SNAP ANALYSIS: Limited Geneva deal wins Iran sanctions respite

Thu Oct 1, 2009 2:40pm EDT
 
[-] Text [+]

By Mark Heinrich

VIENNA (Reuters) - Iran and world powers said on Thursday they had productive talks to ease a stalemate over Iranian nuclear ambitions, agreeing on limited transparency gestures by Tehran and another meeting later this month.

Iran's pledge to give U.N. inspectors access in the coming weeks to a second uranium enrichment site that Western powers said was hidden for three years, and plans for follow-up talks, bought Tehran a reprieve from tougher sanctions in the near future.

That is as long as Iran carries out its promise of more openness without obfuscating delays common in the past, and as long as no more concealed sites of proliferation concern, or any concrete evidence of attempts to develop atomic bombs, come to light.

The talks did not yield a date for the International Atomic Energy Agency to visit the newly revealed enrichment site.

The longer it takes to get IAEA inspectors in there, the more the West will suspect efforts to "sanitize" the site of anything that might suggest it was geared to produce material for nuclear weapons, not fuel for electricity as Iran says.

Still, last week's revelation of the site gave Iran a chance to display cooperation by announcing access for the IAEA -- without addressing the overriding U.N. demand for it to curb all enrichment activity to allay mistrust in its nuclear intentions.

Iran repeated after the talks that it would not submit to limits on its sovereign right to develop nuclear energy.

But Western powers will continue to push Iran for weightier gestures of nuclear restraint and transparency soon.

These will include a freeze on expansion of enrichment capacity and unfettered IAEA access to verify that no sites oriented to nuclear weapons development lurk anywhere in the vast, security-cloaked country.

The IAEA also wants design documentation for the Qom plant and all other planned nuclear sites, something Iran has been withholding for two years in retaliation for initial sanctions.

If Iran continues to rule out such broader confidence-building moves, the United States, Britain, France and Germany are likely to pursue broader United Nations sanctions in earnest.

LACK OF GLOBAL WILL FOR SANCTIONS

The West will calculate that there is no more time to waste, fearing Iran is orchestrating "talks for talks' sake" to stockpile enriched uranium and modernize its nuclear infrastructure to approach nuclear weapons capacity.

Tougher sanctions mooted would target Iran's huge oil and gas sector; firms that insure shipments to Iran; export credits; more Iranian banks and firms run by the Revolutionary Guards; and Iran's top leaders by denying them travel visas.

But the chances of making harsher sanctions work suffer from a lack of global will to enforce them, given Russian and Chinese reluctance, and the risk they will harm ordinary Iranians, reuniting them behind a weakened Islamic leadership.  Continued...

 

More News

TIMELINE: Iran's nuclear programme
Thursday, 1 Oct 2009 05:28am EDT 
Iran broke law by not declaring atom site: ElBaradei
Wednesday, 30 Sep 2009 07:58am EDT 
Geneva talks on Iran may fizzle, more sanctions loom
Tuesday, 29 Sep 2009 08:59am EDT 
FACTBOX: Options for tougher sanctions against Iran
Tuesday, 29 Sep 2009 08:40am EDT 

Editor's Choice

A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours.  Slideshow 

Most Popular on Reuters

  • Articles
  • Video