thursday to avoid a blackout that would have prevented 13 million U.S. homes from seeing TV shows like "The Simpsons" and college and NFL football games.

A customer is served at a counter inside a foreign exchange store displaying a poster of various banknotes including the Chinese yuan or renminbi (RMB) in Hong Kong November 20, 2009. REUTERS/Bobby Yip
OUTLOOK 2010:

Be careful what you wish for

Pressure on China to loosen its grip on the yuan will continue but the U.S. should tread carefully. Here are five world market issues to watch.  Full Article 

Clients work out on machines at the Bally Total Fitness facility in Arvada, Colorado June 15, 2009.  REUTERS/Rick Wilking

Get real with resolutions

We make them and we break them: The secret to keeping them is to avoid the impossible dream.  Full Article