UPDATE 2-Alabama lawmakers say Pentagon tanker rules unfair

Tue Oct 27, 2009 5:26pm EDT
 
[-] Text [+]

* Alabama lawmakers demand meeting with Sec'y Gates

* Senator says tanker bidding "tilted toward Boeing"

* Alabama would benefit if Northrop wins contract (Adds details from letter, quotes from news conference, byline)

By Andrea Shalal-Esa

WASHINGTON, Oct 27 (Reuters) - Alabama lawmakers blasted the Pentagon's bidding rules for a multibillion dollar contract to replace the Air Force's aerial refueling fleet, saying the procedure unfairly favors Boeing (BA.N).

"I believe it's already tilted toward Boeing. I believe it's a sham," Senator Richard Shelby, a Republican, told reporters at a news conference on Tuesday.

Alabama stands to gain jobs if rival Northrop Grumman (NOC.N) and its partner, Airbus parent EADS (EAD.PA), win the contract because much of the final assembly work would be done in that state.

Shelby and other lawmakers sent Defense Secretary Robert Gates a letter saying the new competition rules were fundamentally flawed and did not meet his objective of a "best value competition that is fair, open and transparent."

The lawmakers also criticized an increase in the number of contract requirements to 373 from 37.

Such a detailed list "makes a mockery of the capability that our warfighters truly value by equating water flow in the toilet with fuel flow in the refueling boom," they said.

They demanded a meeting with Gates to discuss their concerns before the Pentagon releases a final version of the bidding rules at the end of November.

Boeing and Northrop have been poring over a draft request for proposals issued by the Air Force on Sept. 25.

Northrop and EADS have already raised questions about pricing data the Air Force gave to Boeing, saying it gave Boeing an unfair advantage in the new competition.

The Pentagon denies that, but told Northrop in a recent letter that it asked Boeing to release its comparable data to Northrop, but Boeing declined.

Northrop has scheduled a news conference Wednesday to share its views about the rules for the tanker competition.

Boeing Chief Executive James McNerney last week took aim at the Air Force for exempting a trade dispute between Brussels and Washington over alleged aircraft subsidies, a factor he said could harm Boeing's chances in the bidding.  Continued...

 

Featured Broker sponsored link

Commentary

James Pethokoukis
Why Geithner will stay

One residual from Timothy Geithner's rough confirmation back in January -- "Turbo Tax Tim" and all that -- is that his political position is probably a bit more precarious than that of the typical newbie treasury secretary.  Blog