ANALYSTS' VIEW: Israel-Syria talks

Wed May 21, 2008 9:36am EDT
 
[-] Text [+]

(Reuters) - Following are comments from analysts after Israel and Syria said in surprise announcements on Wednesday they were conducting indirect peace talks with Turkish mediation.

EZZEDIN CHOUKRI-FISHERE, DIRECTOR, ARAB-ISRAELI PROJECT AT

THE INTERNATIONAL CRISIS GROUP

"It is significant in many ways. It is significant for the Israeli-Syrian track and for other issues in the region. As we said repeatedly, an engagement with Syria is very important if you want ... the Palestinian-Israeli negotiations to continue in a smooth way.

"I think a deal will take time. I will be surprised if a deal comes out quickly from their meetings. The two countries have a number of issues they have to talk about and agree on before a deal becomes possible. The issues are not only the Golan but include Syrian support to Hezbollah and Hamas. These issues are not easy to resolve. I expect the talks to take some time before a breakthrough to happen.

"You need the U.S. administration to be on board for any deal to proceed. The current U.S. administration is very hostile to the Syrian regime. So I would think that probably you still need the next administration to come to office for this effort to come near completion. But it is a very positive development they are talking to each other at this level at this time. The Turkish mediation deserves both support and praise."

EYAL ZISSER, DIRECTOR OF THE MOSHE DAYAN CENTRE FOR MIDDLE

EASTERN AND AFRICAN STUDIES AT TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY,

"This is a major development. For years Syria refused to consider even the resumption of negotiations between Israel and Syria because there was always a very clear Syrian condition that Israel should commit itself, before the resumption of negotiations, to a full withdrawal from the Golan Heights. They probably got it.

"Probably Prime Minister Olmert was ready to commit himself to give Syria what it wanted so much. This is why they moved ahead.

"Now there are indirect talks, and in the future resumption of formal talks will be announced.

"Theoretically, they can reach a peace agreement because the main obstacle, or one of the main obstacles was the issue of the Golan Heights. And if Prime Minister Olmert indeed commits himself to a complete Israeli withdrawal, then this obstacle has been removed and we can reach an agreement."

MOSHE MAOZ, MIDDLE EAST STUDIES PROFESSOR, HEBREW UNIVERSITY

IN JERUSALEM

"This is good news but I am skeptical about the results. U.S. President Bush is against the talks and so were other officials in the U.S.

"Olmert doesn't have the majority support of the Israeli parliament and public support for him is low at this time. Seventy percent of Israelis are against returning the Golan Heights even with a peace agreement.  Continued...

 

Analysis

People walk on an overhead bridge in front of a shopping mall on a hazy day in Beijing, June 18, 2009. REUTERS/Jason Lee
Jump-starting climate debate

President Obama talks in China are highly unlikely they will produce a definitive plan to tackle global warming, but both sides hope to set the tone for Copenhagen.  Full Article | Full Coverage 

Editor's Choice

A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours.   Slideshow 

Most Popular on Reuters

  • Articles
  • Video
Shrimps boats are seen at the coastal area of Bayou La Batre, Alabama November 10, 2009.  REUTERS/Carlos Barria
Shrimpers struggle

Fishermen like Steve Patronas struggle to make a living, but high costs, low prices for their catches and competition from countries like Vietnam or China are putting many of them out of business and choking off their way of life.  Blog | Video