(Adds comment from US congressman, reaction from trade expert,
comments on fast track)
By Antoni Slodkowski
TOKYO, April 10 Big gaps remain between the
United States and Japan after two days of talks on a bilateral
trade deal that is vital for a broader regional pact,
negotiators on both sides said on Thursday.
Japan and the United States are seeking a two-way trade
deal, regarded as a cornerstone of the U.S.-led Trans-Pacific
Partnership (TPP), before U.S. President Barack Obama travels to
Japan for an April 24-25 state visit.
The TPP, a 12-nation grouping that would stretch from Asia
to Latin America, is central to Obama's policy of expanding the
U.S. presence in Asia. Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has
touted it as a main element of his economic growth strategy.
"Our teams arrived expecting that the talks will be tough.
And our expectations have been met," U.S. Trade Representative
Michael Froman told reporters after talks with Japanese
Economics Minister Akira Amari.
"We made some progress over the last two days, but there are
still considerable differences on our positions in key issues."
Amari said progress had been made in some areas but
significant differences persisted and it was not possible to say
whether a basic deal could be reached by the summit.
"The U.S.-Japan summit is one important juncture, but it's
not a pre-set goal. We will continue the talks. It's the content
of negotiations that's important," he told reporters.
U.S. Republican Charles Boustany, a member of the House Ways
and Means Committee which has jurisdiction over trade, said it
was now up to one-on-one talks between Obama and Abe to break
"I am very hopeful that President Obama's visit to Japan at
the end of April will result in progress on market access talks
with Japan," he told a Washington International Trade
Without substantive progress toward a deal in time for
Obama's trip, the summit with Abe could end up more symbolism
than substance, experts said.
The United States wants Japan to open its rice, beef and
pork, dairy and sugar sectors - politically powerful sectors
that Japan's Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has vowed to defend.
"We understand the challenges. These negotiations relate to
fundamental reforms and the market opening of sectors in Japan
that have traditionally been closed," Froman said. "These (TPP)
opportunities are aligned with Japan's own economic reform
A Japanese government official told Reuters this week that
lowering farm tariffs was possible but scrapping them entirely -
the goal of the TPP framework - was not.
Japan also wants a timetable on U.S. promises to drop
tariffs of 2.5 percent on imports of passenger cars and 25
percent on light trucks.
BEEF TARIFF CUT?
The Nikkei business daily reported earlier that Japan was
considering slashing tariffs on U.S. beef imports to less than
10 percent from the current 38.5 percent.
That proposed cut would be much deeper than one negotiated
with Australia, which on Monday agreed to a trade deal with
Tokyo including a halving of the levy on frozen beef to 19.5
But trade experts said a cut in one tariff would not be
enough to win the support of the U.S. agriculture lobby, which
has a lot of influence in Congress.
"On its own that would not be sufficient, even tariff
elimination just on beef wouldn't be sufficient to get the
support of the agriculture sector," trade consultant Craig Thorn
said when asked about the Nikkei report.
"They .. are now seeing that TPP outcome in the broader
context, in the context of what it means for (U.S.-Europe trade
talks), what it means for future TPP expansion, what it means
for future WTO negotiations, that's all got to be factored in."
A spokesman for Australia's foreign affairs and trade
department said if Japan gave another country a better deal, a
review would automatically be triggered with the aim of giving
Australia equal market access.
As part of its proposal, Japan is also looking to impose
restrictions if U.S. beef imports soar as a result of a lowering
of the levy, the Nikkei said, without citing any sources.
Some experts say U.S. negotiators are at a disadvantage
because the White House does not have authority to fast track
agreements through Congress, given opposition by senior
Democrats to a bill laying the groundwork for a yes-or-no vote
Senate Finance Committee chairman Ron Wyden, a Democrat,
said this week he would work in coming weeks on amendments to a
proposal currently before Congress to address concerns about a
lack of transparency in the TPP and other negotiations.
Boustany said it was too late to start over on a fast-track
bill given TPP talks were at a critical stage, but said
Republicans would "possibly" be open to some changes.
(Writing by Antoni Slodkowski and Linda Sieg; additional
reporting by Colin Packham in Sydney; Editing by Richard Pullin,
Robert Birsel and Tom Brown)