• Most Popular
  • Most Shared

MGA "still assessing" impact of Bratz ruling: CEO

LOS ANGELES
Thu Dec 4, 2008 7:43pm EST
Isaac Larian, Chief Executive Officer of MGA Entertainment speaks during the Reuters Retail and Apparel Summit at the Reuters building in New York September 26, 2005. REUTERS/Mike Segar

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - MGA Entertainment Inc is "still assessing" its next move, including whether to lay off staff, after a California judge barred the family-owned toy company from selling its popular Bratz doll, founder and Chief Executive Isaac Larian said on Thursday.

"Bratz is an extremely important part of our company and we are currently assessing the impact of this ruling," Larian told Reuters in an interview conducted by email.

Larian said MGA would appeal the order, issued late on Wednesday by U.S. District Judge Stephen Larson and stayed until next year, but was "open to any reasonable settlement" with rival Mattel Inc MAT.N, which won rights to the $1 billion-plus doll line in a copyright infringement trial earlier this year.

"But, it was relayed to me that Mattel wants it all," he wrote.

A Mattel spokeswoman declined to "speculate" on whether the toy giant, which makes the Barbie doll, would sell dolls and other products impounded by court order or if it would discontinue the line altogether.

Mattel sued MGA and former Barbie designer Carter Bryant for copyright infringement a few years after Barbie began losing market share to Bratz, launched in 2001, and after its attempt at making an edgier doll, called MyScene, failed.

A California jury ruled in Mattel's favor on its claims that Bryant had invented Bratz while under contract to Mattel and had illegally sold the property to MGA.

A second jury considering damages awarded Mattel just $10 million of the nearly $2 billion in it sought in damages for copyright infringement. The panel also awarded Mattel $90 million for damages related to other claims.

Unresolved by both juries was which company could continue to make the pouty lipped, urban chic dolls beloved of young girls who are Barbie's target market.

Larson approved Mattel's motion to stop MGA from selling the dolls or using the Bratz name after court-ordered talks to work out a royalty scheme or other settlement failed.

On Thursday, Larian was mum about whether he and his legal team would approach Mattel about reopening those talks: "That's the job of the court appointed settlement officer," he said.

As to whether the company will launch another fashion doll, Larian said MGA was "currently considering our options."

(Reporting by Gina Keating; editing by Richard Chang)



More from Reuters

Fannie, Freddie CEO pay gets regulator nod: report

(Reuters) - The U.S. housing regulator has approved pay packages for the chief executives of mortgage finance companies Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in the range of $4 million to $6 million, the Wall Street Journal said, citing people familiar with the matter.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) addresses senate health care legislation in a news conference at the US Capitol in Washington, December 19, 2009. REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst

Reid delivers on healthcare

Party-line Senate vote passes bill that would extend health coverage to tens of millions of uninsured Americans, but it's not law yet.  Full Article 

A security guard walks past cars in a Geely Automobile Holdings Ltd. factory in a Shanghai suburb September 28, 2006.REUTERS/Aly Song

China in auto power play

It might not shake up the industry just yet, but China's interest in Volvo and Saab is the start of something big in global autos.  Commentary | Video